Document
SECURITY INFORMATIO N .. ..
Copy RM L52I1 1
NACA
RESEARCH MEMORANDU .M
FIRST LANDING OF BE LL X -2 RESEARCH AIRP LANE By Richard E . Day and Wendell H. Stillw ell Langley Aeronautical Laboratory Langley Field, Va.
CLASSIFIED DOCUMENT ThlB material conta1ns lnlor mation ailecUng the National Defense of Ille Unlled State. wltll!n Ill e meanlng of the espionage laws , Title 18, U.S.C ., Sees, 793 and 794, the transmission or revel.a.Uon of whic h in any manner to unauthorized person is prohibIted by law.
NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE
FOR AERONAUTICS
WASHINGTON October 1, 19 52 NACA RM L52I11 SECRET NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR AERONAUTICS RESEARCH MEMORANDUM FIRST LANDING OF BELL X-2 RESEARCH AIRPLANE By Richard E. Day and Wendell H. Stillwell SUMMARY The Bell X-2 supersonic research airplane is equipped with a skid main landing gear and a n ose wheel. Pending completio n of the rocket engine, glide flights are being performed to determine low-speed handling qualities of the airplane and the landing characteristics with the skid- type landing gear. The present paper presents data obtained during the approach and landing of the X-2 airplane on its first flight .
The approach speed was about 215 miles per hour and touchdown was made at 142 miles per hour, indicated airspeed, with a normal -force coef- ficient of 0.77. Immediately on contact of the skid the airplane pitched down and the nose-wheel support assembly failed. The deceleration during most of the ground run was between 0.4g and 0.8g. The total distance of the ground run was 1,010 feet.
INTRODUCTION The Bell X-2 supersonic research airplane has been constructed as part of the joint Air Force - Navy - National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics high -speed flight research program. The X-2 airplane is intended to investigate the characteristics of swept-wing airplanes at high supersonic speeds . The airplane has several unconventional features among which are the circular-arc wing section profile and the skid-type landing gear.
Pending the completion of the rocket engine for the X-2 airplane, glide flights are being performed by the Bell Aircraft Corp. These flights are for the purpose of determining the landing characteristics and flight characteristics at low speeds.
The first glide flight was performed June 27, 1952. The airplane was launched from the Boeing B-50 mother airplane at an altitude of 31,500 feet and made a 9-minute flight terminated by a landing on the dry lake bed.
SECRET SECRET NACA RM L52Ill The purpose of the present paper is to document the approach and la n ding data of the first flight. Other data recorded during the flight are now being analyzed .
SYMBOLS hp pressure altitude, ft Vi indicated airspeed, mph Oe elevator deflection, deg O at total aileron deflection, deg O r rudder deflection, deg Fe elevator force, lb Fa aileron force, lb AZ normal acceleration, g units AX longitudinal acceleration, g units Ay lateral acceleration, g units
e pitchi ng angular velocity, radians/sec
~ rolling angular velocity, radians/sec .
W yawing angular velocity, radians/sec a angle of attack, deg ~ angle of sideslip, deg g acceleration due to gravity, ft/sec AIRPLANE AND INSTRUMENTATION The X- 2 airplane is a low - wing single-place research airplane having 40 sweep of the quarter chord and 10 - percent-thick circular-arc airfoil sections normal to the quarter chord . For the flight reported herein the rocket motor was not installed . The geometric characteristics of the SECRET ----~~--- NACA RM L52I11 SECRET airplane are presented in table I and a sketch of the airplane is shown as fi g ure 1. The leading-edge flaps were deflected 15 for the entire flight.
The landi"ng gear of this airplane consists of a main landing skid, nose wheel, and wing-tip skids. A drawing of the landing-gear arrange- ment is presented as figure 2 and a photograph of the airplane in the normal ground attitude is shown as figure 3 .
The airplane was instrumented to record the following quantities on internal recording instruments: Altitude Airspeed Normal, transverse, and longitudinal acceleration Rolling angular velocity Pitching angular velocity Yawing angular velocity Elevator angle Aileron angle Stabilizer angle Rudder angle Flap angles Elevator sti ck force Aileron stick force Sideslip angle Angle of attack The accelerometer is lo c ated 123 inches forward of the center of gravity of the airplane.
In addition to the internal instrumentation, a modified SCR 584 radar set was employed to obtain the airplane flight path and landing trajectory.
All i n strumentation was synchronized by a commo n timer.
TESTS, RESULTS, AND DISCUSSION The landing appr oach pattern as recorded by radar is shown in fig- ure 4. The winds at the ground level were about 5 miles per hour and were from the south-southwest. The approach was started on the downwind leg opposite the touchd own point at geometric altitude of 6,500 feet and indicated airspeed of 223 miles per hour with trailing-edge flaps up.
The speed was approximately 220 miles per hour, indicated airspeed, during the downwind and base legs. The trailing-edge flaps were lowered 28 at 210 miles per hour and an altitude of 1,000 feet in the final approach. The flight path was n ot obtained below an altitude of 200 feet because of intervening obstacles.
SECRET NACA RM L52I11 SECRET Time histories of the measured quantities during the flaps-down portion of the approa ch and landing are shown in figure 5. The speed in the approach was reduced gradually from 20 6 miles per hour at time zero to 183 miles per hour at time 26 seconds. After time 26 seconds the speed decreased more rapidly as the pilot held the airplane of f until the contact occurred at indicated airspeed of 14 2 miles per hour and with a normal - force coefficient of 0 . 77. Integration of the accel- erometer records indicated that vertical velocities were less than 5 feet per second near and at touchdown. It was expected that the pilot would be able to control the pitching at contact. However, the pitchi ng at touchdow n was uncontrollable and the airplane experie n ced a peak longi- tudi n al deceleration, exceeding the 1 . 75g range of the recorder. The airpla ne developed a maximum pitching velo c ity of -0.45 radian per second resulting in about a 3.8g accelerati on on the no se gear at co n tact. The airplane slid along on the main skid and nose wheel leavi ng a track the width of the skid and appr o ximately l~ inches deep in the lake bed. A sketch of the skid mar ks on the lake is shown as figure 6 . At time 39 . 5 seconds the pilot applied left aileron control causing the airpla ne to roll to the left and despite corrective aileron control applied at time 41 . 5 seconds, the left wing tip contacted the ground at the point 764 feet from touchdown . This co nta ct was comparatively light but the drag on the tip yawed the airplane ab o u~ 14 0. The right wing-tip skid then struck the ground heavily and broke off. The airplane yawed about 35 to the right and the left tip contacted again. The left skid was be nt inward at this impact and the leading edge of the wing dug into the lake bed and the airplane came to a stop . The total distance covered on the gr o und was 1,010 feet . Inspe c ti on of the nose wheel revealed that the support assembly had failed during the landing. It was indi c ated from remains of the yaw vane found on the lake bed and from comments of the chase pilot that the nose wheel collapsed immedi&tely after ground c ontact.
Figure 7 is a photograph of the skid marks on the lake and the final re sting position of the airplane . The marks made by the wing-tip skids are clearly visible in the ph o tograph .
Langley Aer o nauti c al Labo rat ory, National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, Langley Field, Va.
SECRET NACA RM L52Ill SECRET TABLE I PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF BELL X-2 AIRPLANE Wing: Area, sq ft .. 260.4 Span, ft . '. 32.3 Aspect ratio 4.0 Taper ratio .
0.5 40.0 Sweep at 0.25 chord, deg Airfoil section 10-percent-thick circular-arc Incide n ce: Root, deg .
3·0 Tip, deg 3·0 Dihedral, deg 3·0 Aileron: Area, sq ft 10.8 Travel, deg ±l7.0 Flap, trailing edge: Area (total), sq ft 21.2 Travel, deg . . . . .
Flap, leading edge: Area (total), sq ft 12.2 Travel, deg .
Horizontal tail: Area, sq ft .
43.7 Span, ft 12.8 Aspect ratio 3.75 Sweep at 0.25 chord, deg 40.0 Airfoil section . NACA 65-008 Elevator: Area, sq ft 8.4 Travel: Up, deg . 15 Down, deg Stabilizer: Travel: Leading edge up, deg Leading edge down, deg SECRET 6 SECRET NACA RM L521ll TABLE 1.- Concluded PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF BELL X- 2 AIRPLANE Vertical tail: Area, excluding dorsal, sq ft 38.6 Sweep of leading edge, deg 40.6 Airfoil section: Root NACA 27-010 Tip ..... . NACA 27 -00 8 Fuselage: Length, ft 37.8 Fineness ratio 9.5 Airplane weight, lb 10,337 Center-of-gravity location, percent M.A.C. 22.62 SECRET NACA RM L52111 SECRET 154-----........;
t
//0 ~ -------- 387.31 Fig ure 1 .- T hree- v iew drawing of t he Bell X-2 research airp lan e. All dimensions are in inches.
SECRET co (f.l t:z:j o ~
t-:3 s; o ~ ~ t-' f\) H f--J f--J
\J1 ------, -~---
~
~
installation
__
.
-----
____
, 30315
5h
=}
nose-wheel ___ I -6-8-
__
~
and airplane.
Z69.0Z -- research landing-skid
~
X-2 the Bell
=
the showing on .5
~
5fa
Drawing 2.-
o
Figure
Sia
---~~~--4~~_
~
gJ t-:3 (f) I:'j o gJ
~ :t> ~ l:"""l f\) H f--' f--' 1-'3 \,()
Vl
-
-
:: ~..:
-
.
"':" 6675· U,lUafOltC£ ground
L-7'6119
~~ normal .- in A- airplane
-'"
research X-2 attitude.
----
~ the
-
..:..
'" of Photograph .- Figure
--
.
~ (f) ~
~
10 SECRET NACA RM L521ll ~1'1 1lr;(ed itlllfly'llY o ______ ___ _ 1 'i . =2 15 mph
~cont (J ct
/ ____ North E dS! e dge of .Ropfrs dry J(Jlf'e PJ(Jll vIew 4- ~ 3
'"
~ :::s ......, Side VIew -i::; ........
""
T!m~ sec (for fir(. 5)
/ 5 0
\ 15 10 L f/o ps dowfJ
!t---
0 - 0 I 2 3 1- 5 6 7
Olst!1T1Ce,) yd
Figure 4.- Landing approach pattern of the Bell X-2 research airplane.
SECRET NACA RM L'52I11 SECRET ~
~~~~~kfkkF I I;J I f# I I I I ~
<s'~~~I±1 I I I I I I] I I I I IB
'\....
~ ~ ' ~O:CI I I I I l't-h I I I I I I I
~ \:) ~~ ~~
~ ~ ~ ~f I I I I ¢ f1 I I I I I I I I I
S),~
~ :§- ~I [ I I I I I eE I I I I I I I
~ ~ 1-[ ~IA-",-.!Il.-..-' b i.4.-1 -,-I ~I ""'---'----"---------~-L----'--___'___Il
~~ ~ ~ :'~[:I:=:=:I=Ax=f7::I:==r=:I=:===::::::: ~ ~
r I
EI
'" ~I +
1'"1 I J; 1 (ep; I 6r
I 14 I I I I I I I 1 f I I I
! ~:[ I I ! I I I I I I I I I 1 I 11
30 00
-
;-- r---.
--....
-
l- I-- r----,....
,{).j
-
~
r;t-6rotllJd level. ZZ.50 ff 4 /0 IZ 14 If; TIme, I] 5e c Figure 5.- Time history of landing of Bell X-2 research airplane.
Stabilizer setting, 2.2 leading edge down; weight, 10,337 pounds.
SECRET 12 SECRET NACA RM L52111
I I I I I I I L di l I I I I I
I I I I I I I Idel I I I I I I
/ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~0 ~ 1 ~~~~~~ L ~ I ~~ I ~A~0 ~1 ~~ 1:;:'
~ °1 I :fAx I I I
~ / ~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~EI~~=t~~I~1 31A,Az~\J~I~3~E~1 ~
1 1 119' ::.t I~ 1 __ I 1 I ~ ZOOt
1 IlljllEI#HE
~ /60
I 1 1 1
I I I I <t z.~oo ~ -
-
r--- I I I I
-
~ tS..
r:6nJt/x' level.- ZZ50 II t--I----
---
;; 200 Iv /(j ZO zz. Z4 ZV i'.t3 30 31- lime , tJ .sec Figure 5. - Co nt inued.
SEC REI' NACA RM 152111 . SE CRE T 13 ~ - ~ ~ Z
~ ~ ~k-bd---UJJ-k Va ne hrohn I I I I I 1
.~ 4~~ ~~~m-~'-'- ~-.-.-'-r, tS ~ :§- Z I---+-+-f--+--+-+-++--+-+-t--I--t-+-+-+--+---i 0 ~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~-7~~~ "- ~. Z ~ ~ o ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~= ~ ~ ~V) ~
~1 ~ ~I I I I I I! I I I I I Illtl Llp I
~~ /~~~~~~~,-,-~~~~~~ ~ ~:§- 0 I I 1 1 I Q; -<>- L .1.-1 .!-.- I .J......- I .Lo...- l "--"" I LE""",,-B ....,...,1.)"--'1 I
I J I I ]
i+-- IflI /lol c OIl/ac t
! }HILl±llllll lllll
I Nose boom J Irt/c K grot/nd I
I I I I
I I I I I I ~ I ,Grot/ad leve /. :; Z,Z 50 (I I I I I ZZOO 3Z 34 30 Jt5 40 4 Z 44 4~ ~ Time " I; sec, Figure 5. - C onc lud e d .
SE C RET SECRET NACA RM L52111
o /00 ZOO
I I I I I ,C on/oel
5c ale" rt
I
I
I
I I
I I Norl/;- soul/; I
I /t//J wOf!
I
I I I
I
I
I
I
Polh oT /lOSB w"?ee/orfer leTr w//J~ f/p duq l/Jrt:J grot/ad Le 1'1 wl/Jq tip , /Skld morks F igure 6 .- Ground path of the Bell X-2 research airplane .
SE CHEr
I
--~
s; 0 ~ ~ t-t f\) H I-' I-'
(j) tx:J o ~ f-3 V1 I-' V1 of L-7b120 ~~ position resting final and airplane.
marks skid research the X-2 of the Photograph 7.- Figure
(j) tx:J ~
z > n > t. ~ ;- ~ , , .... '" ...,
.. ... 0 ~ '" '"
,