Appendix A
Appendix A Model Coordinates NASA/TP--2000-210031 27 A1 .--BUSINESS JET AIRFOIL COORDINATES X/C Z/C X/C Z/C 1.0000_ -0.00033 i 0.00000 i _-0.00392 ....
0.82500 _ -0.01321 - ! 0.00050! -0.00006 0.80000 -0.01506 ' 0.00100 0.00137 --0177500 LL -0.01691 i 0.00150 0.00246 0_0-0.01876 _- - _.002_0337 0.00300 0.00471 0.72500 i -0.02061 0.7_0000] :o_ .... 0;00400' 0.00594.
0.67500 -0.02427 [ o oo5o6_ dio6691
0.650001-0.02610_ 0.00750 0.0087(
_6250o_:o.62788, old16ooi_ .... 0.00999
0.60000 -0.02953 i 0.01250! 0.01108 0.57500i-0.03108 0.01500 0.01212 0.52500 -0.03383 I 0.02500 ! 0.01547 0.50000i-0.03501i 0_03000_ 0101694
o_7_O_-bSJ3597_ - o.o4ooo i 0.o1956
0.45000 -0.03666 !0.05000! 0.02184 0.42500 -0.03706 0.06000 0.02388 0.40000! -0.03718, :0.075001 0.02670 0.37500 -0.03709 - _ .j 0.10000! 0.03066 0.350001-0.03681i _0.12500 0.03404 0.325001 -0.03643 i &.15000J 0.03698 0.30000 -0.03598'-- .I0.17500L0.03951 0.27500i -0.035451 0.20000 0.0416!
-0.03482_ i0.2250_ 0.04359 0.22500 -0.03410 i0:250000.0_04520 -0.03322i 0.27500 0.04654 o.2oooo i 0.175001 -0.03218L_ _ 0.30000 i 0.04771 0.15000 -0.03094! L0.32500! 0.04862 0.12500 i -0.02969_ .... _ 0.35000:0.04924 0.10000_ -0.02833 i 0.37500 0.04951 0.07500_ -0.02672i _00 T- 0.04956 0.06000 -0.02551, _0.425001 0.04942 0.05000 -0.02455i 0.45000 0.04915 0.04000 -0.02338' _0.47500_ 0.04863 0.03000 -0.02185 |O_50000 Oib478-9 ----1 o.o25ool-o.o2o9o i 0.52500 0.0468_ 0.02000i-0.01977+___0.55000 i 0.04555 0.01500 -0.01833 _ 10.57500! 0.04404 0.01250i-0.01748 _0.60000 0.04233 0.01000!-0.01656 i 0.62500 0.04042 0100750-01015471_ _di6gO00_ 0.03837 10.67500! 0.00500 -0.01386 0.0362: 0.00400-0.01299T 0.70000 0.033_)-7 0.00300 -0.01192i 0.72500i 0.03154 0.00200-0.01054 L0.750()0 _ 0.02901 !0.77500 0.02629 0.00150 !:0__0_0_9671 0.00100[-0.008621 0.80000; 0.0234( 0.00050 -0.007231 0.82500' 0.02058 !1-000004 0.00033 0.00000i-0.003921 28 NASA/TP--2000-210031 A2.--COMMERCIAL TRANSPORT AIRFOIL COORDINATES x/c ; z/c yac I z/c X/C Z/C _ 4 X/C i Z/C t 0.035223 0.029423 0.635551' 0.043928 _1.00000010.008649 - 0.349370-0.033927 0.041185 0.031511 0.648984i 0.042839 0.990740! 0.007881 . 0.335871 _ -0.033921 0.047581 0.033515- 0.662418-01041710: 0.980977- 0.007064 0.322380L -0.033840 0.054426 0.035429 _0.675855_0.040544 0.9707240.006200: 0.3089101-0.033732 0.9600030.005287: 0.2954-6_585 0.061730 0.037255 0.689294 0.039347 ........... I 0.069503 0.038992 0.702733 0.038120 0.948844 0.004332 0.2820571 -0.033411 _ . f + 0040642 !0.716173 O.036867 0.937286 0.0033331 0.2686951 -0.033220 0.077750 • _ _.___ 2 0.925373 0.002286! 0.255396 i -0.033018 0.086474 0.042203 i 0.729612_ 0.03559 0_131-500.001195! 0.2_0-0.032802 0_095671_ii_43677_ _ 0.743047_ 0.034298 0.900662 0.000006_ 0.2290701-0.032567 i0.105330 0.0450661 _0.7564760.032989 0.887952 -0.001095! 0.216091!-0.032306 i0.1154360.046372:0.76989510.031670 -0.032010_ I 0.1259640.047594! _01783298] -61030345 0:875058.0.862015 -0.003489:0'002281 0.1906420"203272-0_1-6691 _013688Y_ 0_48731_ " 0.796_ 6_029018 %1848852 -0.004715, 0.178234 -0.031278! 101i4817ii 0.0_- -0_1062710_027689 0.835594 -0.005957, 0.166084 -0.030817! 0.159781_0.050754' 0.823333 0.026365 .......... ± - 0.171677! 0.051649 _ 10.836583 0.025048 -0.030289 .0.822262-0.007211_ + 0.154228i -0.029705 0.808873-0.008473 0.142703 0.183822i 0.052471" _ 0.849759_ 0.023742 0.795441-0.009737 0.1315471 -0.029071 0.196182_ 0.052321 _0.862842 0.022453 -0.0283881 0.2087221 0.053863 10.875806 0.021182 0.781977 i -0.011000 0.1207951 0.768490 -0.012261 0.1104771-0.0276581 0.221416i 0.054424 i 0.888621" 01019933 0-754987 --0.013517 .... b 100617_ -0.026881i 0.2342370.054900 T 0.90i25410.018711 0.7_,1-474 -(3J314_3! - _09123_-63_Q_:_471"76 0._276 !0.913667_0..()1Y521 %.:f27956- '0.015cj94! -0_082-328 -0.025204 i 01260202- 0.055525" _ 0.9:_5817_0..-0_0 017144,3_4-01017206_ .... O_6!-0.024309 q O.2_2,_. O..055658_i O.93,7660'.-0-015266 0.7009121-0.018395 0.065958 0.949149 i 0.014211 -0.023373! i0.286525 0.0557191 i0.299796_ 0.055754i 0.960241i -01013201 0.687390 ! -0.019556 0.058473 -0.022407 0.673870-0.020686 0.051434 -0.021387 0.31312310.055776_ .0.970898 _ 0.012236 -0.020314 0326492i 0.055788' , 0.981090_ 0.011321 0.660352 _ -0.021783 0.044823 -0.019194 0.339889i 0.055780 _0.990794 _ 0.010457 0.646836_ -0.022843_ _ 0.038616i -0.0180271 0.353305 _ 0.055740 i0.999998, 0.009644 0.633332-0.023862 _ 0.0327921 -00167971 i0.366733! 0.055654 i -- .....
0.619810 -0.024838 0.027333 I -010154671 I0.380170 0_55512 ! !----- O_60630-0_ -0.025769; 0.022232!
-0.0140011 -_--0.393614_01055318_--- -- 0.59-2791- :0_26652i _ 0.0174901 0_57928f '0.027486i i 6.0_07_ -0.010609 0A20517 0.0548i9 T - - _ ....
-0:0-28267'i 0009 90
0.552262-0.028998 _ 0.005522i -0.0085581 ; 51011 1111ji iiii
0.538750:-0.029676 0.002576 -0.006619 _ 0.447428 i 0.054154 i -0.003357 _0.460880i 0.053752 0.525237 ! -0.030300 0.000617 i 0.0000021 0.511720 -0.030871 -0.0002781 0.474331i 0.053300_ _ ....
0.002726! i0.487778 0.052799 i 0.498201 -0.031389 0.000330 i 0.484678-0.031856 0.000330!
0.002726_ ..... _O.0.501_2210..052248 0.471153 -0.032270 0.001411!
o.0057231 10.514662 0.0516451 i 0.457624 -0.032635 0.0031231 0.008853 _ -_0.528100 0.050990!
0.005434 0.444092 -0.032952 0.01_07 _ i0.541535 0.050282i _ -__.
0.0_-781 _ 10.554968 0.430558i -0.033221 0.0083211 0.049523 ........
0.4170261 -0.033445 0 011711i 0.017531 0.568399i 0.048712. _ .......
0.047851 i 0.4304871-0.033624 0.015544i 0.020162 0.581829 • _ 0.046940 0.022656 0.595259 0.389952 -0.033760 0.019824 i 0.608689 0.045981 i 0.376420. -0.033855 0.024542 i 0.025013 0.622119 0.0449771 0.362894 -0.033910i 0.029678! 0.027260 NASA/TP--2000-210031 29 A3.--GENERAL AVIATION AIRFOIL COORDINATES x/c i z/c i I x/c ! z/c i x/c i z/c i i x/c z/c -1-.0OO00_-0_2-751: [0.47869i-0._985 r 0._86, 0.01082, _ 0.548380.0781:/' 0.9947"I -0.02723 0.46171_ 41 ' " -_ -O,0596 ! i 0.00653_ 6_ ! 0156558, 0_-_0 0.98894 _ -0.026951 _ 0.44476! -0 ,0_5 93 5-" l 0.0-1154! ().-020_66 i 0,5826_ 0.0752---a, 0.98271-0.02669 0.42788 -0.0589ZL L 0.0176_ _7_21 i 0.599671 0.97602-0.02645 10.41107 -0.05851i ; 002450_ 0.02836- 10._3 _ 0.96886 -0.02624 i 0.39435 _ .0.05796i I 0_-,03202! 0.()-3177_ 0.63322_ 0.06926 0.96123 -0.02604 _-0,37775 -0_.05732_ i 0.04009_ 0.03506! 0,_41 ().06682 0.95316:-o.o25871 i 0.36128 -0.05661 _ 0,048-691 _38:23_ 0_-6605 -0,06414 0.94463 i --0..0_ ,--C)-134495 ; ..... _ i- - + --'-- -:--- -0.05583 _-0.05782 0.04127 i 0.68211i 0.06115 0.93565_-0.02562' i0.32-879" _ __0.0674_5 0.04418_-_ 6-_ 0-[6_-77 _31 _- /0.312821 -0.05405! 0.0775_ 0_4_6 _ O_ -0-_05394 0.91638 -0,02_! 0.29704! _ _i{38816 _ 0.049_- _ 01=72845i 0.04963 -(_.90611 -0.02565 ! 0.28148i' -0.05203 i _9-921- &052181-- _- 0;64;,_)1
0.89542!-o.o2586 i (_2_ -0.050941 i 0_1107()i _-_ 0_
088432 -0.0262110.25108 _ 0.87283 -0.04980' L0.1226i-! ():_J_ 0.7714910.034-84 -0.02671 i0.236274 -0.04860_ !£)-:'1349_ 0.0592-6 - ()_:78_ 0-.02979 0_6_696-0.02739 i /0.221_ / -0._:_6! _54766T 0106_,Y W 0179_6d-&02488 0.84872 -0.02825 i !0.20751!-0.0_07 ! i 0.16076__0-:0636_ _ 0.81__20;16
o8361_3 L -0.02930 i 0.19358 -()_ _ 0_-7_3 ()_06-566_ ' 0.824611 0_01-567
0.823191 -0.03053 0.17998 -0.04335! 0.18805! 0.06763 i 0.83719i 0.01142 0.80993 -0.03196 0.16672 -0.04193! 0.20221! __ 0.849470.00744 0.79635 -0.03359i 0.15381 -0.04047 0.21671 o.o712810.8614_ 0.00372 -0.03548 014126 -0.03896_ 0.23151 0.07294 0.87308! 0.00027 0.78249 I ! [ .....
0.76838-0,03772! 0.12909!-0.03742! i 0.24661 0.07449 0.88438-0.00293 _o.754o4 i -0.04036 , 0.11730: I -0.03584+ _ 0.26198 0.07591 ! 0.89533i-0.00587 0._-0.04333 0,105921 -0,03422 i 0.27762 0.07720 0.90591:-0,00859 0.078_ 0.91611 i -0.0110{ 0.72468,-0.04641 _:00_4493_-0.03255, 0.29351 0.70959[ -0.04929 -0.03084 0.30962 0_7 _)-< (3_ 92591_ -0.01337 0.694181 -0.05170 i 0.07426i -0.02909 i 0.32594_ 0.0803-0! _-(316:3530 i -0_ -0.02731!
0.678491 -0.05357 i 0.06457 I 0.34245_ 0.08107 i 0.94426 -0_.0173-7 -0.02549; 0.66255 -0.055011 I 0.055331
-0 59130.o8169
I 0.952801 -0.01912 -0.646411 -()_05617 [ 0_4655, -0.02363 i ! 0.96090[ -0.02070 -_ 0.37597 0.08216!
06 o,o! -0.02169L -
0.3929410.08248 _ 0.96856:-0.02211 -0.01966!
0.41002! 0.08265:_ 0.97577i -0.02338
-005865 !
0,59703 -0-,05798 ! .... !0030431 -0.01749 0.42720: 0.08267 i 0:98252_F -0.02451 i -0.01515i 0.580311 -005917 - i O_016-35 0.44445 i 0.08252 . 0.98881 z -0.02550 -0.012571 0.56350 -0.059551 0.01016 0.46175_ 0.08221 i 0.99464 -0.02636 0.54661 -0.0598210.00475!
-0.00949 I
c)_ ,79o91 0.08175
-0.00516i 0.49645 0.08112 0.52967 -0.05997 i 0.00104i I 0.51379i 0.08032 0.51269, -O.._ _ 0.00000 0.000000 ().49569i -0_,5998! - 0.00069 o.o6_3_ i 0.53111! 0.07934 30 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Appendix B
Appendix B Pressure Tap and Thermocouple Coordinates NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 31 B1 .--BUSINESS JET PRESSURE TAP LOCATIONS [Y measured from tunnel centerline] No. X/C Y/C Z/C X,_)_ Y (in_ Z _in) r - i I I - _ ....
1 ! 0.9700 -0.08331-0.0026 i 34.920, -3.0001 -0.094
3 0.9000'-0.0833-0.0077, 32.400 -3.65_2-77 28.800 I -3.000 -0.544
--_-_ _.7_33 _-0102_25200 -3.000i-0.806
6 i 0.6000-0.0833i-0.0295 i 21.600 -3.000 -1.062 7 0-_-0 08331 -0 03501 1_00_ -3.0.000] -1.260 -- I , .... "_+ "- _---'_4 ----_ .......
8 0.4000 -0.0833,-0.0372 14.400 -3.000! -1.339 9 0.3000-0.08331-0.0360 10.800 -3.000, -1.2961
__0001 -0.0833 -0.0_-_ -3.000 -11951
- 11 _. 0.10-00! -0.0833:70.028_4_13--6()011 i3._ ii--_ 12 0.0800, -0 0833, -0 0271 2.880 -3 000 -0.9761
___ 3 ! 0.06001 -0.o8#3_ -0 0255--__21_..60_ :3 00_.__0, -019i81
l 14 _ 0.0400 -0.0833,-0.0233__1.440 --3.000 ! -0.839 / 15_..i 0.0200, -0 0833 -0.0197 i _0.720_ -3.0oo_ -o:z09 [ 16 +oo_-0.08331 -o.o165 o.360_-3.oo0 i -0.594 0.0040:0.0833:0_o128--o_4 -3.oo6! -o.461 -()_0005_ _-0.0833_ -013073_ - 0_18_0-'- _3 [ 21 0.0100 -0.0833 0.010_0_60 -3.#0-- O_:J60
:00833! 0.0121 00 0.436
23 0.0200 -0.0833 0,0138 0.720 -3,000 0,497 24 0.0300i -0.0833i 0.0170 1,080_ -3 000, 0 612-
2_-6_ -O.O_3:_t 0.019_F- 14_5t -3-000_ -0-706 -
26 0105001-0.0833 o_i_o + -3.000 _ O:_ss
2.160 -3.000 0-86£}1 27 0.0600' -0.08333 0.0239'
2520_%.00d -&_51
28_io_.o833 616257 i
2:88 -- iooot-
30 0.0900'-0.0833 0.0290 3.246 -3.000 _ ! 3_ 0.1000!-_ 0.0307!
3.6001 -3.000_ 1.105 "32 -_0.1500_ -0.0833 0.0370 5.400 -3.(]00___ "11332 33 0.2000 -0.08331 0.0417i 7.200 -3.000 1.501
34___2500i -0.0833_45_2 9.000_ -3_00_.627
35 I 0,30001 -0.0833_ 0.0476 10.800 -3.000 1,714 36 0.4000' -0.0833 0.0496 14,400: -3.000 1.786 38-I 0.6000 -0.O_3i 0_4_' 39 -! 0.7000 _0_08-_ 0.0340 ,_ '! [X-0! lj2-2-4 40 0.8000,-0.0833! 0.0234i 28.80_ -3.000 0.842
41 -I o_ooo_ -o.o_o-o-1_9_32._6L -_.o6Qi_.4_
42 0.93001-0.0833 0.0090 33.480-3.0001 0.324 43_ 0.9700 -0.0833 0.0038i 34.920 -3.000' 0.137 0 r 1 .......
44 11 000_ -0.0833] .0000_3_6.000_ -_3:000+ ...... 0.000 -- ! .... I Thermocouple Locations 0_ Y/C Z/C i X, i(in) Y, (in) Z, (i_ --1 0-()_-0_. 600_ 3.000 -1.-022 2 0.0500 _ :0.0241 1.80-6 ] 3.000 ---0.868 _O.lOOOi 0.08331 0.0307! 3.60043__3.000 1.104
4 , o.o2 sW oZ o, 6
oloooo iooo÷ o
32 NASA/TP--2000-210031 B2.--COMMERCIAL TRANSPORT PRESSURE TAP LOCATIONS No. i X/C . Y/C _ Z/C . X,(in.) i Y, (in.) i Z, (in.)
1 0.9700 -0.0833 0.0061 34.920 -3.000. 0.221 2 _ 0.9278-0.08334 0.0027 33.400 -3.000 _ 0.097 3 0.9000 -0.0833 0.0000 32.400 -3.000 0.000 + .... ---- - 4 ;0.8000 -0.0833 -0.0093 28.800 -3.000 -0.335 5 0.7000 -0.0833 -0.0185 25.200 -3.000 -0.665 + .... -- 6 0.6000 -0.0833 -0.0262 21.600 -3.000 -0.943 7_ 0.5000- -0.0833 -(}))313 _ 18.000 -3.000 -1.128 -8 , 0.4000_-0_0833-0.0337 L 14.4007--3.000 _ -1.212 9 0.3000-0.0833-0.0336 10.800:-3.000 -1.211 100.2000 -0.0833 -0.0319 7.200 -3.000 -1.149 11 0.1000 -0.0833 -0.0268 3.600 -3.000' -0.966 12 0.0800 -0.0833 -0.0250 2.880 -3.000 -0.898 13 " 0.0600-0.0833 -0.0226- 2.160 _ -3.000" -0.814 14 0.0400 -0.0833 -0.0194 1.440 -3.000 -0.700 15 0.0200 -0.0833 -0.0148 0.720 -3.000: -0.532 16 + 0.0i00 -0.0833 --010110 0.360 -3.000:-0.396 17 - 0.0-000- -0.()833 -0.0003 0.000; -3.000 -0.010 t .....
18 0.0050-0.0833 0.0113 * 0.180--_ 0.408 19 0.0100 -0.0_8.33 0.0161 0.360 -3.000i 0.581 20 0.0150+-0.0833 0.0198 0.540_ __-3000_-+__0.712 21 . 0.0200-0.0833 0.0227 L 0.720 -3.000i 0.819 22 0.0300,-0.0833 0.0274 1_.0801 -3_0()! 0.986 23 0_0400 -0.0833 0.0311_ 1 440 -3.000 1.120 24 0.0500_-_0.0833 0.0342 1.800 -3.000_i 1.231 25 0.0600-0.0833 0.0368 2.1601-3.000; 1.326 26 .... (3.0--700 -0.0833 0.039i 2.520_--3.000. 1.407 27 _ 0.0_.800 --0.0833- 0.0410_ ....2.880_ -3.000 _ 1.478 28 0.0900-0.0833 0.0428 3.240 -3.000 1.540 29 0.100011-0.08331 0.0443-- 3.600 _ -3D.O()OT 1.595 30 0.1250 -0.0833 0.0475 4.500 -3.000 1.709 31 0.1500 -0.0833- 0.0499 5.400 -3.000 _ 1.798 32 0.1750 -0.0833 0.0519 6.300 -3.000 1.867 33 0.2000 -0.0833- 0.0534- 7.200- -3.0-00- 1.923 34 0.2500 -0.0833 0.0553 9.000 -3.000 1.992 35 0.3000 -0.0833 0.0558 10.800 -3.000 2.007 36 0.4000 -0.0833 0.0552 14.400 -3.000 1.988 37 0.5000 -0.0833 0.0523 18.000 -3.000 1.883 38 0.6000 -0.0833 0.0466 21.600 -3.000 1.678 39 0.7000- -0.0833 0.0384 25.200 -3.000 1.381 40 0.8000 -0.0833 0.0287 28.800 -3.000 1.033 ....... t 41 0.9000-0.0833 0.0188 32.400 -3.000 0.678, ,_,2 - 0.9300" -0.0833_ 0.0160" 33.480 -3.000 0.575' 43 0.9700-0.0833- 0.0123 34.920 -3D00-- 0.443 44 " 1.0000--0.0833 0.0087-- 36.000 -3.000- 0.311 _ Thermoc0uple Locatigns _ _ _ X/C Y/C Z/C X. (in.) Y,(in:) _Z,(in.)
1 0.1000 0.0833 -0.0284 3.600 3.000 -1.022 2 0.0500 0.0833 -0.0241 1.800 3.000 -0.868 3 0.1000 0.0833 -0.0307 3.600 3.000 -1.104 4 0.0500 0.0833 -0.0218 1.800 3.000 -0.786 5 0.0000 0.0833 0.0000 0.000 3.000 0_000 6 0.0000 -0.2500 0.0000 0.000 -9.000 0.000 NASA/TP--2000-210031 33 B3.--GENERAL AVIATION PRESSURE TAP LOCATIONS [Y measured from tunnel centerline] No. I X/C ! Y/C Z/C i X, (.in.) i Y, (in.) i Z_i_n.)_ i 1" 0.59703-0.08333 i -0.05-865_-2"1.493_ -3.000, -2.1121 -:2-- _9_4i_ -.0_.1_ 38_89j -0.03255 3.418 -5.000 -1,1721 3 : 0.00475 -0.16111-0.00949_ 0.171_-5,800_0.342 4 I 0.00000 -0.16667 i 0_0OO()0/ O_05_--6_0001 O_000 --5-t 0.00_ -0.17222 i 0.01601"- 0_235_ -6.2.2-00 -5.000i 1.786 6 0.088161 -0.13889 0.04962: 3.174 7 0.59967_ 0,07346_ 21 ._ General Aviat on Thermocouple Locations| ................ + X/C ! Y/C : Z/C _-X,_in.) _ Y, _in_ _ Z, (in.l
1 5._oo_ 5__6-0oo _ o.ooooo/-oooo7q8.o6o! 5 6o6 _
2 0.599671 0.50000 ! 0.07346 21.588 18.000 2.645 34 NASA/TP 2000-210031 B4.--GENERAL AVIATION (LTPT) PRESSURE TAP LOCATIONS [Baseline leading edge and main body] No. i x/c y/c z/c I x, in. i y, in. _ z, in.
t 09700 013074 -002630 34.92014.707 i -0.947
2 i 0.950001--0_12575--616_034.200: 4.527 -0.929 3 : 0.900000.11328-0.02570 q_ 32.400 4.078-0.925- - 4 0.85000__0.10082 -6:()28_ 130.600 3.629_-1.015_ 5 ' 0.82500__0..09459 -0.0305329.700 3.405 -1.099 6 " 0.80000 0.08835 -0.03320 28.800 3.181:-1.195 7 0.78750 0.08524 -0.03500 28.350 3.068! -1.260 " 6.77500T 0.08212 -0.0367027.900 2.956-1.321 9 " 0.76250! 0.07900 -0.03890 27.450 2.844 -1.400 2.732 -1.480 10 0.75000 0.07589-0.0411027.000 2.620 -1.573 11 _ 0_73750_--01(J7277 _ -0.0437026.550_ 2.507 -1.676- 120.725000.06965-0.04640:26.100 2.395 -1.750 1_ 0.7__!290 ___0;06654 -0.04860 25.65d -1.832 14 0.70000 0.06342 -0.05090 25.200 2.283 -1.940 15- 0.67500" 0.0-5719-0.0539024.300 2.059 -2.016 16 i 016-50000.05971 -0.0560023.400 2.150 -2.070: 17_O_6_0---0106594 -0.0575022.500 2.374 -2.110 180.60000 0.07218 -0.0588021.600 2.598 19 ! 0.55000 0.08464 -0.05980 19.800 3.047 -2.153 3.496 -2.160!
20 0.50000 0.09711 -0.06000 18.000 -2.142 21 0.45000 0.10958 -0.05950i 16.200 3.945 22 0.40000 0.12204 -0.05820 14.400 4.394 23 0.35000 0.13451, -0.05610 12.6001 4.842 _-2.020 i -1.9191 24 0.30000 0.13035 -0.05330 10.800 4.693
--l:f86*
25 " 0.25000 0.117891 -0.04970 9.000 4.244 I 26 0.20000 0.10542' -0.04540' 7.200i 3.795 -1.6341 Baseline -1.4401 Leading_ 27 0.15000 0.09296 -0.04000, 5.4001 3.346 28 0.12500 0.08672 -0.03670 4.5001 3.122 -1.3211Ed e9£__ -1.2021 29_ 0:10_000i 0.08049 -0.033401 3.600] 2.898 30 _ 0.0_80000.0_7550 -0.03080 _ 2:8 _ 2.718 -1.1091 31 ! 0.0700010.07301 -0.02890 2.520 2.628-1.040!
32!0.06000 0.07052 -0.02650 2.160_ 2.539---0.954 T _[ 0.55600! 0_06802_-0_024401 1.8001 2.449 -0.878 - 3410.04000 0.06553-0.02210 1.440J 2.359 -0.796 35 i 0.03000 0.06304_-0.01960! 1.080 2.269 -0.706 36- 0.02500! 0.06179 -0.01810_0.900N__ 2.224 -b_ ....
37_ 0.02000 0.0605 -0.01650 0.7201 2.180 -0.594 38_O.61506 O]O5Cj30 _ -0.01470 0.5401 2.135 -0.529 39 0_0-10-00 _ 0.05805 -0.01260 b_360__ 2.090 -0.454 40 0.00500 0.05680-0.00990 0_-80_ 2.045--0.3156- 41 0.00220 0.05618-0.00590 0.079 + 2.022-0.212 0_0472.001-0.068 42 0.00010 0.05558 -0.00190 43 - 0_0510--0_05558 0.00220 0.004: 2.001! 0.0791 44 -- 0.00_2120 0.05618 0.00830
0.079 2.o22 _
45 0.00500 0.05680 0.01440 0.180 2.045 0.5181
0.360 2.001 0.702i 46 _ 0.0-10()0_ 0.05558 0.01950 f 47 " 0.0_0_--0_05930 0.02310 0.540 2.135 0.832 i 48 0.02000 0.06054 0.02610 0.720 2.180: 0.940_ 0.900 2.224_ 1.0331 49 0.02500i 0.06179 0.02870 -50_ 0.03000 0.06304 0.03100_ 1.080 2.269:1.116 i .__ 51 0.04000 0.0655310.03510J_440 2.359 1.264_ 52_ 0.05000 0.06802! 0.03870|1.800 2.449 1.393 53 i 0.06000 _ 0.07052 0.04200 2.160 2.539 1.512 54 i 0.07000 --0.07301 0.045001 2.520 --2.628 1.620 55 [ 0.08000 0.07550 0.04800, 2.880 2.718 1.728 End 56 i 0.10000 0.08049 0.05240 3.600 2.898 1.886BaSeline 57 0.12500 0.08672 0.05720' 4.500 3.1221 2.0591Leadin& 58 0.15000 0.09296 0.06190 5.400 3.346] 2.228!Edge NASA/TP--2000-210031 35 B4.--Continued.
[Baseline leading edge and main body] I 59 I 0.17500 0.09794_ 0.0656_ 6:300! 3.526_ _2.362' 60 0.20000 0.1041_ 0.06930 7.200, 3.750i--2.495 61 0.22500 0.11165 0.__..1-0-0 i 4.020"--_-2..596 _ - 0_07490- 91(_00" 4.244 2.696
62-t 0.25000 F 011789r
0.27500! 0.12412i 63 0.07690 9.900 4.468! 2.768i , 4.693! 2.840!
0.30000' 0.13035' 0.07890 10.800 0.32500 0.13659i 0.08020! 111700t 4.917 2.887 0.13451 E66v .
0.35000 0.08140j 12.600 4.842, 2.930i 0.12828!
167 o.375oo 0.08200_ 13500,- 4_8__2.9_J
68 0.40000 0.12204 6-i08260_- 1-_,_-400 i 4_394 2.9741 69_ 0.42500 0.115811 0.08255 15.300 / _69i zeFE 70 0-.4_0 0.10958 i 0.08250_ l&:)-O0 3.945 2.970 71 0.47500 _ 0.10334 0.08f8_1-60-3_720-! 2.945i 72 0.50000J 0.09711 6108100_1&.00-0! ......3-,¢§6 _- 2.916 73 ' 0.5250_ 0.09081 0.07960 i 18.900 3.272i 2.866_ 74 _00 _ 0.08464 0.07810 19.80-01 3.047_ 2181;2! -- 75 0.57500 0.07841" 0.07580 20.700 i 2.._ _2_72{) ?
76 i 0.60000 0.07211 0.07350 21.600_ 2_598_2__.6_ -- 77 ! 0.62500 0.06594 0.07040 22.500 2.374 2.534 78 0.65000 0.05971 o.o668ol 23.400___ _.2 1501 2.4051 790.67500 0.05719 0.062601 _24.300 i 2.059 2.254!
0.05730: 25.200[ 2.283 8o i o.7oooo 0.063421 2.063 ..... 0.06654 o.o54ooi 25.650 2.395i 1.944i 81 ' 0.71250 0.0696? 0_050_8__0 26.100-]_ _2.507]_1T829! -- 82 i 0.72500_ 83 i 0.73750 0.07277 0.04670 _0-|- 2.620_-1_68;I _ - -- 84 ! 0.75000 0.07589 0.04260 i 27.000|-2_.7-3'2- _4_ ....
85 _ 0.76250 0.07900 0.03800 27.450' 2.844! 1.368i 86 0.77500 0,08212 0.03350 27.900 2.956! 1.206_ 87 0.78750_ 0.08524i 0.02890, 28.350i 3.068 _ 1.0401 88 0.80000 i 0.0883_ 0.024401 28.8001 3.1811 0.878, 8_- 6._550 / _ 0.o158oi 29.700 3.405 i 0.569 90 , 0.85000! 0.1008_ 0.00730] 30600j 3.629 0.263 91 I 0.90000j 0.11328 4.078-0.256_ -0.00710! 32.400 92 _ 0.12575 -0.01850 i -0.666 34 200, 4.527 0.95000_ _ 0.13074 -0.022401 34.920 4.707 -0.8061 94 0.70000! 0.25000i 2.063_ .....
0.05730 25.200 9.000 95 i 0.70000 0.33333 0_5730! 27._n_nO 12.000 2.063 96 i 0.70000! 0.38889 O.05_00____0 2.063i 15.000 2.0631 0.41667 0.0573_ 25.200 98 0.70000 i 0.430561 15.5001 2.0631 0.05_0_ 2_.20E 16.000: 2.063'
0.057325.2
_0 i 0.70000 0.44444 , 0.45833 16.500 2.063 o.700001 0.05730' 25.200I 17.0001 2.063 _00 ! 0.47222 0.05730] 25.200 102 0.70000 i 0.48611 17_051 2_0631 0.05730 i 25.200¢ 103 i 0.70000 -0.05556_ -2.000_ 2.063 0.057301 25_200_ 104_ 0.700001 -0.16667 -6.000 2.063 0.05730 _L 0.05730_ 25.2001 -9.000 2.063j ......
105 0.700001 -0.25000 106 0.70000! -0.33333 107 0.70000'-0.38889 0.0573_2_ -12.000-2.063! ---- t _05730_&.200_ -1_ 2.063! --- 0 70000 -0.41667i 0.05730; 25.2501-_15.000 2_b6-3_-
#
-0.430561 _-i 0.70000 0.057301 25.200_-1-5_00_2.063_
-_0' 0.70000 -0.44444! o.o573o I 25.20_116-_00_2.0_
111_ o.7oooo-o.45833
0.057301 25.200_-116_0_2:063L .... _ 0.057301 25.200|-17000 2063 1_ 0.700001 -0.4722_ 113 : 0.70000 -0.4861_ 0._5730 i 25.20_ -17.500, 2.063 i 114 i 1.00000 0.2500_ -0.027511 36.00_ ...... §._0 -0.990] 115 0.33333 1.00000 -0.02751_Q00 12.00_--00:99-0 116 1.000001 0.416671-0_2751_3&-.000_;000!-0.990 i 36 NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 B4.--Continued.
[Baseline leading edge and main body] 117 1.00000 0.47222 -0.02751 36.000_ 17_.000 -0.990 `118 7 1.00000 -0.05556 -0.02751 36.000! -2.000 -0.990 119 I 1.00000 -0.16667, -0.0_2751 36.000 t -6.000 -0.990 ];_()-_ 1.00000 -0.25000 -0.02751 36.000i -9.000 -0.990_- - 121 1.00000 -0.33333-0.02751 36.000_-12.000 -0.990 ----- b 122 ; 1.00000 -0.41667 -0.02751 36.0001-15.000-0.990!
123 1.00000 -0_4722:_ -0.02751, 36.000!-17.000 -0.990 B4.--Continued.
[Leading edge for ice shape 621] No. x/c y/c _ z/c x, in. _, in. z, in.
26 0.18721:0.0-83-331 -0.04417 6_7401 3.000T :1.590 27 70.;15944 0.083_0-z_`111 .... 5.740T - 3_0001 -11480 28 ! _1_3167_ 01-08:]33'-0.03778 4_740_ :31_0_ "1.360 2g _ 0.10390- 0.08333! -0.03444 3.740_ 3.0001 -1.240 3(3 _ 0076101 0.08333-0.03028 2.7401 3.000 t -1.090 31 _0_05528_ 0.08333 -0.02611 1.990_ 31000 :0194_0 • - -4 32 _ 0.04139 0.08333 -0.02278 1.490 3.000 -0.820 33 : 0.02839T 0.08333"-0.02000 1.022" 3.000!-0.720 34_0.01536_ 0.08333_0_;1611 _ - 0.553 3.0001 -0.580 35 0.00494! 0.08333 -0.01139 0.178 3.000 -0.410 36 _-0_00i19_0.083:]3- 0.00()28! -01(343" 31000_ 0.01(3 3_.(30072! 0.08:333- b.51_-_i(3:26__ 3_000_0_(3 38 _ 0.00550 _ 0.08333 0:018333 0.198 3.000. 0.660 39 _0.01417i 0.08333 0.02389 0.510 3.000 0.860 40 i 0.02458! 0.08333 0.02917--0_885- 3.000 1.050 41_ _ (].03500_ 0.08333 __0.03361- -1.260_ --3.000_1:210 42 0.04889 0.08333 0.03833 1.760 3.000 1.380 - -43_ 0.06278- 0.08333 _ ()_6_4_ 2.260 3.000 1.540 44 0.08014- 0.08333 0.04778 2.885 3.000 1.720 45 0.10097 0.08333 0.05278 3.635 3.000 `11900 46 0.12180 0.08333 0.05694 4.385 3.000 2.050 --47 -- 0.;14264-- D.O8:]:]_6b_5_1:35_ :3.00(3 2_]90 NASA/TP--2000- 210031 37 B4.--Continued.
[Leading edge for ice shape 622] No. _ . x/c .__y/c _ __Z/C ' x, in. _y, in. _,z, in.
260.18721 0.08333 i 6.740 ,q_-3._0-1.5-90 _7-_ -0.04417 i i_ 0.15944 0.08333!-0.041111 5.740 3.000i-1.480 28 i 0.13167! 0.08333 -0.03778 4.7777_-- 3.000t-1.360 29 0.10390i 0.08333-0.03722 i 3.740 3.000-1.340
30 i 0.07610 _.08333-_31_9! Z(4_ i _._oo_-_._i_
31 ] 0.05528 0.08333 -0.02667 1 9_ 3000 -0960 .... L . ..... ! __ t.....
32 0.03444 0.08333 -0.02306 _1.2.40 Z 3.000:-0.830 ,_ 0.01708J 0.08333-0.01917! 0.615 i 3.000 i -0.690 3 0.00180! 0.08333 -0.01333 ....... 0:06_5__ 3.0()0_--0.48__ _ 35 -0.00464 0.08333 i 0.00028 -0.167 3.000! 0.01_ 36 i -0.002301 0.08333i 0.01000-0.083i 3.000 0.360 3"7 0.002361 0.083331 0i0i944" O_O85_ 3.00-0__ 38 0.01417 0.08333 0.02500 0.510 3.000 _ 0.900 39 0.02200 0.08333! 0.02917 0.792: 3.000 1.050 40 ' 0.02980! 0.08333' 0.03278 1.073[ 3.000i__I ;I.18_0 -_41 ! 0.0384_ 0.08333 0.03611 1.385! 3.000! 1.300 _.42 0.04889 i 0.08333! 0.038331 1.760 3.000 1.3801 i --- ' I -_ -- - 43 i 0.059301 0.08333 0.04167j 2.135_. 3.000 1._ 44!0.08014 ! _0_0_i3333 0_04'750 ,' 2.885_31000_i:T1_] 45 0.100971 _1-01052501 31635 31(3C)01 _46_ 0A-21_ O..08333! 0_ _4_3-8-5- 3_000 i 2.050 I 47 i 0.14125i 0.08333 0.06056 5.085i 3.0001 2.1801 B4.--Concluded.
[Leading edge for ice shape 623]
y, in. i z, in. I
No. i x/c _ _ z/c x, in.
--2.66_-3.6o_ 1
2610.17680 0.0833-01-0_04444--6.365 27 0.14900 0.08330! -0.04139 5.364 0.08330-0.03472 3.614 28 W 0.10040!
2.99_ -_
_L o:o_
0.083301 -0.0305_ 2_491_
30 ! 0_6201
l
o -o
0.08330 ! -0.0-3056. -0._ 0
31 -0.000_ 2.9991 -1.1oo 1
0.08330 -0.028611 -0.198 32 _ -0_._550_ 2._030J 33 -0.01160!
o.%_;:_6 i -_o2_o-0r '6;418
.... 21999 -0.9OC)] 34 -0.01880
_99_: o.o_ I
0.08-330 _ 0.02889 -0.6ff
35-0.01880i
-2.99C-_
.... 2.996!--1.1001
0.0_330i 0.030_ c0.4_ 36 ] -0.01360 i
37 _ -0.00840!
0.083-301 0._ -0:302 2.9991 --1_100'
0.08330! _02861 _6 38 0.02460: 2.999 1.030 - i A9--i 0.04110 0_08330 0.03556 !- 1.48(] 2.999. 1.280 40 0_()6020_ 0.0_8330i 0_()419__ - :2.1-67 2.999i 1.510 41 0.08010, 0108330! 0.04_ 2.884 21999 1.710
_ 0.10100 0.08330 0.05250 3.63( 2.999 1.890
--43' 0.12530 0.083301 0.05750 i 4.511--2.999_-2.070 44 0.13920 0.08330[ 0.06000 i 5._1 r---2__999_ 2_60" 38 NAS A/TP---2000-210031
Appendix C
Appendix C
Test Matrices
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 39
C1 .--COMPLETED BUSINESS JET (1st ENTRY) TEST MATRIX Run Mach Airspd Attitude Tt Tt Ts i Ts MVD LWC . LWC Par Pwat / Spray ; Notes " i I 7- _ _ -- _ ....... .3, _ .... -3 -_ _ _ f "_ - No. No, kts) deslredl F , C _ F , C : um (g/m) i (g/m) si sd _ rnn ' ; i : ' I desired act 072595.01 0.28 175 6.0' 30.6 -0.8 23.0 -5.0! 20_.54() + 0,540 -_- 17.0----371_- 610i 072595.02 0.28 F -_ --, --_ ..... _ _ ---._ _ ........
0725,9510-31 0.28! 175: 60 30:61 -0,8 23:0 _ -,5.0 20 0_4_2,540_ - 17.0i 37.9! 6.01repeat of 072595.01
, , 175i 6.0 i 306 -0.8L_23_.0-5.0 20_ 0.54_0.540 17.0]-37.9 22.5! ..... -
072595.04 i 0.28' 175_ 6.0__ 30.6! -0.8_ 23.0 -5.0, 20 0.540 0540 : 170 379 450
072695.011 0.28 1751 6.0! 28.9 -1.7 21.4i -5.91 201 0,300 0.405-[ 10.3 18.6i 4.4
072695.02 028 L 175 80 289 L -18, 212 -60, 20 0.300 0:3: -i8 ; 7i
072695.03 i 0.28! 175 6.0_ 28.9! -1.7i 21.4' -5.9, 201 0.300 0.405 10.3 18.6 ! 33.3 , , t _ .... , ............
072695.04! 0.28 175 6.0 21.4, -5.9 14.0_0_ 201 0.430 0.430_ 11.6 21.6 6.0 07 6 5.05 0.28 175 6.0, 0:430ii.E ....
072795.01 0.281 175i 6o1_ 2141.I _&91 14.01-10.0 2-0-_-&430 0430 116i .... 2i_ 2;_5_
6.0_ 21.41 -5.91 14.0!-10.0 15_ 0.600 0.600__60.0] 66.7 6.0! 072795.02i 0.28 175!
I :072795.03! 0.28 175 I 6.0 21.4 -5.9 14.0:-10.0 i 15 I 0.600 0.600+60.0 66.7 22.5 -- 15 O-60_ 0-.60(),-- 60.0" -66,7 i 45.0_ .......... 072795,04_ 0.28 175 6.0 21.4 -6.0 14,0 ]-10.01 20 0.300 _- (Z-_3i 1816! 44i 072795.05! 0._ 175 6.0 12.31 -t10 5,0 -1_ 072795.060.281 175 t _6._ 123! -11,0i 50 -15.0 20 , 0.3000,405 10,31 18.6 33.3:mold
07_2895.02 i 0.39i 2501 1.529.7 -1,3 ! 15.3 -9.3 t 15 0.600 0.500 i 71.2 82.7 3.9
07289503 0.39 250 1.5 29.7 -1.3 151 15 0.600 4 0.500 i 71.2 82._ 7,2
.... 8.2 .......... 072895.04 0.39 i 250 1.5
072895.05 0.391 250 _.5 _ 28,0 -Z-2! 1&7 -10.2 ! 20_ 0.430 1 0.430 18.2_ 41.8i 3,01 . 13.7 -10.2 20 I 0,430 0.430 1 4i[8 _ 61()" 072895_()6 0.39 250- 1_5"_2-8_0_ _2.2] i3:_ :'10:_ 20! 0.540 0.540 29.1 75.1_ 3._+-- 072895.07 0.39 / 250 1.5 28 0 -2 2, 13 7 -10.2 20 0 540 0 540 29 1 75 1 6 0 072895.08 0.391-175 6.0 12:3_-11.0_ 5.01-1_.0 20--0:_I0 01540 ! 17.'0_ 3719 _ --45.%_mold ......
073195.01 0_-39-! 250 _ 1_9! -73F---_---20_0.300-_ 0.310 - i0.3: 18.5' Z9_ .......
073195.02t r 0.3_ T 250 1,5_ 18.9 i -7.31 4.7-15.1-- 20_.3()0- 0,31010,3- 18-15"- 5'8_ .....
073195.03i (3-128 175 _- 6.0- 12.3- -_-E_15_0 _ 20"-(}_300_ 0.405 I 10 3 1_}-6-- 161_ ........
-0T3%5.0_ _ 0_8 "?T_' ...._.0_ _2.3 -ST.o_ _ -15.01 20--0540t0.540_5_ 3-/# 60|
080195.01_ 0.39 250 +1 1.5_ 9.5: -1Z5! -4.3- -2-0_2 40 T--()]1-()0_0.410 i 1016 32.6 i 0.7' -.....
080195.02! 0.39 250 1.5 9.5!-12.5 -4.3_-20.2 i 40 0.100 i0.4101 10.6 32.6__ 1.5: 080195_030.28_ 175 60 678_-t4.0:0_4_-18.0 20 0.540 _,0.5351-i-7_ _19_ 6.0! ........
080195.04i, o.28 I 175 4,oi 6.8i -14.0i -0,4 -18.0__ 20 0.540 0,535 17.0_ - 3719 60!r_(38-0_ 080195.051 0.28 175 4.0 68 -14,0! -0.4 -18.0 40 0.540 0,535 , 10.6 32.6 6.0
o8o195.o6 o.34 212 4.o 6,8 -14.0 -3.7+-19.9 4o %1_4_--0.535-_ 10.6 32.6_ _.oi
080195.07 0.34 212 4.0 6.81 -14.0, -3.71 -1_ 20 0.5'_0 0.540 !-_17.0, 37.9i ..... 61_ ...........
6:q4- 61 -0.4i -18.0 40 0.540 0.540 10.6i 32.6 6.0
080195.08 0.28 I 175 I 6.0i 6.87 -14.04 -0.4 -18.0 40 0.100 0.535 10.6 32.6 4.2
080195.09 0.28 1751 ...... _---- ....
080295.01 I 0.28 1751 6.0' 30.6 -0.8 23.0 -5.0 20 0340 0.540 17.0 37.9, 120 -5.0 20 0.540 i 0.540_ 37 91- 22 5 080295.02 ' 0.28 175 : 4.0 30.6! -0.8 23.0 i ......................... " ....
I ......... _---_ I :i - 080295,04 0.28 175 4.0i 3-(316_ --(3181 23.0_ -5.0 20 0.540 _0.540 17.0_ 37.9 22.5
o8o295.o5 i 0.34 212 4-(3_-3.9!-i410 -10.0 20= 0.430 0.430 11.6 i 21.6' 22.5
080295.06' 0.28 175 - 4.0 30.6_ -0.8 23.0i -5.0 i 20 _ 0.540 0.540 17.0 37.9 22.5imold ....
-_ 2.500 0.750 28.9 t - , .......
__ - i5 9,9_ lO.OJ 080395.01 0.39 250 1.5, ---8 71 20_ 080395.02 0.39 250 1.51 30.8 -0:7.___16.4_ 2.250 1.250 68.0__ 57.5_. --54_.: - 080395.03 0.28 175 6.0_ 28.4i -2_01-20.9' _ 15i 2.500 1.000 28.319,8 15.01 080-39-5_04J 0.28 175 6.0l 24.2 -4.4 16.7 -8.5 20/ 2.250 1.600 70.8 61.3" 8.4"-- .......
, , 1 080395.05 0.39 250 1.5 18.8 i -7.4 4.7i-15.2i 15 i 2500 0750 I 289 99i 100 080395.06 0.39 L 250 1.5 18.8, -7.4 4.7i -15.2i 20 2.250 _ 1.250 i 68.0 57.5, 5.4 6.0_ 12.3j _.04 -15.0+ 20 2.255 -i7600 _ _7_--8.4_;__ 080395.07 0.28 i 080495.0_ 0.28_ 175 6.0 -18.0 -27.8i -24.9' -31.6 160 0.830 0.830 5.0 50.0!
080495.02 0.28
175 _-_;0 -1810i _ :2_9--_6-.6 _ 0.830 0.830 _ 50_ 6.0
175 .....-6.0' 12.21 -1_ ...... _-___ 160 _` 0.830 ' 0.830 j 5.0- _ 20_---
080495.03 0.28 i I 4 _ "-_ _ ' i 080495.04! 0.28' 175_ .0_ 12.2j -11.0__ 4.9,-15.0 160 0.830 L 0.830 5.0_--5010 20.0 0804_i05 ! 0.28 175_--6_ 30_6 -0-_i _ _51d 16{3- i 0.8300.830 5.01 5()__ 080495.06 0.28;
175: -6.0_%0.6 i -0.8 _ 23T0- -_-.o _ 2o 1 0.540 0.540 _ 37_ 22.5[mo_
40 NASA/TP--2000-210031
C2.--COMPLETED BUSINESS JET (2nd ENTRY) TEST MATRIX Run Mach Airspd Attitude Tt i Tt Ts ; Ts MVD LWC LWC Pair Pwat i Spray . Notes No. _ No. - _ desired (F)_+_) {F) i-(_n?_**(glm!_i (g/m3)_ !PsLq[± (psid) i (min) .
l _ desired act
201 028 175 60 300 -08 224 -50 2o 0300, 040_iq3! 1961 441
202 . 0.28+ 175 60 30.0! -0,8 22.4 -5.0 20 0.540; 0.540 17.0 37.91 2.0.
202r- _0,28 175 !_ 60, 3_.0.0 _ -0,8 22.4_ -5.0 20__ 0.540 i 0.540: 17.0 37.91 2.0repeat 202m_ 0.28 175 ! 6,O_ 30.0_ -0.8 22.4 -50 20 0.540, 0.540 17.0j 37.9_ 2.0mold 203 0.28 175 6,0 30.0' -0,8 22.4: -5.0 20 0.5401 0.540 17.0 37.91 6.0 204 0.28. 175. 6,0 30.0 -0,8 22.4 -5,0 20 0.540i 0.540 17.0 37.9_ 22.5 205q 0.28/ 175. 6.0 20.8 -5.9 13.4-10.0 40 0.100_ 0.535__ 10.6+ 3_2.6: 1.1.
205r 0.28i 175 60 208 -59 134 -100 40 01001 0.535 10.6 32.6 1.!repeat 206_028 i 175 6:0 220.8:_-5.9 13.4 -10.0 40 0.100 0.535 10.#_ 326 4.2 207 L 0.28 ! 175 , 6.0 20.8 -5.9 13.4. _-10.0 _ 0.4301 0.430 11.6! 21.6: 2.0 208 0.28 175 6.0 20.8 -5.9 13.4 -10.0 20 0.430! 0.430 11.61 21.6; 6.0 209-0.28! 175 _ 610 _ 20.8 -5.9_ 13.4-10.0 20 0.430 0.430 11.6 21.6 22.5
2i0_ 028_ i_(T 6.0_ _.7 -116 10.3! 18.6_ 20
" - " 4.4 _ 20 _ 0.4_ t " 21 ! + 0,28 175 ! 6,0__. 11:7 -11,0- _ 4,4-15.01 20 0,300! 0.405 10.3: 18.6 4.4 212 L 0.28 175 6,04 11.7 -11.0 4.4 -15.0! 20 0.300 0.405; 10.31 18.6 16.7
_i3 0.28- 17_i 610i 20;8 -5,9i 13.4 _ _ 0.600 0.6001 600 665_ 2.0-
:fi_ 0._75_ _-2516--.516-i3_4_-10.01-_ 0.600; 0.6oo 600_ 6_5- 60-
221 0.39' 250 1.5_ 30.0 -0.8_ 22.4 -5.0i 20 0.540 0.540 29.1 75.1 30 222---(_39/ 250 .... 1_5 30,0 -0.8! 224 -5,0! 20_ 0.540 0.540__ 29.11 75.1_ 601 223 0.39! 250; 1.5! 30.0 -0.8_ 22.4: 20 0.300 0.310 10.3 18.5 2.9 i 224 i 0.39_ 250 1.51 30.0 -0.8! 22,4,-5.0L _ 0.300 0.310_ 10.31 18.5." 5.81 225 t 0.39 __ 250 ; 1,5__ 20.8 -5.91 . 13.4_ -10.01 15 0.600 0.500 71.2 82.7 3.6 2261 0.39 250 1.5i 20.8 -5.9: 134 -10.01 15 0.600 0.500; 71.2 82.7 7.2 231_ 0.28. 175, 4.0i 30.0 -0.8 22.41 _-6.0 20 0.540 0.540 17.0 37.9 2.0+ 232_ 0.28 175 . 4.0i 30.0 -0.8i 22.4 -5.0 L 20 0.540_ 0.540 17.0 37.9. 6.0 233! 0.28 175 4.0 20.8 -5.9 13.4-10.0 15 0.600 0.600 60.0 66.7 20 234_ 0.28 1 " 175 4.0_. 20.8 -5._9 134_-1_0 0 150,600 0.600 60.0.. 66.7 L 6.0_ 235 _ 0.28 175 4.0i_20.8 _ -5.9__ 13.4_-10.0 40 0.100 0.535 10.6 32.6 !.1.
236 0.28; 175 4.0 20.81 -5.9 13.4i -10.0 40 0.100 0.535 10.6 32.6 4.2 237 0.28 175 4.0 11.71 -11.0 4:.4- -15.0 20 0.300 0.405_ 10.3 18.6+ 1.5 238 0.28 T 1"75- 4.0 11.7' -11.0 4.4 -15.0 20 0.300 0.405 10.3 18.6 4.4 NASA/TP--2000-210031 41 C3.--PLANNED COMMERCIAL TRANSPORT TEST MATRIX Run Mach Airspd Attitude Tt Tt Ts Ts MVD LWC Spray No. No. (kts) (F) (C) (F) (C) (um) (g/m s) (min I 101 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10.6 20 0,410 6,0 102 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10,6 20 0.410 6.0 103 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10.6 20 0.410 22.5 104 0.45 279 -1.0 14.0 -10.0 -4.4 -20.2 15 0.295 6.0 105 0.45 279 -1.0 14.0 -10.0 -4.4 -20.2 15 0,295 22.5 106 0.45 279 0.0 14.0 -10.0 -4.4 -20,2 15 0,295 6.0 107 0.45 279 0,0 14,0 -10,0 -4.4 -20.2 15 0.295 22.5 108 0,45 279 0.0 14.0 -10.0 -4.4 -20.2 15 0,295 30,6 110 0.45 282 -1.0 23.0 -5.0 4.2 -15.4 20 0,285 6,0 111 0.45 282 -1.0 23.0 -5.0 4.2 -15.4 20 0,285 22.5 112 0.45 282 0.0 23.0 -5.0 4.2 -15.4 20 0,285 6,0 113 0.45 282 0.0 23.0 -5.0 4.2 -15.4 20 0.285 45.0 114 0.45 282 0.0 23.0 -5.0 4.2 -15.4 20 0.285 30.0 115 0,45 282 0.0 23.0 -5.0 4,2 -154 20 0.285 22.5 116 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10.6 20 0410 6.0 122 0.45 284 -1.0 32,0 0.0 12.8 -10,6 20 0,410 6.0 123 0.45 284 -1.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10.6 20 0.410 22.5 124 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0,0 12.8 -10.6 20 0.410 6.0 126 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10.6 20 0,410 30,0 127 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10.6 20 0.410 22.5 128 0.45 282 0.0 23.0 -5.0 4,2 -15.4 20 0.285 2.0 129 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10,6 20 0.410 2.0 130 0.40 253 0.0 32.0 0.0 16.7 -84 56 0.420 22.5 131 0.40 253 0.0 33.0 0.6 17.7 -7.9 56 0.420 22.5 132 0.40 253 0.0 35.0 1.7 19.7 -6.8 56 0.420 6.0 133 0.40 253 0.0 34.0 1.1 18.7 -7.4 56 0,420 22.5 141 0.45 284 0.0 18.0 -7.7 -0.6 -18.1 40 0,100 7,5 142 0.45 284 0.0 18.0 -7.7 -06 -18.t 40 0.100 2.0 143 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12,8 -10.6 40 0,512 6.0 144 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10,6 40 0,200 6,0 145 0.45 284 0.0 32.0 0.0 12.8 -10.6 40 0.200 22.5
42 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
C4.--COMPLETED COMMERCIAL TRANSPORT TEST MATRIX Run i Mach Airspd Attitude Tt Tt Ts Ts i MVD LWC LWC ! Pair Pwat S_ray i Notes NO" I No. , (k_S) : desired_) C(_(F) (C_ i u_ (g/m-) (g/m)_(psg) _sid____m!n ) ' i _- " C ----- i- ._7 ____,clesired act 101 _ 0.45i 284; 0.0 32.0 00 13.0 -10.0 20 0.410' _ 20.0 47.0 6.0 not scaled 102- 0.40_250 t 010- 320 t 0.0 _ 13.5"- _ 20 Q-4_ 0.460 20_0 4710 6.0_not scaled 103-Q_250_ 0-0_ 3210- 00_ 1-3-5"-100 + 201 ().4]-01 0.460 i 20.0 47.0 22.5ino_scaled
104 0.401_48_ -1.0 10.5 -1201 4o -20.01 15 I o.295 0.339- 17.:3__25.3_ 59
105- 0.40, 2_,-8_ _110!_0;5 --120_.0_-2_5 0.295! 0_3391 17.3 25.3 22.0
106 ...... ()AO_ 248 T 0101 __---2_5 i o295] 0.339 _ 17a_5----59 _ - -
106r1- -0._6_,48 i 00!-10:5_---1_-200 15! 0.29-5i 0.33_-- 25_3----_._ _i - _07" _--248_ -&O _015_-12.0"--_4_0_-20_ 15W01295 0.339_7.3_25.3--22.0" 108_ 040T 248_ "_00W105: -_ 12.0 --4.0_-20.0! 15!--0295 0.339i 17.3 .... 25.3--29.3' 110 0.40_ 250 -1 0 20.0i -6.3 5.1, -14.6 i 21 ! 0.285i 0.3414 11.8 23.2 5.7
11i-; 6.40'_25{) = :10T 20.OP -6,3_51! -146 211 0._5 0,341 _ i118 23_2 21.1: "
112 I 040 250 0.0 20.0! -6.3i 5.11 -14.6! 21 I 0.285 0.341 118 232 5.7 .....
_{4 1 B_.40_ 2-56_-206_--6_ t. -14.6 21 0.285; 0.341 _ i_8 23:2 28.3
115 0.40 250 0.0: 20.01 -6.31 5.1! -146 21 0.285! 0.341 11.8 23.2: 21.1 mold made i16 " 0.40T 255 _ -1.0-3816_ 4.0! 23.1_-4.6 ' 21 0.410 0.500 23.8 62.6 55 ice shed - no data 122 0.40i 253 _ -1.0 29_ -1.1 14.3 i -9.5 21 0.410 0.563 29.7 83.22 4.9 123 0.40i 253 -1.0 29.5 i -1.1 14.3_ -9.5 21 0.410 0.563 29.7 83.2 18.5 124_ OT40_ 253 0.0 29.51 -1.1 14.3' -9.5 21 0,410 0.563 29.7 83.2 i 4.9 _ _ 126 0.4_0_ 0.0 29.5 -1.1 14,3: -9.5 21 0,410 0.563 29.7 83,2 24,6
_27, 5 217.1 _-43! ;gT 21' 0.410 0563 29.7_ 83.2: 18.5mo_0 made
1_ 0.40 _ 250_ 010" 20,0 _- -613- 5i]*-14.6 21 0,285 0.341 11.8 23.2L 2.0 ........
.... + ..............
129 i 0.40 253 0.0 29.5 -1.1 14.3 -9,5 21 0.410 0.563 29.7_ 83.21 2.0 130 0.40i 253 0.0 32.0 0.3 16.7 -8.t 56 0.420 unk 8.2: 32.0 18.0 not scaled 131 0.40_ _ 253_ ._0.0 33.0 0.9 17.7 -7.6i 56 0.420. unk -, 8.2 32.0 18.0.no_t scaled___ : not scaled, ice shed - _ 132 0.402 .... 253 . 0.0 35.0 2.0 19.7 -6.5_ 56 0.420 unk 8.2 32.0 5.2 no data 56 0.420 unk 8.2 32.0 18.0 not scaled 133 0.40! 253 0.0 34.0 1.4 18.7 -7.1 i 141 ..... 0.402z$9--0_0 _ 15.0 .... £9.1-- 013- -1_ 42' 0.100 0400 10.1 30.3 67 i42_ 0.404 249 010 15_0 -9.1 0_3-17.3 i 42 0.100 0.400 i 10.1 30.3 2:Q
Q4_3 _ 0.40_ 253 0.0 29.0 -1.3, 13.8:-9.81 42 0.512 0.6501 21.8 101.8 5.3 ._
144 I 0.40 253 0.0 i 25.51 -3.31 10.4-11.6 42 0.200 0.400! 10.4 31.3 3.0 14_ 0.40 253 0.0_ 25.5_ -3.3! 10.4_-Jt_6 _ 42J__ 0.200 9.400- 19.4 31.3 _ .
i 145m 'Q40_253- 0.0:25.5 -3.3; 10.4:-11.61 42! 0.200 0.4001 10.4 31,3 11.2,molemade NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 43 C5.--GENERAL AVIATION AIRFOIL TEST MATRIX I6i02_ Run FMach ÷ Airspd Attitude 4 Tt i T_t Ts Ts .MVD LWC L_, Pair Pwat Spray_ Noles NO: i No. I (kts) i desire_ (F)____C) [ (F_C) _ _ (g/_) (g/m3i_(psip)! _idii (rnin) _ ! : I ! -desired- aci i _ --. ......
60_--0.29; 180 0,_-3Q0- -6.8. 224 _- -5.0_ 20" 0154-0i 0,540i 19.0- 41.0 _ 210_ 0_2.9L 18<L 0.0-30_0.8_2:4[-5.0 i _ 0_-0__19___ 411_ I 6._i_i i_I 2rn 0.29 | 180! 0.0! 30.0 -0.8 22.41_ -5.01 20 1 0.540 0.640_ 19.0 41.01 6.0_mold ....
-- I _ +- ........
60_ 0.29_ 180! 0.0 30.0 i -0.8 22.4_ -5.0 20 0.540 0.540! 19.0 41.0_ 22.5 i __ 0.29. 180 0.0 20.81 -5_.9i 13.4 _ -i0.0- 2_0 0:__.:30_ 0_430* 14._ 25.0_ 210 _ - 607 [ 0.29 i 180' 0.0 i 20.8] -5.91 _ 13.4 -10.0_-- 2__ -0:4-30: _14.5- 25.0_ " 16_0_ 607__m: 0.29 180 0.0 20.8: -5,9 13.4-10.0 201 0,430 _5 25.01 6.0imoid 608; 0.291 180! 0.0, 20.8J -591 134' -1()i01 __0- -0_4301 14-5V-25_.0 -2_ - 6091 0.29i' 180 0.0 11.7 -110 44i-15.0 ;0--osoo 0 -30 10:01-- 45 ....
610, 0.29 1801 0.0, 11.7-11.0, 4,4[-15.(3_ 0300 03301 10.0 14.5_ 8.0i
-611 0.29! 1801 _ _76_4- -150! 2o' 0_0330!-i0_ .....1-4_2_5T--
_ 612 i 0.29 [ 180-_ 0.0* 2_00:8___-5.9 13.4 -10.0_ -0.600 O_t-801()_----_-- 612r: 0.29 I 180 I O_ 20.8! -5.9; 13.4L-10.0 # 15! 0:600 -0_5_ 80.0 _-- -80_0 _ -- 210_rr_ -613i 0.29! 180 I 0.0 2_9_.z1/-_0: -15'01600- 0.560__6:_6.0 ....
621m 0.21 ! 130 2.0 i 26.4 -2.81 22.4'--5.0_--20-' 0:_0_ o..5_()L - 14_ _._.2.0"mo1_- --622_ 0-.21 _0-_0- 26.4! -2.8, ___-0.540_0:5_,0_ 14.0_-23.0' -60! -- 622rl 0.21 130__ 2.0,' 26.4 -- -2.81-- 22.4 -5 0 i 20 0.54()--5.5401_z[5/230--_eat _- 622r2_ 0.21 : 130: 2.01 26._ -2.8 L 22 4 -5._ 20; 0 540i 0.540 14.01 23.0_ 6.0 repeat 622m 0.2"t[ 130 I 2.0! 26.4! 3:8! 22._-5.0_._i--20 0_40_0_,_i_23.0! .... 6})irnold 623 0.21 130 20 264 -28 224' -50' 20 0540 0540 140 230 _ 225 _ - " 623m I 0.21 130-'_2__-- 20_0. 540 *_ 0 _1114 -0--23 ()--_mo_d ....
625 0.21I 130 i 2.01 -_81 13.41-lo,o_ -_j%o: 0:6_1010! 341(3_ 0:9_--
626: 0.21 ! 1301 2.0 17.3 -7.8 13.4! -10.0 20 0.430 0.440 10.0' 15.0! 2.0i .......
627/ 0.21 130.: 2.Q 17.3 -7.8 13.4 i -10.0 20 0.4301 0.44_ 15.0 5.9
627m[- 0.21 130 2.01 173i-781 13.41 -10.0i 20i ....01430 _ 0,4-4o 10.01--__9+mo]_ -
_ 627r 0.21 [ 130[__ 17.31 -7.81 13.41 -10.0_0_-_:430 _--i5.0 i _5.9;repea, -
627r2 0.21 i 130 2.0 17.3 -7.8 13.4-10.0 20 -&436__5.0[ 15.0-59_reepe_-- 628 i 0.21 130 2.0 17.3 -7_-10.0 -20 _ 6A30_o_o-t10.O * i5.L220; -- 6291 0.21 130, 2.0 83 -12.9 4.4 _ 0.300 0440 1001 1501 14- ....
30 0.21 130_20 8.3-12.9 4.41-15.0_-#0 o.30o 0.440 100 15.0 4,11
631 0.21 130 2.0 8.3 -12 9 4 4 -15.0 20 0.300 0.440 10.0 15.0' 15.3
_--OW2_ 130/ 2._ ;-/A -781 13.,_ -10.01 15/%:600 0,600 35.0 A-5_e-__-
633m 021 / 130 _- -2-0 17 3 78 13-_ i -_-'" ....... _- " ' --- - ____ ...... _ _._ ,,.,., -,.o ,o.l -10.0 15 0.600: _ 35.0 6.0 mold 0.21 130 ' 0.0 17.3 -7.8 13.4 -10_- -20-'---0._4__1-5_0_ 2;0_ ---- 1 / . / -78 134 -100 20, 0430 0440 10.0 150 220 644! __0_.21_130 4.0 17.3: -7.8 134 -10.0 20 0.430! 0.440_ 150 2.0: 0.21 130 40i 17 3 -7.8 13.4 -10_ * :_0-_ - 0.436_" 0.440 i0_-0_ 15.6__-- ¢_5mJ 0.21--_30_-_4.0 17.3 -7.8 13.4-10.0--3_ ()ii_40 _6! 59m_o/d ....
646 0.21 1301 40 173] -78! 13 41--10.0[_Q;,30 044_-_50 220----
-64_0-21 ! 130 t- 6:_ _-7.8, 13.4 ! -10.0 t 20 "_ 514_0_10_.0_-_5.0-_---
60, :43o: 0:44o 1ool 5o7
-649 0.21 __: 6:()17.3 _i3_41-10.0i 201-VA30_ 0_440" 10 _ i5.01 _-
665i o13: 83 - 13.4! .10 20'oeo7 -
656! 0.13 83 6.0 15.0 -91 134 -100 20 0430 i 0650 100, 150 _ ............
661 0.21 I 1301 0.0 28.2 -1.8 -2_ _ 2051 1.0(30 1000'35,5 100-0_ 15"04 ---- 44 NASA/TP----2000-210031 C6.--LaRC/LeRC ICING CONTAMINATION TESTS NOVEMBER 1998 Run nos. 301-310 ice shape 622-2D (SLA) Run nos. 23-35 clean wing Reynolds Mach number Reynolds Mach number number number 0.29 0.05 0.12 0.21 0.05 0.12 0.21 0.29 1 310 1 35 3 3O8 3 25 4.6 3O9 4.6 26 302 307 304 6.4 6.4 24 28 27 8.1 8.1 29 301 306 10 23 30 12 32 Run nos. 401-410 ice sha Runnos. 101-112 icesha Mach number Reynolds Reynolds Mach number number number 0.05 0.12 0.21 0.29 0.05 0.12 0.21 0.29 410 1 1 112 3 409 3 109 4.6 403 4.6 103 6.4 402 407 404 6.4 106 108 111 8.1 8.1 107 10 40 t 406 10 101 102 12 105 Run nos. 501-510 ice sha Run nos. 201-211 ice sha Reynolds Mach number Reynolds Mach number number number 0.05 0.12 0.21 0.29 0.21 0.29 0.05 0.12 510 1 1 211 5O8 3 3 208 4.6 504 4.6 6.4 502 507 505 207 210 6.4 202 8.1 8.1 10 501 503 201 203 Run nos. 701-705 clean wing Reynolds Mach number number 0.05 0.12 0.21 0.29 705 3 7O2 4.6 8.1 701 703 NAS A/TP--2000-210031 45
Appendix D1
Appendix D1
Test Results, Business Jetmlst Entry
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 47
Business Jet- Run 072595.01
Tt = -0.8°C (30.6°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3 C._t... = 0.0093
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
C_-ic_ = 0.0481
MVD = 20 _m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 o __ I I Ice Thickness -0.02 ower Max -0.04 -0.06 -0.05 0,00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0,20 0.25 X/C
48 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072595.02
Cd<t_,n= 0.0093
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (30.6°F)
C__ic_= 0.0478
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0 06 0.04 0_02
J
u
Lower Max
I
i UpperMa x /t: _rnha tckoneu _ e
-0.02 _36" Tracin_l 11.43 mm IO45"/I 3.81 mm (0.15" I , -0.04 -0,06 ................. L ....................
_.05 0.00 005 010 0.15 020 0.25 X/C
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 49
Business Jet - Run 072595.03
Tt = -0.8°C (30.6°F) LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 22.5 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,08 0.06 0.02 o
Upper Max Stagnation Line Lower Max
I ,ceT.,ckne.s I I
_36"Tracin_l 32.1 mm(1.26" I 12.8mml0.50" ) -0,02 _04 _0.06 ...................... _ ....................
-0.05 0.0o 0.05 0_I0 0.15 0,20 0.25 yJc
50 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072595.04
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.800°C (30.6°F)
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
Spray = 45.0 min
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Attitude = 6.103 chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0 O4 _11 Ice Thickness Lower Max -002 -004 -0 06 -o.o8 ................
o.o5 OlO o15 020 -o lO _ 05 o.oo xJc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 51
Business Jet - Run 072695.01
T, = -1.7°C (28.9°F) LVVC = 0.405 g/m 3 Cd-c_=n = 0.0093
T, = -5.9°C (21.4°F) C_._,_= 0.0258
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 4.4 min
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 F
I
i 0.06 0.04 0.02 J ooo Lower Max upper Max Sta_lnation Line I _36" Tracin_l 9.07 mm (0.36") 3.56 mm (0.14" 1 I Ice Thickness =0.02 -0.04 _306 _ ...........
-005 0.00 0.05 0.10 015 0,20 0.25 x/c
52 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072695.02
LWC = 0.405 g/m 3 C,j-ci,,.n = 0.0093
Tt = -1.8°C (28.9°F)
C,j-ic_ = O. 0526
Ts = -6.0°C (21.2°F)
MVD = 20 p.m
Spray = 16.7 min
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
O08 0.06 0.02 J u !
000- Ice Thickness Lower Max UpperMax I Stagnation Line j 24.0 mm (094" I 11.8 mm (0.47" I 36" Tracing -0.02 -0.04 -006 .......................
015 020 _).05 000 005 010 _C
NASA/TP--2000-210031 53
Business Jet - Run 072695.03
"It = -1.7°C (28.9°F)
LWC = 0.405 g/m 3 C_._l=, = 0.0093
T, = -5.9°C (21.4°F)
C__,:,_= 0.1001
MVD = 20 I_m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 33.3 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0.04 0.02 //
i ,ceThickn
Lower Max
O,_,oe.'.x I _*',,°..,'o°'-'ne I
__ . , . . " -0.02 -0.04
__ 119o > 21,rnm 10'_/
-0.08 -01o -0.05 0.00 0.05 0 10 015 0.20 X/C
54 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 072695.04
LVVC = 0.43 g/m 3 Cd-:_,,,o = 0.0093
Tt = -5.9°C (21.4°F)
Cd.i_ = 0.0202
T, = -10.0°C (14.0°F)
MVD = 20 p,m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 c)
I I ,oe_,c_oe,_
Lower Max
upper Max Sta_lnation Line
I --36"Tracin_l , 8.9mm(.35")I 6_3mml25"/ I -002 _104 -006 .......................
0.20 025 _005 0.00 005 0.10 015 xJc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 55
Business Jet - Run 072695.05
"It = -5.9°C (21.4°F)
LVVC = 0.43 g/m 3 Cd._n = 0.0093
T, = -10.0°C (14.0°F)
Cd-_d = 0.0412
MVD = 20 Hm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 45.0 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.(38 • !
l 0.06 0.04 0.02
0.O0 _.-.---"_J I I ,ceT,,_°e,s
Lower Max
__ \ J J Upper Max [ Sta_lnation LineJ
-0.02 _ _ !--36"Tracin_ [ 67.2mm(264",J44.gmm(1.77.)[ -004 _ -0,06 ..............
-0.10 -0.05 0,00 005 010 0.15 0,20 x/C
I*
56 NAS A/TP----2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072795.01
LWC = 0.43 g/m 3 Cd-:,_o= 0.0093
TI = -5.9°C (21.4°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.0277
T, = -10.0°C (14.0°F)
MVD = 20 _m
Spray = 22.5 min
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
OO6 0.04
J
0 02 u 0.00
Lower Max
upper Max Sta_lnation Line I
I Ice Thickness I
I 32.0 mm (126') 20,3 mm (0.80") I
-002
cin_
-0.04 -006 ......
0.15 020 025 _0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 x/c
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 57
Business Jet - Run 072795.02
"It = -5.9°C (21.4°F) LVVC = 0.60 g/m 3 Cd<l_n = 0.0093
T, = -10.0°C (14.0°F) Cd._ = 0.0125
MVD = 15 _m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o.oej
I
!
0.06 0.04 0.02 0,00 Lower Max Upper Max Stal]nation Line I Ice Thickness I 36" Tracin_ 11 mm (.43") 4.1 mm (.16"1 -0,02 -004 -0.06 -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 015 0,20 0.25 x/c
58 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072795.03
C___t_,= 0.0093
LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
T, =-5.9°C (21.4°F)
Cd-io.d= 0.0251
T, = -10.0°C (14.0°F)
MVD = 15 _tm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o Lower Max Upper Max Sta_lnation Line J Ice Thickness J 35" Tracing 45.1 mm/1.78 / -0.02 -0 04 -006 00o 005 o 10 015 020 • .0 05 x/c
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 59
Business Jet - Run 072795.04
"It = -6.0°C (21.4°F)
LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
Cd<t_, = 0.0093
T, = -10.0°C (14.0°F)
Cd..:_ = 0.0266
MVD = 15 p.m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 45.0 min
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 r
006 i
004 L l I i 0.00 [
Upper Max StaQnation Line I Lower Max
I
Ice Thickness I J
719 mm (2.83I
_)02 - _).04 -OC_i -0.I0 4_.05 0.00 0.05 010 0.15 020 xJc
60 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072795.05
Cd<l,,o = 0.0093
LWC = 0.405 g/m 3
Tt = -11.0°C (12.3°F)
Cd.,c,_= 0.0197
T, = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
Spray = 4.4 min
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0 O8
J
c> O.C(] Upper Max Stagnation Line Lower Max
I I I'ceT--ss I I
_36" Tracing 6.0 mm (24" I 4) 02 -004 -00.8 0.00 005 010 015 020 025 -005 x/c
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 61
Business Jet - Run 072795.06
Tt = -11.0°C (12.3°F) LWC = 0.405 g/m 3
Cd-cl,, = 0.0093
T, = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.0218
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 33,3 min
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 r 0.06 L 0.04 0.02 "_ I Ice Thickness 0.00 Lower Max -0.02
_oo, 1,0u_ ,-,;_, is",n"°° "he I
-004 -0.06 - - - _.i0 _},05 0.00 0.05 010 0.15 0.20 YJc .....
62 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 072895.02
Cd_clea n = 0.0082
T, = -1.3°C (29.7°F) LVVC = 0.50 g/m 3
T, = -9.3°C (15.3°F) Cd-_ = 0.0132
MVD = 15 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 3.9 min
Attitude = 1.6 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 .
004 , 002 • 0.00 •
Ice Thickness
Lower Max
36" Tracm
-0.02 , -004 -006 ...........................
-005 0.00 005 0 10 0 15 0 20 0.25 x/c
NASAITP--2000- 210031 63
Business Jet - Run 072895.03
Tt = -1.3°C (29.7°F)
LVVC = 0.50 g/m 3 C_._t_,o = 0.0082
T, = -9.3°C (15.3°F)
C_.,c_ = 0.0161
MVD = 15 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 7.2 min
Attitude = 1.6 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,08 0.06
J
0.02
J
J
u 0,011
Ice Thickness
Lower Max
36" Tr
-0.02 -004 -0.06 .......
-0.05 OCO 005 0 10 0.15 020 0.25 x,'C
64 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 072895.04
Cd-_l,_,= 0.0082
LVVC = 0.43 g/m 3
It = -2,2°C (28°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0170
Ts = -10.2°C (13.7°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 3.0 min
Attitude = 1.6 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
jf
/ • i 0.00
Upper Max Sta_lnation Line Lower Max
I Ice Thickness I _36" Tracin_ 3,38 mm t0.13"/ -002 -004 _0.o6 010 015 020 025 -005 000 0 05 X/C
NASA/TP--2000-210031 65
Business Jet- Run 072895.05
T, = -2.2°C (28.0°F)
LWC = 0.43 g/m 3
Cd-ct,an = 0.0082
T, =-10.2°C (13.7°F)
Cd-ic,d= 0.0264
MVD = 20 _m
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 6.0 rain
Attitude = 1.6 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
OO8 0.06 i 000.
Ice Thickness Lower Max --36" _,02 -0.04 -006 _0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 xJc
66 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072895.06
C_._,_n= 0.0082
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
T_= -2.2°C (28.0°F)
C__,c,_ = 0.0188
T, = -10.2°C (13.7°F)
MVD = 20 I_m
Spray = 3.0 min
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Attitude = 1.6°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0.04
J
0.02 u 0.00
Ice Thickness ]
I-- 36" Tracin_l I upper Max
I Sta,nation Line l Lower Max
8.88 rnrn/0.35") 9.35 mm (0.37" /
-0.02 -004 • -006 ...................
015 0.20 0.25 -0.05 000 005 010 YJC
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 67
Business Jet - Run 072895.07
"It = -2.2°C (28.0°F) LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
C_.cl_o= 0.0082
T, = -10.2°C (13.7°F)
Cd._ = 0.0315
MVD = 20 _m
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 1.6 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 ,
I
0.06 0.04 0.02 u L i 0(30 Ice Thickness Lower Max B36" -9.02 [
i
-004 i i _006 -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 025 X,'C
68 NASAJTP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 072895.08
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3 Cd-cl_n= 0.0093
T, = -11.0°C (12.3°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.0220
Ts = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
MVD = 20 }am
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 45.0 min
Attitude = 6.1° chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0.04 ¢.___,_._-_-_;_J I I ,ce Th,ck°e,, Lower Max
'___ I -_o Tracin_l I._==,_%?, 1 Sta_lnation.ne I
-0 02 -0 04 0.15 -0 10 X).05 0 00 0 05 0 10 X/C
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 69
Business Jet - Run 073195.01
Tt = -7.3°C (18.9°F)
LWC = 0.31 g/m 3 Cd._l_o= 0.0082
T, = -15.0°C (5.0°F) C_.,=_= 0.0125
MVD = 20 _um
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 2.9 min
Attitude = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 O00
Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max
I I '°eT"'ck°e" 1 1
_36" Tracin 9 3.6 mm (,14") J -0.02 -0.04 -005 0.00 005 o. 10 0 15 0.20 0.25 x/c
70 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 073195.02
Cd-cl_n= 0.0082
LWC = 0.31 g/m 3
T, = -7.3°C (18.9°F)
Cd_,=_ = 0.0134
T, = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 5.8 min
Attitude = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0 08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0,00
upper Max I Leading Ed,qe I Lowe, M.x
Ice Thickness I I I --36" Tracing
I 7,67 mm/0,30"/
-002 -004 -006 015 0.20 0.25 0.10 _).05 0.(30 005 x/C
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 71
Business Jet - Run 073195.03
It = -11.0°C (12.3°F) LWC = 0.405 g/m 3
Cd-d_n= 0.0093
T, = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
C_-ic_ = 0.0220
MVD = 20 Hm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 16.7 min
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,08 0,06 0.04 0,00
Lower Max
Upper Max Leadin_l Eddie
I I'ceTh'ckn" I
21,3 mm (0.84")
-002
1 _36" Tracin_
.0.04 i .0.06 ....
.0.05 000 005 0.10 015 0.20 0.25 x/c
72 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 073195.04
Cd.clea n " 0.0093
LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -11.0°C (12.3°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0212
Ts = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
Spray = 6.0 min
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0(30 Lower Max Stagnation Line 9.86 mm 10.39 '/ _.02 Ice Thickness -0.06 ..............
015 0.20 0.25 -005 000 0.05 010 x/c
NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 73
Business Jet - Run 073195.05
T, = -11.0°C (12.3°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3 Cd.clea n -"0.0093
T, = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
Cd.,=_ = 0.0299
MVD = 20/am
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 22.5 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,06 004 - 0.00 I I ,°eT.,okne..
f \ I J Upper Max 1 LeadingEdge
-oo2 _ _ I --36"Tracing I i40.2mm(1.58.,,I LowerMax J
_0.04 -006 ............................................
_). 10 -0.05 0.00 005 0,10 0.15 020 X/C
74 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080195.01
Cd-_,_, = 0.0082
LVVC = 0.41 g/m 3
T, = -12.5°C (9.5°F)
Cd-_:_ = 0.0091
T, = -20.0°C (4.3°F)
MVD = 40 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 0.7 min
Attitude = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 Ice Thickness
Lower Max
I
Upper Max Leadin,qEd(:le
1.07 mn_ t0.04"/ I 36" Tracin_l -002 -004 -006 ..............
0 10 0 15 020 _) 05 000 005 x/C
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 75
Business Jet - Run 080195.02
T, =-12.5°C (9.5°F)
LWC = 0.41 g/m 3
Cd.c_o = 0.0082
T, = -20.0°C (-4.3°F)
Cd._ = 0.0112
MVD = 40 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Spray = 1.5 min
Attitude = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06
o04 i
i 0.02 I i o ; 000: Upper Max Leadin 9 Edge J Lower Max
I I i ' Th'ckne [
_36" Tracin_l 2,87 mm (0.11" / J -0.02 -0.04 -0.05 0,00 0.05 010 0.15 0.20 0.25 x/C 'ili :41 '1
76 NAS A/TP--2000-2 t0031
Business Jet - Run 080195.03
Cd-_,_.= 0.0093
LWC = 0.535 g/m 3
Tt = -14.0°C (6.8°F)
Cd-ic. = 0.0188
Ts = -18.0°C (-0.4°F)
MVD = 20 #m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 6.1° chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness 13.00 Lower Max _02 -004 _).OB .............................
_005 0.00 0 05 0 10 015 0 20 X/C
NAS AffP--2000-210031 77
Business Jet - Run 080195.04
-It = -14.0°C (6.8°F) LWC = 0.535 g/m 3
C_-c_an = 0.0087
T, = -18.0°C (-0.4°F)
C_-ice_ = 0.0151
MVD = 20/am
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 4.0 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.02 /""/ I Ice Thickness O.OO Lower Max -0.02 -0.04 -0.06 -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 O. 15 020 0 25 X/C
78 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080195.05
LWC = 0.535 g/m 3 C_<,_ = 0.0087
Tt = -14.0°C (6.8°F)
C__,_ = 0.0201
T, = -18.0°C (-0.4°F)
MVD = 40 _.m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 4.0 ° chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 002 . lJ J o 001) J J Ice Thickness Lower Max -002 ; L -0.04 .
-006 .................................
-0.05 0.00 0.05 010 015 0.20 0.25 X/C
NASA/TP--2000-210031 79
Business Jet- Run 080195.06
"It = -14.0°C (6.8°F)
LVVC = 0.535 g/m 3
Cd._,,,,o = 0.0087
T, = -19.9°C (-3.7°F)
Cd.,=_= 0.0192
MVD = 40 pm
V = 109 m/s (212 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 4.0 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,08 0.06 0.04 I I Ice Thickness 0.00 _02 _,,____' \ _ I --36" Tracin_l I Upper Max I 1L.ega_rm g/E.d_le, i I Lower Max I -0.04 -oo6 ........................................
_)05 0.00 0.05 0 10 0 15 020 0.25 xJc
80 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080195.07
Cd-cl_,n = 0.0087
LWC = 0.535 g/m 3
Tt = -14.0°C (6.8°F)
Cd_io_ = 0.0174
T, = -19.9°C (-3.7°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 109 m/s (212 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 4.0 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.04 0¸[7:)
Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max
I I I'ceTh'c'°''s I
_36" Tracing] 11.8 mm t0.47') -002 .O, 04 -006 0 15 0 20 0.25 0(30 0.05 010 -O05 x/C
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 81
Business Jet- Run 080195.08
"It = -14.0°C (6.8°F) LVVC = 0.535 g/m 3
Cd-_l,,,n = 0.0093
T, = -18.0°C (-0.4°F)
Cd._ = 0.0302
MVD = 40 _m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 O04 0.00
Upper Max Leading] EdFje Lower Max
I I Ice Thickness
_36" Tracin_l 123 mm (0.49" I
-0,02 -0.04 -0.06 -005 000 0.05 010 0.15 020 025 X/C
!'! i'iiii_iil
i¸ ii!ii_il; ¸
i!_
iiiii_ii_!iiii!i_
82 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080195.09
LVVC = 0.535 g/m 3 Cd-_l,,o= 0.0093
Tt = -14.0°C (6.8°F)
Cd._ = 0.0275
T, = -18.0°C (-0.4°F)
MVD = 40 [um
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 4.2 min
Attitude = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0 O2 Ice Thickness t Upper Max I Leading Edge I Lower Max I s28 mm (0.33") I I -002 -0.04 -0.06 ......................
0.20 Q25 -0.05 000 0.05 0.10 015 X/C
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 83
Business Jet - Run 080295.01
"It = -0.8°C (31.0°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
C___,,,n = 0.0093
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
Cd_ic_= 0.0679
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 12.0 min
Attitude = 6.0 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
O06 0,04 0.02 I Ice Thickness 0,(30 Lower Max
I Upper Max I Stagnation Line I
.0.02 _36"Tracin_ I 19,6 mm 10.77"11 8.20 mm I0.32" / -0.04 - 0.00 0.05 0,10 0.15 0.20 0,25 x/c
84 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080295.02
Cd-cl_o= 0.0087
LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (31.0°F)
C_.,c_ = 0.0014
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
Attitude = 4.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 u __j/ [ Ice Thickness 0.00 [ _ _ Lower Max -002 -0.04 -006 ..............................
-O.08 000 0.08 0 10 015 0 20 025 >dC
NASAfrP--2000- 210031 85
Business Jet - Run 080295.04
"It = -0.8°C (31.0°F) LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
C__cl_,= 0.0087
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
C_._ = 0.0217
MVD = 20 _m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 4.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o_o8 r
!
0.06 0.04 0.02 - u 0.170
__ J I Ice Thickness
I -_. T=o0 I_u,:: _oaX I ,St,_n,_oo_,_,,,,; I Lower Max J
43.02 -004 _0.06 i ...........
-0.05 0,00 0.05 010 015 0.20 0.25 x,'c
86 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080295.05
Cd.clea n = 0.0087
LWC = 0.43 g/m 3
Tt = -3.9°C (24.9°F)
Cd-ic,_= 0.0352
T, = -10.0°C (14.0°F)
MVD = 20 _m
V = 109 m/s (212 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
Attitude = 4.1° chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 i i _ickness Lower Max _)02 _)04 -006 ............
010 0 15 020 025 -0 05 000 0,05 xJc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 87
Business Jet- Run 080295.06
T, = -0.8°C (31.0°F)
LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3
C___l_,o = 0.0087
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
Cd_,:_= 0.0679
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
Attitude = 4.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,08 0.04 0.02 u
I I Joe T,iokne,s I
0.00 I I Upper Max I Sta_lnation Line I Lower Max I -002
I _36"Tracin_ I 32.0 mm (1.26")1 7.32mm (0.29" I ] I
_).04 -006 _)05 Q00 005 0,10 0.15 0.20 0.25 X/C
88 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 080395.01
Cd__,_,o = 0.0082
LVVC = 0.75 g/m 3
T, = -0.7°C (30.8°F)
Cd-iced = 0.0380
T, = -8.7°C (16.3°F)
MVD = 15 p.m
Spray = 10.0 rain
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Attitude = 1.5 ° chord = 90 cm (36 in)
006 - 0.04¸ 0.0(I i Ice Thickness i Lower Max 36" Tracir -002 -004 , -006 ...................
-0 05 O.00 005 0 10 0.15 :'Jc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 89
Business Jet - Run 080395.02
T, = -0.7°C (30.8°F) LWC = 1.25 g/m 3
Cd_:,_,o = 0.0082
T, = -8.7°C (16.3°F)
C_.,_ = 0.0247
MVD = 20 !um
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Spray = 5.4 min
Attitude = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.04 0 O2 0,00 Ice Thickness Lower Max --45" Traci_ -O.02 -004 -O.06 -O05 000 0.05 0.10 015 0.20 0.25 XJC
90 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080395.03
Cd_clea n = 0.0093
LWC = 1.00 g/m 3
Tt = -2.0°C (28.4°F)
C_.,c_ = 0.0775
T, = -6.2°C (20.9°F)
MVD = 15 p.m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 15.0 min
AOA = 6.1 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
J
ceThck
I I UpperMax I Stal]nati°nLine I LowerMax _0 O2 I _36"Tracin_l I 36.6 mm (144")1 128.7 mm (1,13") -004 _o.o6 ......
005 OlO o15 0,20 _3.o5 o.oo xJc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 91
Business Jet - Run 080395.04
"It = -4.4°C (24.2°F)
LWC = 1.60 g/m 3
Cd.clea n = 0.0093
T, = -8.5°C (16.7°F)
C_._,_= 0.1027
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 8.4 min
Attitude = 6.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
008 , 0.06 0,04 0,02 o 0.00 Lower Max Upper Max Stagnation Line I Ice Thickness _36"Tracin_] 38.5mm/1,51" / 14.0mm(0.55 ) I -002 _)04 _.06 -005 000 005 0.10 015 020 0.25 xJc
92 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080395.05
LVVC = 0.75 g/m 3
Tt = -7.4°C (18.8°F)
Ts = -15.2°C (4.7 °F)
MVD = 15 p.m
Spray = 10.0 min
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Attitude = 1.60
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o
Upper Max Stagnation Line Lower Max
I I i'c'_'ck°'ss i I
_36"Tracina I 28.7mm(1.13") 16,8mm(0.66") 27.9mm(1.10") -9 O2 -O04 -0.06 .......................
020 025 -005 0.O0 0.05 010 0.15 xJc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 93
Business Jet - Run 080395.06
Tt = -7.4°C (18.8°F) LWC = 1.25 g/m 3
Cd-cl=o= 0.0082
T, = -15.2°C (4.7°F)
C,-,c_ = 0.0577
MVD = 20 _.m
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Spray = 5.4 min
Attitude = 1.6 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00
Lower Max
Upper Max I Sta_lnation Line I
I I Ice Thickness I
_36" Tracin_l I 34,3 mm 11.35") I 11.3 mm (0.44"} I
_02 -0.04 -006 .............
_).05 0(30 0.05 010 015 0.20 0.25 xJC
i_i:!!iii_iii
94 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 080395.07
Cd-c,_n= 0.0093
LWC = 1.60 g/m 3
T, = -11.0°C (12.3°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0433
Ts = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 8.4 min
Attitude = 6.1 o chord = 90 cm (36 in)
008 r 0.06 0.04 u J 009_ __...._ I Ice Thickness I Stagnation Lin Lower Max I _36"Tracir 21.6 mm {0.85 .
-0.02 -004 4306 ...........................
-o lo -005 o.oo 005 o lO 0.15 x/c
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 95
Business Jet - Run 080495.01
TI = -27.8°C (-18.0°F) LVVC = 0.83 g/m 3
T, = -31.6°C (-24.9°F)
MVD = 160 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 6.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 J 002 i 0.00 I --36" Tracing 18,4U3PmP_ ;a;3,,)I StaFIn:tiOn Line I -0 02 __ Lower Max J -0.04 _.o6 .....
-0.05 o.00 0.05 0.10 015 020 025 X/C
96 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 080495.02
LVVC = 0.83 g/m 3
"It = -27.8°C (-18.0°F)
T, = -31.6°C (-24.9°F)
MVD = 160 pm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
Attitude = 4.1 o
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
O08 0.06 0,02 o % 0(73 I Ice Thickness Lower Max ] Upper Max ] Stagnation Line I
-002 _ I _36" Tracin_l I I
_O4 -0(1t3 _ .....................
020 025 -005 0.(30 0 05 0 10 0 15 YJc
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 97
Business Jet - Run 080495.04
Tt = -11.0°C (12.2°F)
LWC = 0.83 g/m 3
T, = -15.0°C (5.0°F)
MVD = 160 Hm
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 20.0 min
Attitude = 4.1°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
006 , I
o.o4
I
I 002 i
_racin
-0.08 -0.10 -0.05 0,00 0,05 010 0.15 0.20 X/C
98 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 080495.05
LWC = 0.83 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (30.6°F)
T, = -5.00C (23.0°F)
MVD = 160 pm
Spray = 20.0 min
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Attitude = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
008 •
i
o.c_ [ i oo4 i L I 0.02 i i u I Ice Thickness 0.00 i
I Lower Max
Upper Max Sta,qnation I
_36" Tracin_ 34.2 mm (1.35") I ' Line 4?.02 -004 _).o6 .............................
-005 000 005 0 10 0 15 0 20 X/C
NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 99
Business Jet - Run 080495.06
Tt = -0.8°C (30.6°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Cd-cl_o= 0.0093
T, = -5.0°C (23.0°F)
C_._ = 0.1201
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 90 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 22.5 min
Attitude = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 u 0.00 Ice Thickness Lower Max -0.02 -004 -0.06 *0.05 o.oo 0,05 010 015 0.20 0.25 X/C
100 NAS A/TP----2000-210031
Appendix D2
Appendix D2
Test Results, Business Jet--2nd Entry
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 101
Business Jet - Run 201
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
LWC = 0.405 g/m 3
C_._l_n= 0.0092
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
Cd.,c,_= 0.0353
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 4.4 min Ci.ctea n -" 0.676
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C,=ed= 0.654
0.08 r _:_ Thickn@s_ upper Max Leadin_ Edge Lower Max --42" Tracing 6,7 mm (.27") 4.3 mm (.17") 2.5 mm (0,10") 0.06 36" Tracing 5.6 mm (.22") 3.5 mm (. 14") 1.8 mm (0.07") -- 30" Tracing 6.7 mm (.26") 4.4 mm (.17") 3.7 mm (0.15") 0.04
J
u 0,00 -0.02 -0.04 -0.06 .....
-005 0,00 0,05 0.10 0.15 020 0,25 X/C 1.2 ........
Clean --e-- Iced
.=_=
E
=_
-I ;
o o
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
102 NASA/TP---2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 202
Cd-clo_n = 0.0092
LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
Cd-_ = 0.0293
T, =-5.0°C (22°F)
MVD = 20 I_m
C_-:_e,o = 0.676
Spray = 2.0 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Cl-,ced = 0.646
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Leading Edge Lower Max upper Max 4.0 mm (.16") 25 mm (.10") -- 42" Tracing _ 36" Tracing 27 mm (.11") 2.1 mm (.08") 30" Tracing 3.7 mm (.15") 2.8 mm (.11") u -002 -004 -o D6 .......................................
-0 05 00O 0 05 0 10 0 15 020 025 :,dC 1.2- - _ _-- - , + Clean --e-- Iced 1.0 0,8 = .e 0.6 o O 0,2 0,0 ........ L ......
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 AngLe of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 103
Business Jet- Run 202m
"It =-0.8°C (30°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
C_-_te,, = 0.0092
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
Cd-_d = 0.0292
MVD = 20/am
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 2.0 min Cl-_Lean = 0.676
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_-ic,d = 0.661
0.08 Ice Thickness i
Upper Max Leadin_l Edge Lower Max
-- 42" Tracing 0.06 i 36" Tracing 30" Tracing 5.0 mm (20") 4.2 mm (.17") 27 mm (.11") i 0.04 !
0.02 i 0.00 F i -0.02 -0.04 4) 06 -0.05 000 0.05 0.10 015 0.20 0.25 x/c 1.2 I 0.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
104 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 202r
C,<_, = 0.0092
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
C,_ic_ = 0.0291
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
MVD = 20 _m
Cl_clea n = 0.676
Spray = 2.0 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
AOA = 6.2 ° Cl-_e_= 0.651
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 3.7 mm (.15") 2.2 mm (.09") 0.06 _36" Tracing 2.9 mm (.12") 2.2 mm (,09") 3.7 mm (.15") 2.7 mm (.11") 30" Tracing 0.04 J 0.02 J u -002 _04 _o6 0 15 020 025 ooo 005 olo -o.o5 x/c 1,2
I
+ Clean + Iced 1.0 0.8 o 0.6
E
_J 0.4 0.2 0.0 ....
15.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
i
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 105
Business Jet - Run 203
"It = -0.8°C (30°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3 C_.c,=n= 0.0092
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
Cd.,=_= 0.0158
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Cl.clea n " 0.676
Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = 6.2 °
Cl-_ed= 0.631
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness i Lower Max Upper Max Leadina Edae -- 42" Tracing 11.1 mm (0.44") 5.60 mm (0.22") 36" Tracing 11.0 mm (0.43") 5.20 mm (0.21") - 30" Tracing 11.9 mm (0.47") 5.30 mm (0.21") 0.04 X)02
!
-0.04 -0.06 -0.05 0.00 0,05 010 0.15 020 025 x/c 1,2
i
Clean --e-- Iced
I
1.0
i
i 0.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, dog
106 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 204
Cd_,_ao = 0.0092
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
C_-_,d= 0.1104
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
MVD = 20 pm
Ci_,..o = 0.676
Spray = 22.5 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
C_-,cea = 0.632
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness Upper Max Leadin_l Eddie Lower Max 40.8 mm (1.61") 11.1 mm (0.44") 20.4 mm (0.80") -- 42" Tracing 0.06 _36" Tracing 37.7 mm (1.49") 100 mm (0.40") 19.7 mm (0.77") 44.4 mm (1,75") 11 4 mm (0,45") 22.9 mm (0.90") L 30" Tracing 004 .
ooo2
-004 - " -006 000 005 010 015 0.20 025 -0 05 X/C 1.2 i Clean --e-- Iced 1.0 i 0.6 0.4 0.8 __ 0.2 0.0 + 15.0 5,0 10.0 0.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 107
Business Jet - Run 205
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
LWC = 0.535 g/m 3
Cd-_,,,,n = 0.0092
T, =-10.0°C (13.4°F)
C,-i_ = 0.0173
MVD = 40 pm
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 1.1 min Cl..clea n - 0.676
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_-iced = 0.668
Ice Thickness
i
Leading Edge Lower Max
Upper Max
-- 42" Tracing 2.3 mm (.09") 0.06 !
2.4 mm (.09") 36" Tracin_ 30" Tracing 2.2 mm (,09") I
o.o21
J 0(30 _ -002 i 4).04 -006 _.05 0.00 0.05 015 0,20 025 X/C 1.2 I --a-Clean--e--Iced 0.8 0.6 !
-I
L
0.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15,0 Angle of Attack, deg
108 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 205r
Cd-c_o = 0.0092
LWC = 0.535 g/m _
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd._ = 0.0176
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 40 pm
C_-clean = 0.676
Spray = 1.1 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Cl-iced = 0.662
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Leadin_ Ed,qe Lower Max Upper Max -- 42" Tracing 2.8 mm (.11") 0.06 36" Tracing 1,9 mm (,08") 1.5 mm (06") 30" Tracing 0.04 0.02 o 0.00 -002 -004 -006 .........
020 025 005 0 10 0 15 -0.05 000 xJc 1.2 - --l--Clean ---t-- Iced 1.0 0.8 0.6 O O -I 0.4 --- 0.2 0.0, - ! ......
0.0 5,0 10.0 150 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 109
Business Jet - Run 206
"1", = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
LWC = 0.535 g/m 3
C,._,_,, = 0.0092
"Is =-10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0176
MVD = 40 pm
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 4.2 min C,-_l_.o = 0.676
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_-iced = 0.637
0.08 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Eddie Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 10.2 mm (0.40") 11.0 mm (0,44") 6,9 mm (0,27") 0,06 8.8 mm (0.35") 36" Tracin_l 9.1 mm (0.36") 5.6 mm (0.22") .... 30" Tracing 9,9 mm (0.39") 10.5 mm (0.41") 6.6 mm (0.26") 0.04
u j/
0(30 -o 02 -0.04 _].06 -0.05 0.(30 0,05 O.10 0 15 020 0.25 X/C 1.2 T 1.0 0.8 0.6 i rj 0,4 i 0.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
110 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 207
LWC = 0.43 g/m 3 Cd_clea n "- 0.0092
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd-_ = 0.0186
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
C_lean= 0.676
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
Ct-iced = 0.657
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness
Lower Max
Leadin_l Eddie
upper Max
2.5 mm (.10") -- 42" Tracing _36" Tracing 2.2 mm (.09") 30" Tracing 2.7 mm (.t1") 0.04 0.02 u 00(1 -002 -0 04 -006 ...........
010 015 0.20 -005 OO0 005 x/C 1.2 -- -- Clean --e-- Iced 1,0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0,2 - -_ | ._ _ 0.0 j 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 111
Business Jet - Run 208
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F) LWC = 0.43 g/m 3
Cd-c_n = 0.0092
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0301
MVD = 20 t_m
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min C_leao = 0.676
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) Cl-_ = 0.641
0.08 Ice Thickness Lower Max
upper Max Leading Edge
-- 42" Tracing 9.8 mm (.38") 5.8 mm (.23") OO6 36" Tracing 8.4 mm (.33") 53 mm (.21") 30" Tracing 9.6 mm (,38") 5.8 mm (.23") 0.04 0 O2 u 0.00 - i i -0.02 , -0.04 i _.o6 L -0.05 0.00 0,05 010 0.15 0.20 xJc
1.2 _ .......... •
Clean _ Iced r o
=_
-J 0,4 i 0.2 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
112 NASA/TP 2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 209
Cd-d_n= 0.0092
LVVC = 0.43 g/m 3
T_= -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd-_ = 0.0343
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
C_cl_n= 0.676
Spray = 22.5 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
AOA = 6.2 ° C_.iced = 0.655
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max 37.7 mm (1.48") 25.9 mm (1.02") -- 42" Tracing 0.06 i 32.6 mm (129") 22.0 mm (0.87") _36" Tracin_ 37.5 mm (1.48") 24.7 mm (0,97") -- 30" Tracing 002 .
/ u 0.017, -0.02 -004 .
-006 ..........
020 025 005 010 015 _.05 000 xJc 1,2 - -- Clean + Iced 1.0 _ * - 0.8_ - - - 0.6.
-i 0.4 15,0 5.0 10,0 Angle of Attack, dog NASA/TP--2000-210031 113
Business Jet - Run 210
It = -11.0°C (11.7°F)
LWC = 0.405 g/m 3 Cd-d_n= 0.0092
T, = -15°C (4.4°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0171
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Cl-cje,,= 0.676
Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 6.2 °
Cl-,=ed = 0.660
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Lower Max upper Max Leadin_l Eddie -- 42" Tracing 2.3 mm (.09") 36" Tracing 2.0 mrn (.08") 30" Tracing 2.3 mm (.09") 0.04
J
0.00 -0.02 -0.04 -0.06 ....
-0.05 O00 0.05 010 015 0.20 0.25 X/C 1.2 ----=-- Clean --e- Iced i i
,_==
E O =_ .,J 0.4 F 0.2 0.0' 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg 114 NAS A/TP---2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 211
LVVC = 0.405 g/m 3 Cd-d_o = 0.0092
"It = -11.0°C (11.7°F)
Cd_icl_ I = 0.0252
Ts = -15°C (4.4°F)
MVD = 20 #m
Cl-_,eao = 0.676
Spray = 4.4 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
AOA = 6.2 ° C_-_ed = 0.647
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness Lower Max Leading Edge upper Max 5.8 mm (23") 5.8 mm (.23") -- 42" Tracinc_ 5.2 mm (20") 5.2 mm (20") 36" TracinQ 6.6 mm (26") 5.7 mm (.23") 30" Tracing 0.04 0,02 u -002 .006 ..................
0.15 020 0.25 -005 000 005 010 xJc 1.2 .... _ -- I
• -.- Clean _ Iced
1.0 0.8 _ 0.5 0.4 0.2 0,0 .......
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 l 15
Business Jet - Run 212
T: = -11.0°C (11.7°F)
LVVC = 0.405 g/m 3
Cd.cl,,,n = 0.0092
T, = -15°C (4.4°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.0287
MVD = 20 pm
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 16.7 min C_de,, = 0.676
AOA = 6.2 °
C_.i_ed = 0.658
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness 30" Tracing I Upper Max I Leadin_lEd_le I Lower Max J 24.0 mm (0.95") J 21.9 mm (0,86") I 0,06 F 004 - 0.02 - u .0.02 -004 -0.06 .005 0.00 0.05 0,10 020 0,25 X/C O .d
o.o i i
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg l 16 NASA/TP---2000-210031
Business Jet- Run 213
Cd-c_o = 0.0092
LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
T, = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd-,;_ = 0.0129
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 15 tJm
C,-c_,n= 0.676
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
C_-ioed = 0.660
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max --42" Tracing 3.3 mm (.13") _36" Tracing 3.1 mm (.12") 30" Tracing 3.6 mm (.14") -002 -0.04 *0.05 ...............
0,15 O20 025 _).05 0.00 0.05 010 x/C 1.2 T I Clean +Iced 1_0 , 0.0 • 15.0 5,0 10.0 0.0 Angle of Attack, deg NASA/TP--2000-210031 117
Business Jet - Run 214
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
Cd-_,,a, = 0.0092
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.0158
MVD = 15 _m
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min C_<leao = 0.676
AOA = 6.2 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_-iced = 0.675
0.08 ice Thickness Lower Max upper Max Stagnation Line -- 42" Tracing 12.1 mm _.48") 0.06 - 36" Tracing 11.1 mm (0.44") L -- 30" Tracing 12.6 mm (0.50") 0.02 -0.02 -0.04 -0,06 <}.05 000 0.05 0.10 015 0,20 0,25 x/C 1.2 Clean --e-- Iced
! f
'_o.o! __7,/ i
0.4 !.... _
i '
0,0 5.0 10,0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
118 NAS A/TP--2000- 210031
Business Jet - Run 221
LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3 Cd-_n = 0.0081
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0151
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
MVD = 20 pm
C_cle,o = 0.228
Spray = 3.0 min
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
AOA = 1.5 ° C_._ed = 0.220
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Lower Max Upper Max Leading Edge 2.8 mm (. 11") 7.8 mm (31") 7.0 mm (27") -- 42" Tracing 6.6 mm (.26") 2.6 mm (.10") 63 mm (25") 36" Tracing 7.6 mm (.30") - 30" Tracing 7.8 mm (31") 2.6 mm (.10") o 02 0.(30 -0.02 _O.04 -0.08 ...............
015 0.20 0.25 -0.05 0.00 0,05 010 X/C 1.2 1.0 0.8 .O 0.6 O O (J
¢_
-I 0.4 0.2 0.0 ,-- 15.0 0,0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 119
Business Jet - Run 222
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F) LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Cd-c_,n= 0.0081
Ts = -5.0°C (22°F)
C_.ic_ = 0.0238
MVD = 20 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min C__c_,o = 0.228
AOA = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_-_ed = 0.222
0,08 Ice Thickness ; Upper Max Lower Max Leadin_ Edge -- 42" Tracing 14.5 mm (0.57") 5.5 mm (0.22") 13.5 mm (0.53") 0.06, _36" Tracing 14.3 mm (0.56") 4.8 mm (0.19") 12.3 mm (0.48") i i 30" Tracing 16,1 mm (0.64") 5,1 mm (0.20") 15.6 mm (0,61") 0.04 - 0,02 u -0.02 _04 -006 , -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 015 0,20 0,25 X/C --.m-- Clean _ Iced 1.0 _-_ i
o8 i
c E 0.4 0,2 0,0 ± 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg 120 NAS A/TP--2000- 210031
Business Jet - Run 223
C___,_n = 0.0081
LWC = 0.31 g/m 3
It = -0.8°C (30°F)
C_._ = 0.0125
Ts = -5.0°C (22°F)
MVD = 20 pm
Cb-c,eao = 0.228
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 2.9 min
C_-_c.d = 0.226
AOA = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 8.7 mm (34") 3.8 mm (.15") 8.3 mm (.33") 36" Tracin_l 7.7 mm (.31 ") 3.6 mm (. 14") 7.6 mm (.30") 30" Tracing 9.1 mm (36") 3,8 mm (. 15") 7.7 mm (.30") 0.02 u -0 02 _).04 -0.06 ................................
-005 0.00 005 010 015 0.20 0.25 XlC 1,2 -- --a--Clean--e--Iced 1.0 0.8_ 0,6 O O 0.4 0.2 0.0 - 15.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 121
Business Jet - Run 224
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
LWC = 0.31 g/m 3
Cd_l_,n= 0.0081
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
Cd-_ = 0.0179
MVD = 20 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Spray = 5.8 min C_-_,.,n = 0.228
AOA = 1.5 °
C_-iced = 0.232
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness
Upper Max Leadin_l Edc=le Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 17.8 mm (0.70") 7.60 mm (0.30") 16.8 mm (0.66") 0.06 _36" Tracin_ 17.3 mm (0.68") 6.80 mm (027") 13.2 mm (0.52") ..... 30" Tracin_ 17,8 mm (0.70") 6.90 mm (0.27") 15.8 mm (0.62") 0_04 I 0.02 L u .0,02 .0.04 - -006 -0.05 O00 005 010 0.15 0.20 0.25 _c 1.2
f
1.0 0.8 C
._o
0.6
! i
0.4 0.2 i i
i
I
i
0.0 '- 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
122 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 225
C___o = 0.0081
LWC = 0.50 g/m 3
T_= -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd.,_ = 0.0096
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 15 pm
Ct-_,,an = 0.228
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 3.6 min
Ct-,ce_ = 0.217
AOA = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 1.7 mm (.07") 0,06 1.7 mm (.07") 36" Tracing 30"Traong 1.7 mm (.07") 0.02 jJ o 0,00_ -0,02 • -004 , -0 05 0 oo 005 0 to 0.15 0.20 xJc
1.2- -- i " -
--=--Clean --e--Iced
1.o "
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 _ 15,0 0,0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 123
Business Jet - Run 226
"It = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
LVVC = 0.50 g/m 3 Cd-_t_,n = 0.0081
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
C_-ic_ = 0.0113
MVD = 15/_m
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) C_,_o = 0.228
Spray = 7.2 min
AOA = 1.5°
Cl__ = 0.227
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Lower Max upper Max Leadin_l Eddie -- 42" Tracing 3.8 mm (.15") 0.06 _36" Tracing 3.8 mm (.15") 30" Tracing 3.9 mm (.15") 0.04 0.02 r -002 -0.04 -0.06 -0.05 0(73 005 010 0.15 020 0.25 x/c i 0,8 O
.=_
0.0_ 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg 124 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 231
Cd-d_,,= 0.0086
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
C__ic_= 0.0196
Ts = -5.0°C (22°F)
MVD = 20 jam
Ci-deao = 0.472
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 4.0 ° Ci-iced = 0.463
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,08 Ice Thickness Lower Max Upper Max Leading Edge -- 42" Tracing 3.1 mm (.12") 1.7 mm (.07") 0,06 _36" Tracing 2.4 mm (,10") 2.3 mm (.09") 30" Tracing I 3.0 mm (,12") 1,8 mm (.07") 0k04 0.02 0.00 -0,02 -004 0.10 015 0.20 025 0.00 005 -0 05 x/c 1.2 • --=-- Clean --e--Iced 0.8 --
o.6_ / --
0.4
/
0.2 _/ 0,0 15.0 0,0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 125
Business Jet - Run 232
"It = -0.8°C (30°F) LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Cd-,_,o= 0.0086
T, = -5.0°C (22°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.0394
MVD = 20 Hm
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min Ct.clee n -" 0.472
AOA = 4.0 °
Cl-_ed= 0.470
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Lower Max
upper Max Leadin_ Eddie
-- 42" Tracing 11.3 mm (0,44") 4.50 mm (0.18") 6.30 mm (0.25") 3.80 mm (0.15") 5.40 mm (0.21") _36" Tracin_ 11.4 mm (0.45") i 30" Tracing 11.8 mm (0.47") i 5.10 mm (0.20") 5.50 mm (0.22") O.O4 0.02 0_00 _.02 -0.04 -006 -0.05 0(30 0.05 0.10 015 0.20 0.25 x/C 1.2 0.0 ..... _m 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
126 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 233
C__cl_n = 0.0086
LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd_ic_= 0.0116
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 15 pm
C,-_tean = 0.472
Spray = 2.0 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
AOA = 4.0 ° Cl-ice_ = 0.480
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
OO8 Ice Thickness Lower Max Upper Max Leading Edge 3.1 mm (.12") -- 42" Tracing] 0.06 3.0 mm (.12") 36" Tracin_l 3.3 mm (.13") 30" Tracing 0.00 !
-0.02 -0.04 .
-006 ........
015 020 025 -005 0.00 005 0.10 xtc 1.2 - - ---=--Clean --e--Iced 0.8 ....
0.6 0.4 0.2 0,0 ; ..........
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 127
Business Jet - Run 234
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F) LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
Cd-_l_,o = 0.0086
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0142
MVD = 15/am
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 6.0 min Cl.clea n = 0.472
AOA = 4.0 °
Cl-_ed= 0.472
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 12.4 mm (0,49") 7.40 mm (0.29") _36" Tracing 10,2 mm (0,40") i6,40 mm (0.25") .... 30" Tracing 13.2 mm (0.52") 7.80 mm (0.31") 0.04 -002 -0.04 -0,06 -005 o.0o 0.05 0.10 015 020 0.25 XJC 1.2 Clean --e--- Iced L 1.0 0.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
128 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 235
Cd_,_o = 0.0086
LWC = 0.535 g/m 3
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
C__,o_ = 0.0.132
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 40 I_m
CI-cleao = 0.472
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts) Spray = 1.1 min
Cl-_,d = 0.467
AOA = 4.0 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Lower Max Upper Max Leadin_ Edge 2.0 mm (.08") -- 42" Tracing 0.06 2.5 mm (. 10") 36" Tracing 2.4 mm (. 10") 30" Tracing 0.o2 J o0o -002 -004 -006 .........................
o 20 025 .005 0.00 005 0 10 0 15 x/c 1.2 Clean --e-- Iced ._e o .J 0.2 !
0.0 - 15.0 0.0 5,0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 129
Business Jet - Run 236
"1", = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
LWC = 0.535 g/m _
Ca-chin= 0.0086
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd._,_= 0.0252
MVD = 40 ram
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 4.2 min C_-_l_n = 0.472
AOA = 4.0 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) Cl-_d = 0.455
0.08 Ice Thickness upper Max Leadin_l Eddie Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 11.5 mm (0.45") 4.90 mm (0.19") 6.80 mm (0.27") 0.06 _ 36" Tracing 10.9 mm (0.43") 4.80 mm (0.19") 7.70 mm (0.30") - 30" Tracing 10.9 mm (0.43") 4.90 mm (0.19") 8.00 mm (0,32") 0.04 0,00 -002 .0.05 O00 005 010 0.15 020 0,25 x/C 1.2 .e O O (.,)
=_
0.0: 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
130 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Business Jet - Run 237
C,<l_n = 0.0086
LWC = 0.405 g/m _
"It = -11.0°C (11.7°F)
C__,c_= 0.0113
T, =-15°C (4.4°F)
MVD = 20 _m
C,<teao = 0.472
Spray = 1.5 min
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
C1__ = 0.462
AOA = 4.0 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness Upper Max Leadin_l Eddie Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 1.9 mm (.08") 36" Tracing 1.6 mm (.06") 1,8mm(.07") 30" Tracing 0.02 _ _/ 000 1 -002 -004 , -0.06 ................
015 020 0.25 _)05 0.00 0 05 X/C 1.2 ---=--- Clean --e-- Iced 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 - 15.0 5.0 10.0 0.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 13 !
Business Jet - Run 238
"It = -11.0°C (11.7°F)
LVVC = 0.405 g/m 3
C_-cb_o = 0.0086
T, =-15°C (4.4°F)
C__,c_= 0.0169
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 90.0 m/s (175 kts)
Spray = 4.4 min Cl-_)ean = 0.472
AOA = 4.0 °
C_-iced = 0.453
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leadin_ Edge Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 6.5 mm (26") 5,9 mm (.23") 36" Tracing 4.9 mm (.19") 5.3 mm (.21") 30" Tracing 5.5 mm (,22") 5.8 mm (23") 0.04 002 !
0(30 -0.02 -004 -0.06 ........................................................
4J.05 000 005 &10 0 15 0.20 0.25 xJc 1.2 "5 O
5-
0,0 0.0 5,0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
132 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Appendix D3
Appendix D3
Test Results, Commercial Transport
NASA/TP--2000-210031 133
Commercial Transport- Run 101
Tt = 0.0°C (32°F)
LWC = 0.41 g/m 3
T, = -10°C (13°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 146 m/s (284 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = 0.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Eddie Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 15.7 mm (0.62") 6,40 mm (0,25") 13.5 mm (053") O00 12.7 mm (0.50") 7,10 mm (0.28") 11.2 mm (0,44") _36" Tracing 14.2 mm (0.56") 14.2 mm (0.56") 30" Tracin_ -o.o6 .......
4).05 o0o o,o5 O.lO o15 0.20 025 x]c
134 NASA/TP---2000-210031
Commercial Transport- Run 102
LVVC = 0.46 g/m 3
Tt = 0.0°C (32°F)
T, = -10°C (13°F)
MVD = 20 p_m
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = 0.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0£ Z
r
Ice Thickness t Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max 002 i -- 42" Tracin_l 8.6 mm (.34") 0.8 mm (.03") 7.9 mm (.31") --36" Tracing 84 mm (.33") 0.8 mm (.03") 7.9 mm (.31") 000 u 30" Tracing 107 mm (A2") 0.8 mm (.03") 9.7 mm (38") _)02 -004 -0 06 ...........
0 10 0 15 020 -005 0 O0 005 x/C
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 135
Commercial Transport- Run 103
It = 0.0°C (32°F) LWC = 0.46 g/m 3
T, = -10°C (13°F)
MVD = 20 I.tm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = 0.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o.o8 [ I
o04 1
I i Ice Thickness 0.02 upper Max Leading Ed[_e Lower Max -- 42" Tracin_ 44.5 mm (1.75") 0.80 mm f0,03") 44.5 mm (1.75") o.co 36" Tracing 40.9 mm (1.61") 0.80 mm (0.03") 22.4 mm (0.88") -- 30" Tracing 52.3 mm (2,06") 0.80 mm (0.03") 41,1 mm (1.62") -0.02 -004 -006 .................................................
-0.05 o.oo 0.05 0.1o o15 020 0.25 x/c
136 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport - Run 104
LVVC = 0.339 g/m 3 Ci.clea n = 0.215
Tt = -12.0°C (10.5°F)
Cl-,c,d= 0.211
T, = -20°C (4.0°F)
MVD = 15 pm
Spray = 5.9 min
V = 128 m/s (248 kts)
AOA = 1.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Ice Thickness
Lower Max 0,02 Upper Max
Leadin_Edge
-- 42" Tracing 102 mm(0.40" I
9.1 mm (0.36")
36" Tracin_
0D0 11.2 mm (0.44")
30" Tracing
-002 -0.04 J306 ; .........................
0.25 -005 000 005 0 10 0 15 0.20 )de • L,
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 137
Commercial Transport- Run 105
-It = -12.0°C (10.5°F) LWC = 0.339 g/m 3
Cl_clea n = 0.215
Ts = -20°C (-4.0°F)
Ct-ic,,d = 0.209
MVD = 15 ,um
V = 128 m/s (248 kts) Spray = 22 min
AOA = 1.7°
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.£ Ice Thickness 0.02 upper Max Leadin_l Eddie Lower Max -- 42" Tracin_l 38.6 mm 11.52") 36" Tracin_ 34.3 mm (1.35")
ooo !
30" Tracing 40.4 mm (1.59") _).02 L r *O.04 i !
_}.06 .............................................
,.0.05 0.00 0.05 0 10 0 15 0.20 0.25 x/c
138 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport- Run 106
LVVC = 0.339 g/m 3 Cd-cl_o= 0.0085
Tt = -12.0°C (10.5°F)
Cd._ = 0.0120
T, =-20°C (-4.0°F)
MVD = 15 p.m
C_-_leao = 0.097
V = 128 m/s (248 kts) Spray = 5.9 min
AOA = 0.7 ° Ci-iced = 0.100
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04 ,
IceThickness
Lower Max
Upper Max
Leading Edge
0.02 • 10,7 mm (0.42") -- 42" Tracing] o
8.6 mm (0.34")
36" Tracin_l
9.7 mm (0,38")
30" Tracing
000 : -002 -004 JJO_ ..................................
-005 0.00 005 0 10 0 15 020 025 x/c
NASA/TP--2000-210031 139
Commercial Transport - Run 106rl
Tt = -12.0°C (10.5°F) LWC = 0.339 g/m 3
Cd._,_o= 0.0085
T, = -20°C (-4.0°F)
C__,_ = 0.0120
MVD = 15 p.m
V = 128 m/s (248 kts) Spray = 5.9 min C_,e.o = 0.097
AOA = 0.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C,.,_ = 0.099
0,08 0.06 Ice Thickness Lower Max upper Max Leadin_l Eddie u 9.7 mm (0.38") -- 42" Tracing] 8.9 mm (035") 36" Tracin_ 0.1_ --- 30" Tracing 10.2 mm (0.40") -O 02 _),04 _0.06 -005 000 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 yJc 140 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport- Run 107
Cd-_i_o= 0.0085
LWC = 0.339 g/m 3
Tt = -12.0°C (10.5°F)
C_.,:_ = 0.0163
T, = -20°C (-4.0°F)
MVD = 15 Hm
C,-_,.,o= 0.097
Spray = 22 min
V = 128 m/s (248 kts)
AOA = 0.7 ° C_ice_ = 0.099
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 / 0C Ice Thickness Lower Max upper Max LeadinB Edge 37.8 mm (1.49") -- 42" Tracing 34.3 mm (1.35") 36" Tracing 0.09 30" Tracing 40.9 mm (1.61") -002 -0 04 _).06 ..............................
0.25 -0.05 0.00 005 0 10 0 15 020 YJc NAS A/TP--2000-210031 141
Commercial Transport- Run 108
T, = -12.0°C (10.5°F) LVVC = 0.339 g/m 3
C_._.o = 0.0085
Ts = -20°C (-4.0°F)
Cd.io_ = 0.0163
MVD = 15 _m
V = 128 m/s (248 kts)
Spray = 29.3 min Ci-clean = 0.097
AOA = 0.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) CI-iced = 0.098
O08 0.06 0.04 i i Ice Thickness 0.02 i Lower Max Upper Max Leading Edge u -- 42" Tracing 49.8 mm (196") 46.0 mm (1.81") o.oo i 56.1 mm (2.21") -0-02 - -0_04 ,
F
.006 i -0.10 -005 000 005 0 10 015 020 X/C
142 NASA/TP--2000- 210031
Commercial Transport - Run 110
LVVC = 0.341 g/m 3 Cd-_l_,n = 0.0087
T, = -6.33°C (20.0°F)
C_.ic_ = 0.0154
T, = -14.6°C (5.1°F)
MVD = 21 pm
Cl_ctea n = 0.215
Spray = 5.7 min
V = 129 m/s (250 kts)
AOA = 1.7 ° Cl-ice_ = 0.201
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 OO6 0C Ice Thickness Lower Max upper Max Leadinc_ Edge 7.1 mm (.28") -- 42" Tracing 5.8 mm (.23") 5.6 mm (.22") _36" TracinEJ 6.4 mm (.25") 5.1 mm (20") 5.8 mm (.23") 0¸(30 30" Tracing 7.9 mm (.31") 5.8 mm (23") 84 mm (.33") _0.02 -004 -oo6 ......................
020 025 _).o5 o oo 005 o lO o 15 x/c
in
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 143
Commercial Transport - Run 111
Tt = -6.33°C (20.0°F) LWC = 0.341 g/m 3
Cd-_e,,= 0.0087
Ts = -14.6°C (5.1°F)
C_-,ced = 0.0288
MVD = 21 _m
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 21.1 min Cl-_,,,n= 0.203
AOA = 1.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_ = 0.196
0O4 Ice Thickness 0,02 Upper Max Leading Edge Lower M_ -- 42" Tracing 35.9 mm (1.42") 27.7 mm (1.09") 36.1 mm (1,42" 33.3 mm(1.31") 28.5 mm (1.12") 31.4 mm (1.24") 0,00 36.7 mm (1.45") 29.2 mm (1.15") 34.9 mm (1.38") _0,02 -0.04 _.o6 _.o5 000 0.05 010 0.15 0,20 0,25 x/C .......
144 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport- Run 112
LVVC = 0.341 g/m 3 C___l_n = 0.0085
T, = -6.33°C (20.0°F)
C_.ic_ = 0.0148
Ts = -14.6°C (5.1°F)
MVD = 21 pm
C,-clean = 0.097
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 5.7 min
AOA = 0.7 ° C_ = 0.096
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 Ice Thickness 0.02
Lower Max
Upper Max Leading Edge 7.1 mm (28") 41 mm (.16") 7.6mm(.30") -- 42" Tracin_ 5.6mm(.22") 7.6mm(.30") 6.4mm(25") _36" Tracin_ 0(30 5.1mm(20") 91mm(36") 30" Tracing 7.6mm(.30") _).02 _]04 -006 .............................
-005 000 005 0.10 015 0.20 x/C 1.2 _ ....
,oi _+c,o.o
0.6 _ . - - ,
'5
E
o
5-
0.0 _ , - - -0.4 ...........
-5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 145
Commercial Transport- Run 113
It = -6.33°C (20.0°F)
LVVC = 0.341 g/m 3 C,_-,=_=,n = 0.0085
T,, = -14.6°C (5.1°F)
Cd-,:,_= 0.0209
MVD = 21 pm
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 42.4 miin Cl_clea n "" 0.097
AOA = 0.7 °
C___.,,_, = 0.096
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
oo8 F o.o6 o.£ Ice Thickness 0.02 UDDer Max Leadina EdRe Lower Max 71.2 mm (2.80") 52.1 mm (205") 72.3 mm (2.85") O.OOL 63.8 mm (2.51") 49.5 mm (1.95") 63.2 mm (2.49") 70.6 mm (278") 60.5 mm (2.38") 71.6 mm (2.82") -002 , -oo4 -o.06 .............................................
-o 10 -005 0.00 005 010 0.15 o,2o yJc
146 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport - Run 114
C__oj_,= 0.0085
T, = -6.33°C (20.0°F) LVVC = 0.341 g/m 3
Cd-ioed = 0.0286
Ts = -14.6°C (5.1°F)
MVD = 21 pm
C_-cleao = 0.097
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 28.3 miin
AOA = 0.7 °
Ci-iced = 0.100
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
jJ
Ice Thickness 0.02 upper Max Leadin 9 Edge Lower Max 48.0 mm (1.89") 42.4 mm (1.67") 47.2 mm (1.86") 41.7mm(1.64") 38.1 mm(1.50") 40.9mm(1.61") 44.5 mm (1.75") 40.9 mm (1.61") 43.9 mm (1.73") i _ 30" Tracing -002 -0 04 -006 ...................................
4) 10 -005 000 0 05 010 015 0.20 xJC
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 147
Commercial Transport - Run 115
LVVC = 0.341 g/m 3 C_-c,_n= 0.0085
Tt = -6.33°C (20.0°F)
C_-ic_ = 0.0209
T, = -14.6°C (5.1°F)
MVD = 21 I_m
CI-deao = 0.097
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 21.1 min
AOA = 0.7 °
C_-,_ed = 0.095
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0.04 0.02 Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max I I Ice Thickness [ I o 30"Tracing I 34.8mm(1.37) 31.8mm(1.25") 36.1mmt1.42" 1 00(1 -0.02 - -0.04 -0.06 -005 000 &05 0.10 0.15 020 025 x/C 1.2- ..... , i --=--Clean --e--Iced ! i, -= 1.0 ! I_ .e O I -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
148 NAS A/TP--2000- 210031
Commercial Transport- Run 122
C_<_,_ = 0.0087
LWC = 0.563 g/m 3
Tt = -1.06°C (29.5°F)
Cd.,,=,_ = 0.0280
Ts = -9.49°C (14.3°F)
MVD = 21 IJ.m
C_,_.o = 0.208
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Spray = 4.9 min
AOA = 1.6 ° C___,,_ = 0.202
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Q£ Ice Thickness 0.02 Leading Edge Lower Max Upper Max 17.5 mm (0,69") 4.30 mm (0.17") 12.4 mm (0.49") 16.5 mm (0,65") 380 mm (0.15") 11.4 mm (0.45") 0,00 4.10 mm (0.16") 9.9 mm (039") 17.0 mm (0.67") _).02 -004 r -006 .....................
020 0.25 -005 000 005 010 0 15 X/C
NASA/TP--2000-210031 149
Commercial Transport - Run 123
"It = -1.06°C (29.5°F) LWC = 0.563 g/m 3 Cd-_,_an = 0.0087
Ts = -9.49°C (14.3°F) Cd-io_= 0.0799
MVD = 21 I_m
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Ckclean = 0.208
Spray = 18.5 miin
AOA = 1.6 °
Cl-_.d = 0.184
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0_C_ Ice Thickness 0.02 Upper Max Leadina EdA( t L?w_r M{Jx 56.9 mm (2.24") 10.2 mm (0A0") 51.8 mm (2.04") 54.1 mm (2.13") 10.7 mm (0.42") 48.5 mm (191") 57.2 mm (225") 11.2 mm (044") 59.2 mm (2.33") -002 _.04 -0.06 -010 <105 0.00 0O5 010 o15 020 x/c
150 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport - Run 124
C___,_o = 0.0085
LVVC = 0.563 g/m 3
Tt = -1.06°C (29.5°F)
C___ = 0.0269
T, = -9.49°C (14.3°F)
MVD = 21 p.m
Ct-_teao = 0.097
Spray = 4.9 min
V = 130 m/s (253 kts)
AOA = 0.7 ° Cl-iced = 0.088
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0¸(38 0.04 Ice Thickness
upper Max Leadin_l Edge Lower Max
-- 42" Tracin9 15,5 mm (0.61") 4.60 mm (0.18") 14.2 mm (0.56") o _36" Tracin_ 14.5 mm (0.57") 3.60 mm (0.14") 13.2 mm (0.52") 30" Tracing 12.7 mm (0.50") 4.10 mm (0.16") 14.5 mm (0.57") 0.00 -0.02 -0 O4 -oo6 ..................................
-oo5 ooo 005 O.lO o 15 020 025 xJc 1,2 S ....
1.0 : --I- Clean --e-- Iced / o,; .... :
L '
0.4 IE ¢,) 0.2 0.8 00l i -0.4 -5.0 0,0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 151
Commercial Transport- Run 126
"It = -1.06°C (29.5°F)
LWC = 0.563 g/m 3 Cd-c,_n= 0.0085
T, = -9.49°C (14.3°F) Cd-iced = 0.1422
MVD = 21 p.m
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Cl.clea n -" 0.095
Spray = 24.6 min
AOA = 0.6 °
Cl-,:_d= 0.072
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 • 0.06 1 0,04 - Ice Thickness 0.02 Upper Max Leadina Edoe Lqwer M_x 77.5 mm (3.05") 11.2 mm IOA4" t 72.6 mm (2.86" 1 66.3 mm (2.61") 14.5 mm (0.57") 64.0 mm (2.52") 0.00 F 76.5 mm (3.01") 15.2 mm (0.60") 72.4 mm (2.85") _0.02 .
-0,04 !
i , _1 --30"Tracing -006 ..........................................
-0.10 _.05 O00 005 0 10 0.15 020 x/c
152 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport - Run 127
LVVC = 0.563 g/m 3 C,_.d,,,° = 0.0085
"It = -1.06°C (29.5°F)
C,j.,c_ = O.1398
T, = -9.49°C (14.3°F)
MVD = 21 #m
C+.d,,,o = 0.097
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Spray = 18.5 min
AOA = 0.7 °
Cl-ic_ = 0.079
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
J
30" Tracing 0.02 u 0.130 -O.O2 4) 04 4).06 ............................
-0,05 000 005 0 lO 0 15 020 025 xJc 0,8 + 0.0 5.0 10.0 15+0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 153
Commercial Transport - Run 128
LWC = 0.341 g/m 3
Tt = -6.33°C (20.0°F) C_-_i,ao = 0.0085
T, = -14.6°C (5.1°F) C,_iced = 0.0112
MVD = 21 p.m
Ci-cl,ao = 0.095
V = 129 m/s (250 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 0.6 °
C,-ic_d = 0.098
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0,06 0.04 Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max -- 42" Tracing 2.0 mm (.08") 2.5 mm (.10") 2.0 mm (.08") _36" Tracing 1.8 mm (.07") 2.3 mm (09") 1.5 mm (.06") 0.00 30" Tracing 2.0 mm (.08") 2.5 mm (. 10") 1.5 mm (.06") -0.02 -0.04 -0.06 ...............................................
,305 000 0.05 0 10 O. 15 0.20 0.25 X/C
1.2l ............ ,- -
--B- Clean ---e-- Iced 7" F I 1.0 _ _ - 0.8 0.6 (3 o.,
=_
..J
o.2 i/"
o o/
-0.2 .
!
-0.4 ............. i ..............
-5,0 0.0 5.0 10,0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
154 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport- Run 129
C_-_,_,n = 0.0085
LWC = 0.563 g/m 3
T, = -1.06°C (29.5°F)
Cd-,c_= 0.0154
Ts = -9.49°C (14.3°F)
MVD = 21 pm
CL-_ean = 0.097
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 0.7 ° C_.,ce_ = 0.092
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08
J
J
Ice Thickness Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max u 1.5 mm (.06") 5.1 mm (.20") 6.1 mm (24") -- 42" TracinQ 4.6 mm (. 18") 1,5 mm (.06") 4.3 mm (,17") 36" Tracing 0(30 48 mm (.19") 1,5 mm (.06") 5.1 mm (,20") -- 30" Tracing -002 -0.04 - -006 ............................
-0.05 o0o 005 0.10 0.15 020 025 x/c 0.8 0.6 ._e 0.4 o
5- 0.2
0.0 -0.2 -0.4 ..... _ ..............
-5.0 0.0 5.0 10,0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 155
Commercial Transport - Run 130
T, = 0.33°C (32.0°F) LWC = 0.42 g/m 3 Cd.clea n = 0.0085
T, = -8.14°C (16.7°F)
C_-icoa = 0.1168
MVD = 56 pm
C,.c_,a, = 0.095
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Spray = 18.0 min
AOA = 0.6 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) Cl-,ced = 0.078
o o8 0 o6 004r Ice Thickness Lower Max
upperMax Leading Edge
5 10 mm (0.20") -- 42" Tracin_l 43.9 mm (1.73") 384 mm I151"/ 442 mm (1.74") 560 mm (022")
i -- 36" Tracin£1 36.1 mm (142")
-- 30" Tracing 470 mm (185") 560 mm (0.22") 368 mm (1 45") 000 [ -002 -
!
-0 04 L -o 06 ........................................
-005 ooo 005 OlO o15 020 o 25 x/c
156 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport - Run 131
Cd__, = 0.0085
LVVC = 0.42 g/m 3
T, = 0.89°C (33.0°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.1027
T, = -7.60°C (17.7°F)
MVD = 56 pm
Cl.c_,,,= 0.095
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Spray = 18.0 min
AOA = 0.6 ° Cl-ic,,d = 0.082
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0.04 Ice Thickness 0.02 Lower Max Upper Max Leading Edge 33.0 mm (1.30") -- 42" Tracin_l 21,6 mm (0.85") 4.80 mm (0.19") _ 36" Tracing 18,8 mm (0.74") 2.80 mm (0.11") 28.2 mm {1.11" / 0.0(3 29.0 mm (1.14") 30" Tracing 178 mm (0.70") 3,60 mm (0.14") -002 4.04 .006 .........................
-005 000 005 0 10 0 15 020 025 X/C
NASA/TP--2000-210031 157
Commercial Transport- Run 133
"It = 1.44°C (34.0°F)
LWC = 0.42 g/m 3
Cd.o_,, = 0.0085
T, = -7.07°C (18.7°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0251
MVD = 56 pm
V = 130 m/s (253 kts)
Spray = 18.0 min C_.de,,= 0.093
AOA = 0.5 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) Cl-iced = 0.083
i 0.06 • 0.04 Ice Thickness 0.02 Lower Max Upper Max Leadin_l Edge -- 42" Tracin_ 292 mm (1.15") 9.10 mm (0.36" / 14.5 mm (0.57") 36" Tracing 8,60 mm 10.34"/ 0.00 • 6.60 mm (0.26") 10,7 mm (0,42") 30" Tracing 11.4 mm (0.45") _.02 !
L
!
_.o6 I -005 0.00 0.05 0.10 015 0.20 025 XJC
158 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport- Run 141
Cd__l_o = 0.0085
T, = -9.11°C (15.0°F) LVVC = 0.40 g/m 3
Cd-ic,_= 0.0177
T, = -17.3°C (0.3°F)
MVD = 42 _.m
Ci.clea n _- 0.097
V = 128 m/s (249 kts) Spray = 6.7 min
AOA = 0.7 °
C,.i_ = 0.091
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0,06 0.04 Ice Thickness 0.02 Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max 16.0 mm (0.63") 11.7 mm (0.46") 15.7 mm (0.62") -- 42" Tracin_l 145 mm (0.57") 11.7 mm (0.46") 13.5 mm (0.53") 36" Tracin_l 0.00 30" Tracing 15.0 mm (0.59") 12.7 mm (0.50") 13.2 mm (052") -002 -004 _1.06 ...............................
-005 o00 oo5 010 0_15 020 xJc 1.2 - - 0.8 1.0 _ --=-'- Clean --e--- Iced + 0.6 c o Qo ........ , ......
.,/
0.0 _ _ • -0.2 _ -0.4 ..............
-50 0.0 5,0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 159
Commercial Transport - Run 142
"It = -9.11°C (15.0°F) LWC = 0.40 g/m 3 Cd-_n = 0.0085
T, = -17.3°C (0.3°F) Cd_,,_= 0.0127
MVD = 42 _m
V = 128 m/s (249 kts) C_,e,n = 0.095
Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 0.6 °
Cl-_ = 0.087
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0,06 0.04
Ice Thickness
Upper Max LeadingEdge LowerMax
4.1 mm (.16") 3.6 mm (.14") 4.6 mm (.18") -- 42" Tracin_ _ 36" Tracing 4.1 mm (.16") 3.3 mm (.13") 3.8 mm (.15") 0.00 -- 30"Tracing 4.1 mm(.16") 3.3 mm(.13") 4.3 mm (.17") -0.02 -0.04 -006 -005 O.OO 005 0.10 015 020 0.25 x/c 1.2 - - i +Clean--Iced _ 0.8 0.6
.e
¢)
E=
O O o.4_ / , 0.2 _ - 0.0 - -0.2 -0.4 ............
-5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
160 NAS A/TP--2000- 210031
Commercial Transport- Run 143
Cd<le.o= 0.0085
LVVC = 0.65 g/m 3
Tt = -1.33°C (29.0°F)
C_._ = 0.0443
T, = -9.76°C (13.8°F)
MVD = 42 lam
Ct..clea n = 0.095
Spray = 5.3 min
V = 130 m/s (253 kts)
AOA = 0.6 ° C,-ic,d= 0.085
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 OC Ice Thickness 0.02 Lower Max Upper Max Leading Edge 19.1 mm (0.75") o -- 42" Tracin_l 21.6 mm (0.85") 4.60 mm (0.18") 18.8 mm (0.74") _ 36" Tracina 23.6 mm (0.93") 510 mm (020") 21.6 mm (0.85") 30" Tracing 23.6 mm (0.93") 5.30 mm (O21") _302 -004 *0.06 ..........................
-005 0.00 005 0 10 0 15 0 20 02,5 X,'C 1.2 - - - 1.0 0.8 0,6 0.4 tE (J 0.2 -0.2 0.0 -0.4 ............
-5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 161
Commercial Transport- Run 144
T_= -3.28°C (25.5°F) LVVC = 0.40 g/m 3
Cd-_l_n= 0.0085
T, = -11.6°C (10.4°F)
Cd-iced = 0.0181
MVD = 42 pm
V = 130 m/s (253 kts)
Spray = 3.0 min Cl_clea n "" 0.097
AOA = 0.7 °
Cl-_ed= 0.093
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 Ice Thickness 0.02
Upper Max Leading Edge Lower Max
9.1 mm (.36") 3.3 mm (.13") 8.1 mm (32")
-- 42" Tracin_l 0.00 -- 36" Tracin_l 8.6 mm (.34") 3.3 mm (.13") 7.9 mm (.31") 30" Tracing 9.1 mm (.36") 3.6 mm (.14") 8.1 mm (.32") -002 _.04 -006 -o.o5 000 005 0.10 015 020 025 yJc
.e
o o 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
162 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Commercial Transport- Run 145
Tt = -3.28°C (25.5°F) LWC = 0.40 g/m 3 Cd_,_,. = 0.0085
T, = -11.6°C (10.4°F) Cd._ = 0.0320
MVD = 42 pm
C,<,ea. = 0.097
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Spray = 11.2 min
AOA = 0.7 °
C,__e_= 0.085
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0£ Ice Thickness upper Max Leadin_l Edge Lower Max --42" Tracin_l 27.7 mm (1.09") 30.0 mm (1,18") _36"Tracin_l 29.0mm(1,14") 8.90mm(0.35") 27.9mm(1.10") 0.00 30"Tracin 9 29.5mm(1.16") 910mm(0.36") 28.2mm(1,11") -002 -004 -006 .............................
-0,o5 o.oo 005 OlO o15 0.20 025 x/c 1,2 Clean --e-- Iced 1.0 0.8
i
0.6 .,.,t
==
0,4 tJ 0.2
o,o; ___ -0,2
-0.4 ....................
-5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 163
Commercial Transport - Run 145m
LWC = 0.40 g/m 3 Cd-d_n= 0.0085
Tt = -3.28°C (25.5°F)
Cd.,=,_ = 0.0301
T, = -11.6°C (10.4°F)
MVD = 42 p.m
C_c,,,,,= 0.095
V = 130 m/s (253 kts) Spray = 11.2 min
AOA = 0.6 °
C__,=,_ = 0.086
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0,08 0,00 0.04 0.02 J Ice Thickness Lower Max Upper Max I Leading Edge J J 30" Tracing 269 mm I1.06") J 860 mm (0.34") J 26.2 mm (1.03" t ODO -0.02 -0D8 ..............................
-0.05 0.00 0 05 0.10 0 15 0.20 0.25 X/C
164 NASA/TP--2000-210031
Appendix D4
Appendix D4
Test Results, General Aviation
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 165
General Aviation - Run 601
T, = -0.8°C (30°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3 C_-_leao = 0.0099
T, = -5.0°C (22°F) Cd-,cad = 0.0155
MVD = 20 pm
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) Cl_clea n = 0.272
Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = -1.7 °
Cl-io., = 0.253
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 /j j_
J
0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
36" Tracing 3.0 mm (.12") 28 mm (.11")
o
3.0 mm (.12") 2.8 mm (.11")
.... 30" Tracing
_02 -004 , i
L
-006 -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 x/c 2.0 ,- ------ ........
---e-- Clean --e-- Iced i I
._e
O i
i !
-0.5 -10,0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20,0 Angle of Attack, deg
166 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 602
Cd<,_a,= 0.0099
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -0.8°C (30°F)
Cd-,o_ = 0.0201
Ts = -5.0°C (22°F)
MVD = 20 I_m
C_<_e.0 = 0.273
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = -1.7 ° C,-ice_ = 0.243
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0.04 r
__Maximum Ice Thickness
i 002 •
_ J--36"Tracin_] 9.4UPmP(.r37") 7.6L°w(e.r30 '')
¢J 0.00 4).02
0"Tracing 8.6mm(34) 81mm(32)
4].04 : 43.06 ........................
020 025 4) 05 0.00 005 0.10 0.15 x/c .e o (J -05 ......................... _ .....
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 167
General Aviation - Run 602m
TI = -0.8°C (30.0°F) LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3
T, = -5.0°C (22.0°F)
MVD = 20 _m
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = -1.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 r 0,06_ 0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
-- 30" Tracing 9.9 mm (.39") 8.9 mm (.35")
0.00 _102 -004 -0.06 l -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 xJc
7 r, _i _!:_ i 2 3 4
I ! _ t !
168 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 603
Cd-_n = 0.0099
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
T, =-0.8°C (30.0°F)
C_.ic_ = 0.0466
T, = -5.0°C (22.0°F)
MVD = 20 }Jm
Ci-o_e.n = 0.274
Spray = 22.5 min
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts)
AOA = -1.7 ° C___e_ = 0.221
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 J 0.06
Maximum Ice Thickness
_, f I I Upper I Lower
0.02
\ / I m36" Tracing 125.7 mm(1.01")i 25.7 mm (1.01")
/ I - 30" Tracin_1128.4 mm (1.12") 27.4 mm (1.08")
0.00 -0.02 -004 -006 -- ' 000 0 05 0 10 0.15 0.20 -005 x/c 2.0 Clean --e-- Iced
15 . j,,_-__
1.0 + I ........ *_ - .,.t c ._o o o 0.5 ..i 0,0 -- --' Z 3 4 :$: -0.5 .... d . . , 15,0 20.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 169
General Aviation - Run 606
T, = -5.9°C (20.8°F) LWC = 0.43 g/m 3 Cd.clea n = 0.0099
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F) Cd._ = 0.0124
MVD = 20 _m
Cl-:lean = 0.274
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = - 1.7 °
CI-iced = 0.258
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 :
! J
0.04 .
Maximum Ice Thickness
!
I Lower
Upper
o_o2 F
m 36" Tracing 2.3 mm (.09")
2.5 mm (.10")
-- 30" Tracing 2.5 mm (.10") 3.8 mm (.15")
0,00 -0.02 F -0.04 ; i 4).06 -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 020 0.25 x/C 2.0 i " ---m--- Clean ---e-- Iced 1.0 i .e ¢J O (J 0.54 -0.5 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 Angle of Attack,, deg
170 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 607
C___o = 0.0099
LWC = 0.43 g/m 3
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd_,_ = 0.0158
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
C,<,eao= 0.274
Spray = 6.0 min
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts)
AOA = -1.7 ° C,.,=d = 0.253
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02
36" Tracing 7.6 mm (.30") 8.9 mm (.35")
7.9 mm (.31") 9.4 mm (.37")
30" Tracing
O00 _02 020 0,25 -005 0D0 005 010 015 xJc 2.0 ....
Clean _ Iced
E
-0.5 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20,0 -10.0 -5.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 171
General Aviation - Run 608
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F) LWC = 0.43 g/m 3
Cd-d_,n = 0.0099
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd-+c,_ = 0.0241
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts)
Spray = 22.5 min C,-_,e.o = 0.275
AOA = -1.7 °
C,-+ced = 0.244
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
29.2 mm (1.15") 29.0 mm (1.14")
32.5 mm (1.28") 32.8 mm (1.29")
-0.02 F -0.04 -006 -005 000 005 010 015 0.20 ( x/c 2.0- Clean --e-- Iced
1.5
0.0 =
_.5_ .............. , , q
-10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 150 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
172 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 609
LWC = 0.33 g/m 3 C__c,_o = 0.0099
T, = -11.0°C (11.7°F)
C,.ic_ = 0.0126
T, = -15.0°C (4.4°F)
MVD = 20 _tm
C,-=,ean = 0.272
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = -1.7 °
C,-ice_= 0.258
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
jJ
Maximum Ice Thickness
Lower
Upper
1.5 mm (.06") 1.8 mm (.07")
-- 36" Tracing
2.0 mm (.08") 2.3 mm (.09")
30" Tracing
-002 .006 ........................
-005 0.00 005 010 0.15 020 x/c 2.0 --i-Clean--o--Iced 0.0 -0,5 t -5.0 0.0 5.0 10,0 15.0 20.0 -10.0 Angle of Attack, deg _i!ii!L i _ _:' :!i:i_ii _!:i_i ¸
NASA/TP--2000-210031 173
General Aviation - Run 610
Tt = -11.0°C (11.7°F) LWC = 0.33 g/m 3 C_-:l_n = 0.0099
T, = -15.0°C (4.4°F) C__ic_= 0.0147
MVD = 20 tam
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) CI-cl.an = 0.268
Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = -1.7 °
C_-,=ed = 0.253
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06
Maximum Ice Thickness
Lower
Upper
0.02
4.6 mm (.18")
m 36" Tracin 9 5.1 mm (.20")
4.8 mm (.19") 5.6 mm (.22")
30" Tracing
0.00 -0.02 -0.04 -0.06 .....
-005 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 020 025 x/C 20, -- !
" + Clean _ iced
!
I
1.5 i 1.0 i r
E
O 0.5 _J L
i
-0.5 = -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15,0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
174 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 611
Cd-_,_o= 0.0099
LWC = 0.33 g/m 3
T, = -11.0°C (11.7°F)
Cd_,_ = 0.0192
T, = -15.0°C (4.4°F)
MVD = 20 _m
Cl-_e,n= 0.272
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = -1.7 ° Ct-i,e_= 0.242
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 OO4
Maximum Ice Thickness
Lower
2,, Tracing
Upper
22.4 mm (.88")
19,1 mm (.75")
o
18.5 mm (.73") 22.1 mm (87")
3.
racing
_)04 0 15 0 20 0.25 000 005 010 x/c 2.0 - + Clean + Iced 1.5 e O O -I 0.0 -0.5 , .... _ .... _ ..............
-10.0 -5.0 0.0 50 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 175
General Aviation - Run 612
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F) LWC = 0.56 g/m 3 Cd-d,,,,n = 0.0099
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd-,:,,d = 0.0121
MVD = 15 p.m
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts)
Spray = 2.0 min Cl-_,,,o= 0.272
AOA = -1.7 °
C)-ic_ = 0.257
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0 04
MaximumIceThickness
Upper Lower
0,02
m 36"Tracing 2.3 mm (.09") 2.8 mm (.11")
u
30"Tracin 9 2.5 mm (.10") 3.0 mm (.12")
_.02 L -004 _2.05 0.00 005 010 015 020 x/C
176 NAS A/TP--2000- 210031
General Aviation - Run 612r
LVVC = 0.56 g/m 3 C_<_,,,0= 0.0099
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
Cd_ic_ = 0.0124
T, =-10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 15 p.m
C___l_n= 0.272
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = -1.7 ° Cl__ed= 0.261
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Maximum Ice Thickness
Lower
Upper
0.02
2.5 mm (.10") 3.0 mm (.12")
36" Tracing
o
2.8 mm (.11") 3.8 mm (.15")
-- 30" Tracing
-004 015 020 0 25 -0.05 0 O0 0.05 0.I0 x/C 2.0 _
--- Clean -*- Iced
.a.,
.i
u O O
=_
-0.5 -10.0 -5,0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20,0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 177
General Aviation - Run 613
Tt = -5.9°C (20.8°F)
LWC = 0.56 g/m 3 Cd-d.. = 0.0099
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd-ioed = 0.0146
MVD = 15 pm
V = 93.0 m/s (180 kts) Spray = 6.0 min Cl_clea n - 0.273
AOA = -1.7 °
Cl-_c_d = 0.239
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 i 0.06- JJ 0.04.
Maximum Ice Thickness
F
Upper Lower
0.02 i
-- 36" Tracing
8.4 mm (.33") 9.9 mm (.39")
u
30" Tracing
8.9 mm (.35") 10.7 mm (.42")
0,00 i -0.02 i -004 _ -006 -0.05 0,00 005 010 0.15 0.20 0.25 x/C .O O iii!iFi!iiiiiiiii! _ 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 6 ?ri ; : _v Angle of Attack, deg II IIII ........ @i ;
178 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 621
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3 C_.c,,,o = 0.0105
"It = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
Cd_,_ = 0.0153
T, = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
C_..:,,,,,o = 0.483
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 0.4 °
C,_ced= 0.453
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
Maximum Ice Thickness
Lower
Upper
2.0 mm (.08") 2.0 mm (.08")
-- 42" Tracin£1
o
m 36" Tracing 2.0 mm (.08") 2.3 mm (.09")
O00 2.3 mm (.09") 1.8 mm (.07")
30" Tracing
-002 -004 -0.06 .............
015 020 025 -0.05 000 0.05 0 10 x/c 2.0 -- - [ --m-Clean--e--Iced ,w" ._e O 0.0 - -0,5 -10,0 -5,0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 179
General Aviation - Run 621 m
"It = -2.8°C (26.4°F) LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3
T, = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 0.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
O06
fJ
I i
J
004 i 0,02
f
30" Tracing
u 0.00 4).02 -0,04 -006: 0.00 005 0,10 0.15 0.20 025 x/C
180 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 622
C__o_n= 0.0105
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Tt = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
C___ = 0.0202
T, = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
Ci.clea n = 0.463
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
C,-,=ed = 0.418
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 0.04 -
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02
f -47:: Tracin
8.4 mm (.33") 5.1 mm (.20")
u
8,4 mm (.33") 5.1 mm (.20")
_r / m 36 Tracing
8.9 mm (.35") 6.1 mm (.24")
30 Tracing
_04 _)06 0 15 0 20 0.25 000 005 0.10 YJc 2.0 --B--Clean--e-Iced 1'.5 O ,.J 0.0 -
' i
-0.5 .....
15.0 20.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 -10,0 -5.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 181
General Aviation - Run 622r
-It = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3
C___o = 0.0105
T, = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
Cd__ = 0.0204
MVD = 20 _tm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min Cl-_le, n = 0.461
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_,,ed= 0.425
0.08 i i 0.06 •
[
jJ
0.04 -
Maximum Ice Thickness
0.02 ,
,,i _ , Upper Lower
' " . m(32). " 4.8mm(.19")
u i
i
0,00 i i I -002 -0.04 -0,06 -0 05 090 005 0 10 015 020 025 X/C 2.0
O.5 I
.J -0.5 -10,0 -5,0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
182 NAS A/TP--2000- 210031
General Aviation - Run 622r2
LVVC = 0.54 g/m 3 C_:,=o = 0.0105
Tt = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
Ts = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
MVD = 20 _m Cd-,c_ = 0.0204
Spray = 6.0 min C,__,e_ = 0.479
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C,-,:ed = 0.440
0.08
_J
0.06
J
0.04 J
f Maximum Ice Thickness
,, Upper Lower m36 Tracing 8.9 mm (.35") 5.1 mm (.20")
/I/ 30" Tracing 9.4 mm (.37") 5.1 mm (.20") -002 4}.04 4.06 0,25 0(30 005 0.10 015 020 -005 X/C 2.0
i---Clean---Iced
i L =., .=_, -0.5 .......
15.0 20.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5D 10.0 "_:_:" i_ : ........
Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 183
General Aviation - Run 622m
"It = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
T, = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
J !
0,02 u
30" Tracing
,f
0.00 -002 -0.04 -0.06 -005 000 0.05 010 015 020 025 X/C
184 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 623
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3 Cd.clea n "" 0.0105
Tt = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
C_-,ce_ = 0.0459
T, = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
MVD = 20 p.m
C_<_,o= 0.460
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = 0.3 ° C_-ic_= 0.401
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02
27.4 mm (1.08"1 24.4 mm (0.96")
-- 42" Tracing
25.4 mm (1.00"1 22.1 mm (0.87")
m 36" Tracing
27.7 mm (1.09"1 24.4 mm (096")
30" Tracing
0.00 _0.02 -004 -0.06 o2 0.05 0 10 0 15 020 405 000 x/c 2,0 - ' -_-- Clean --e-- Iced 1.5 -- 1,0 o o
E
0.5 -1 0.0 = -05 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 185
General Aviation - Run 623m
T, = -2.8°C (26.4°F) LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
T, = -5.0°C (22.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 1 I i t 006 • j J OO4 0.02
30" Tracing
0,_ L -0.02 -0,04 -006 ..................
-0,05 0,00 0,05 010 015 0.20 0.25 X/C
186 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 625
LWC = 0.66 g/m 3 C___l_n = 0.0105
"1-,= -7.8°C (17.3°F)
Cd.ic_ = 0.0152
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 40 _m
Cl-_,_an = 0.475
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 0.9 min
AOA = 0.3 °
C_-iced = 0.447
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0 04 Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
i m " . . ' 1.5mm (.06") u 0.00 -002 -004 ÷ .
-006 ....................
0.15 0.20 -005 0.00 0.05 010 xJc 2.O-- Clean --e-- Iced 1.5 + 1.0 c .__ __ 0.5 ..I 0.0 -0.5 15.0 20.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg NASA/TP--2000-210031 187
General Aviation - Run 626
T, = -7.8°C (17.3°F) LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
Cd-c_,_n = 0.0105
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd__,_ = 0.0142
MVD = 20 IJm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) C_<jeao = 0.476
Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) Cj-iced = 0.451
0.08 0.66 0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02
36" Tracing; 1.8 mm (.07") 1.5 mm (.06")
0,00 -0.02 -006 -0.05 000 0.05 010 015 0.20 025 xJc ! + Clean --e-- Iced
I
0.0 F -0.5 -10.0 -5,0 0,0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20,0 Angle of Attack, deg
188 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 627
C,._,,,,n= 0.0105
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
Tt = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
Cd.,c_ = 0.0169
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
C_,,o = 0.462
Spray = 5.9 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
AOA = 0.3 ° C,_ic,,d = 0.433
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Lower
Upper
002 -
6.1 mm (.24")
-- 42" Tracing
i
m 36" Tracing
000 , 30" Tracing
-002 -0.04 .
-0.06 015 020 02 005 0 10 _105 000 x/C 2.0 Clean --e-- Iced 1.5 1.0 e.
o
U .-I 0.0
i i
t -0.5 0.0 5,0 100 15.0 200 -10.0 -5.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 189
General Aviation - Run 627r
Tt = -7.8°C (17.3°F) LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
C_-cl_o= 0.0105
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd.,:_ = 0.0167
MVD = 20 _Jm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 5.9 min Cl..,:,,,,,,_ = 0.478
AOA = 0.3 °
C_i_d= 0.443
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06
J
0,04
Maximum Ice Thickness
0,02 I ,, Upper Lower
/_/ I m 36,,Tracing 5.3 mm (.21") 6.4 mm (.25")
" , 6.4 mm (.25") 6.4 mm (.25")
-0.02 -0.04 -0,06 ! ...............................................
-0.05 000 005 0 10 0 15 0.20 0.25 x/c 2.0-- i ....
!
--m-Clean--e--Iced F !
-0.5 , -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
190 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 627r2
Cd-=,_n= 0.0105
LVVC = 0.44 g/m 3
T, = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0172
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 IJm
C__c,_n = 0.476
Spray = 5.9 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Cj-,ced = 0.435
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 0.04
____1 _ _ T¢a Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
cin_ 5.3 mm (.21") I 5.1 mm (.20")
u
.1 mm (.24)
-0 02 -0 04 -006 ..................................
_.05 000 005 0.10 0 15 020 025 x/c 2.0 - _.
--m-Clean --_- Iced
L
i
i
-o.5 4 . .
15.0 20.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 -10.0 -5.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 191
General Aviation - Run 627m
"It = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 _tm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 5.9 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08
i
0,06
J
J
0.04 !
I
Maximum Ice Thickness
002 )
Upper I Lower
30" Tracin9 _ 5.8 mm (.23") 5.6 mm (.22")
Y
u 0.00 -0,02 -0.04 43.00 ..........
-005 000 0.05 0 10 0.15 020 0,25 x/c ii!ii : iil ii)_iii!_i!i_i _,_ 'i,)iii'
192 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 628
Cd-_,ao= 0.0105
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
T, = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
Cd-iced = 0.0272
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 pm
C_<,e,o = 0.474
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 22.0 min
C_._ = 0.428
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
J
J
Upper I Lower
c) 000-
Maximum Ice Thickness
, -- 36" Tracing 23.4 mm (.92") 121.3 mm (.84")
-0 02 -004 -006 .......................
-005 000 005 0 10 0 15 0,20 x/C 2.0 + Clean + Iced 1.5 1.0 U 0.5 i 0.0 -0.5 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 193
General Aviation - Run 629
Tt = -12.9°C (8.2°F) LVVC = 0.44 g/m 3
C__=j_,= 0.0105
Ts =-15°C (4.4°F)
Cd.,c_ = 0.0131
MVD = 20 _m
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 1.4 min C_c,=,o = 0.470
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C,_k:e_ = 0.447
0.08 0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02
m36" Tracing] 1.3 mm (.05") 1.3 mm (.05")
30" Tracing 1.3 mm (.05") 1.3 mm (.05")
0.00 -0.02 _I.04 -0.05 O00 005 0.10 0 15 0.20 0.25 x/c 20 F 7-_ ........
--=--Clean--e--Iced
1.5 !
F
)
O0 -0.5 ........ _ ......
-10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
194 NASA/TP---2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 630
Cd.clea n -" 0.0105
LVVC = 0.44 g/m 3
Tt = -12.9°C (8.2°F)
Cd-,c_= 0.0154
Ts = -15.0°C (4.4°F)
MVD = 20 }_m
Cl-_l.an = 0.467
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 4.1 min
C,._e_= 0.437
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
006 J
J OO4
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
m 36" Tracing
3.6 mm (.14") 4.1 mm (.16")
o
3.6 mm (.14") 3.6 mm (.14")
30" Tracing
_)02 -0 O4 -006 .................
0.20 025 0.15 -005 0 00 005 0.10 x/c 2.0 _ • : -iP- Clean ---o--Iced 1.5 ÷ "5 E= O 0.5 0.0 _0.5 .....
15.0 20.0 -1Q0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
!!iiii_
NASA/TP--2000-210031 195
General Aviation - Run 631
T, = -12.9°C (8.2°F)
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3 Cd._o = 0.0105
T, = -15.0°C (4.4°F)
Cd-,c,_ = 0.0207
MVD = 20 pm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) C_<l_n= 0.469
Spray = 15.3 min
AOA = 0.3 °
Cl__ = 0.433
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06
J
0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
0.02
,, Upper Lower
/"-" f --36 Tracing I 14.0 mm (0.551') 16.3 mm (0.64")
' ' . . ') 16.0 mm (0.63")
0.00 -0.02 -0.04 _).06 -0 05 0.(30 0.05 010 015 020 025 x/C
"B
O O .J
196 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 632
Cd-_,_o= 0.0105
LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
"It = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
Cd-ic_ = 0.0125
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 15 #m
Cl_ctea n = 0.471
Spray = 2.0 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
AOA = 0.3 ° C_-i_ed = 0.454
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
36" Tracing
1.3 mm (.05") 1.8 mm (.07")
u
2.0 mm (08") 2.5 mm (.10")
30" Tracing
0.00 _0.02 -0.04 015 0.20 025 -0 05 000 005 010 xJc 2,0 - i
i
Clean --*--Iced 1.5 _ (.} .=J -0.5 - 20.0 -5.0 0.0 5,0 10.0 15.0 -100 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 ! 97
General Aviation - Run 633
T, = -7.8°C (17.3°F) LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
C_-_,an= 0.0105
T, =-10.0°C (13.4°F)
C,-iced= 0.0151
MVD = 15 pm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 6.0 min C,-c,,,n= 0.472
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_iced = 0.439
0,08 0.06 0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
0.02 Upper Lower
-- 42" Tracing 6.4 mm (.25") 6.1 mm (.24")
36" Tracing
5.1 mm (.20") 5.8 mm (.23")
0.00
-- 30" Tracing
6.9 mm (.27") 7.4 mm (.29")
-0,02 -0.04 -0,06 -0.05 0,05 010 0 15 020 02 X/C I 1.0 ¢,.
i
e
-I i -0.5 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10,0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
198 NASA/TP----2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 633m
LWC = 0.60 g/m 3
Tt = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 15 pm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 6.0 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
J 0.06 J
j_
J
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02
32" Tracing 6.4 mm (.25") 5.6 mm (.22")
L
-002 -004 -0.06 ................................
-005 0.00 005 0kl0 0.15 020 025 x/c
NASA/TP--2000-210031 ! 99
General Aviation - Run 641
"it = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
Cd-_l_.n = 0.0092
T, =-10.0°C (13.4°F)
C_-ic_ = 0.0108
MVD = 20 #m
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 2.0 min Cl_clea n = 0.263
AOA = -1.7 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C,-ic.d= 0.248
0.08 0.06 J J 0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
0,02 Upper Lower
m 36" Tracing
1.8 mm (.07") 2.0 mm (.08")
- 30" Tracing 2.0 mm (.08") 2.0 mm (.08")
0.00 43.02 r -0.06 -0.05 0.00 005 0.10 0.t5 0.20 025 X/C 2.0 l-.-=--Clean--e--lced i e.
O O
J
-o.5_--i
-10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
200 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 642
Cd.o_n = 0.0092
LVVC = 0.44 g/m 3
T, =-7.8°C (17.3°F)
Cd-,c_= 0.0154
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 _m
Cl_clea n -- 0.255
Spray = 5.9 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
AOA = -1.7 ° Cl-_ed= 0.233
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 jJ J
Maximum Ice Thickness
Lower
Upper
5.1 mm (.20") 5.6 mm (.22")
m 36" Tracing
u
5.1 mm (.20") 5.8 mm (.23")
30" Tracing
0.00 -002 -O04 -0 06 ..............
015 020 025 -005 000 005 0 10 xJc 2.0 '3 _E fO O0 -0.5 15,0 20.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 201
General Aviation - Run 643
It = -7.8°C (17.3°F) LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
C___l,,o = 0.0092
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
C__,c_= 0.0241
MVD = 20 Hm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 22.0 min Cl-c,,,n= 0.267
AOA = - 1.7 °
C,_ = 0.229
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.06 lJJ / 0.04 Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02 36" Tracing 22.4 mm (0.88") 21.6 mm (0.85") o 30" Tracing 22.1 mm (0.87")'22.1 mm (0.87") 0.017 _)02 - -0.04 -006 0.00 0.05 0.10 015 0.20 0.25 xJc 2.0 e- '3 E ¢_ -I 0.0 -0.5 + I -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10,0 15.0 20,0 Angle of Attack, deg
202 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 644
Cd.clea n = 0.0123
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
T, = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
Cd-ic.d= 0.0152
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 #m
Cj_c_e,o = 0.655
Spray = 2.0 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Cl-ic_ = 0.619
AOA = 2.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.(:6 0,04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0,02
1.8 mm (.07") 2.0 mm (.08")
m 36" Tracing
o
2.0 mm (.08") 2.0 mm (.08")
30" Tracing
-002 -0 04 _000 0 15 0.20 0.25 005 0 10 -0,05 O00 x/C 2.0 - .--_-Clean--o--Iced -0.5 .....
15.0 20.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10,0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 203
General Aviation - Run 645
"It = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
L_ = 0.44 g/m 3
C,_cl_o= 0.0123
T, =-10.0°C (13.4°F)
C,__ = 0.0189
MVD = 20 _m
V = 66.9 m/s (130 Ms)
Spray = 5.9 rain C,-c_ea. = 0.665
AOA = 2.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C,-ic.d= 0.606
0_ 0_
Maximum Ice Thickness
0.02
, Upper Lower
i
5.6
36'Tracing mm (.22") 5.3 mm (.21")
m (24') 61mm(24)
-0.02 -0._ -0._ _,05 0,00 0.05 0.10 015 0,20 0.25 X/C 1.0 ._O U 0.5 t 0.0 F -0.5 _ ....
-10,0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
204 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 645m
LVVC = 0.44 g/m 3
Ti = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4 °F)
MVD = 20 him
Spray = 5.9 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
AOA = 2.4 ° chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 OO6
J
0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02
7.1 mm (.28") 6.6 mm (.26")
32" Tracing
000 I
4).04 4),06 ......
0.05 010 0 15 0.20 0.25 -0 05 0,00 xJC
el4
• <+ 7 30 ! z _
NASA/TP--2000-210031 205
General Aviation - Run 646
Tt = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
LVVC = 0.44 g/m 3 C,_._,o = 0.0123
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 p.m Cd-,:,_= 0.0302
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 22.0 min C_._,,,,o = 0.659
AOA = 2.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_,ced = 0.602
0.08 , 0.0,4 Maximum Ice Thickness 002 F
, Upper I Lower
u m36' Tracing 22.6 mm (0.89")119.8 mm (0.78") ' , , i . . it) i i -0.02 i -0.04 i i _.06 -0,05 0.00 0.05 0.10 015 0.20 0.25 x/c 2.0 I r + Clean --e-- Iced i
15!
tJ .¢3_ I I ,=1 , !
I -0.5 , , i .... i ....
-10,0 .5.0 ¸ 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
206 NASA/TP---2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 647
Cd.c_e.o = 0.0171
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
Tt = -7.8°C (17.3 °F)
Ca-iced = 0.0233
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 #m
Ci-cl_n= 0.837
Spray = 2.0 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
C_-i_,,d = 0.780
AOA = 4.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06 O04
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0,02
1.8 mm (.07") 1.5 mm (.06")
m 36" Tracing
u %
f
000 Ib -0 02 -0 04 -0.06 000 005 0.10 0 15 0.20 0.25 -0.05 X/C 0.0 -0.5 15.0 20.0 -10.0 -5,0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 207
General Aviation - Run 648
T, = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
LWC = 0.44 g/m 3
C__cl,n= 0.0171
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
Cd_ic_= 0.0235
MVD = 20 #m
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 5.9 min Cl_clea n " 0.832
AOA = 4.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) Cl-_ed= 0.748
0.08 0.06 jJ 0.04
,?T.ic::ess
o.o2 [
I 0._ _ i
m 36" Tracing 8.6mm(.34") I 5.3mm(.21")
43.02 -0,04 4)¸06 -0,05 0.(30 04)5 0,10 015 020 0.25 xJc 2.0 i -,B--Clean --e--Iced
! : !
.e
O O _=, i -0.5 _--_----_ , , , I ' ' , , i , , , -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15,0 20,0 Angle of Attack, deg
208 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 649
Cd..clea n '- 0.01 71
LVVC = 0.44 g/m 3
T, = -7.8°C (17.3°F)
C,J-,:ed = 0.0311
Ts = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 jam
C_._,,,,,n = 0.834
Spray = 22.0 min
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
C,-,ced = 0.748
AOA = 4.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08
O06 J
I Maximum Ice Thickness
_ Upper Lower
_,_ ' -- 36" Tracing 24.9 mm (09811) 22.6 mm (0.89")
30' Tracing 25 4 mm (100 )122 9 mm (0 90 )
0.00 _0.02 *0.04 -005 000 005 010 0 15 020 025 X/C 2.0 + Clean + Iced 0.0 -0.5 ......
150 200 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 209
General Aviation - Run 655
Tt = -9.1°C (15.0°F)
LVVC = 0.65 g/m 3
Cd-cle, n = 0.0172
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
C,.i=_ = 0.0199
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 42.7 m/s (83 kts)
Spray = 2.0 min Cl-=l.an = 0.830
AOA = 4.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) Cl_iced = 0.788
0.08 .
0.06- / I
/
0.04
Maximum Ice Thickness
0.02 Upper Lower
_ 36" Trac!ng
1.0 mm (.04") 1.0 mm (.04")
1.3 mm (.05") 1.3 mm (.05")
0.00 -0 02 -0,04 -0.06 : 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 X/C = -1
o.o i
! I
F I I
L
i
r ! i
-0.5 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
210 NASA/TP--2000- 210031
General Aviation - Run 656
Cd_clea n _-" 0.0172
LWC = 0.65 g/m 3
T, = -9.1°C (15.0°F)
Cd-,=_= 0.0242
T, = -10.0°C (13.4°F)
MVD = 20 p.m
Cl-_eao = 0.830
Spray = 6.0 min
V = 42.7 m/s (83 kts)
Cl-,ced = 0.760
AOA = 4.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0¸061 004 L !
Maximum Ice Thickness
Upper Lower
0.02 1
m36" Tracing 3.3 mm (.13") 3.3 mm (.13")
i
30" Tracing 3.3 mm (.13") 3.8 mm (.15")
-0.02 -0.04 .
-006 ..........
0 15 020 0 25 -0.05 0.0(3 0.05 X/C 2.0
-.- Clean --.- Iced
1.5_ 1.0 o "3 o 0.5 + .-J L i L 0.0 _¸ -0.5 20.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 -10.0 -5.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NASA/TP--2000-210031 211
General Aviation - Run 657
"It = -4.1°C (24. I°F)
LWC = 0.65 g/m 3 C,.=,_.o= 0.0172
Ts = -5.0°C (22.0°F)
MVD = 20 #m Cd_,c_= 0.0265
V = 42.7 m/s (83 kts)
Spray = 5.0 min C___,.ao = 0.834
AOA = 4.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in) C_ = 0.756
0.08 0.06 J J 0.04
Upper Lower
0.02 Maximum Ice Thickness o m36" Tracing 4.8 mm (.19") I 3.8 mm (.151') • .... i -002 -0.04 _.06 .....
-0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 x/c -0.5 i .... i .... , , i , !
-10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
212 NASA/TP--2000-210031
General Aviation - Run 661
Cd_:l_o= 0.0092
LWC = 1.00 g/m 3
Tt = -1.8°C (28.2°F)
Cd-_ = 0.0347
T, = -4.0°C (24.0°F)
MVD = 20.5 pm
Cl-:_,o = 0.275
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 15.0 min
AOA = -1.7 ° C_-i_ed = 0.233
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
0.08 0.06
Maximum Ice Thickness
upper Lower
_n/ 30" Tracingg
17.5 mm (0.69") 18.5 mm (0.73")
22.9 mm (0.90")21.1 mm (0.83")
,1'
000 i
-002 _.04 X).06 ..................
0 20 025 -005 0(30 005 010 015 xJc 2.0 ....
--*- Clean --- Iced
1.5 ..... .
1.0, ; .....
.,,.r
"5
tE
(3
o.5, - i . -
0.0 -0.5 . - --_ ........................
-10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg
NAS A/TP--2000-2 !0031 213
Appendix D4
Appendix D4
Test Results, General AviationmLTPT
NASA/TP--2000-210031 215
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o 08 0 O6 o 04
-- NLF-0414
-0 O2 -004
t
_0_06 _ ..........
0 o5 010 015 020 025 x/c 2.0
Ma = 0.12
Re = 6.4x10^6 i i
i I
1°1 _ - i
o O ._ (?5
J i/ i _
oo ---e-Re=3xl0^6 0.0 i - +Ma 012 -.-e---Re:6.4xlO^6 I _ Ma=021 -.,t--Re:lOxl0^6 ! _ Ma:O.29 -05 -0.5 ..... _ .........................
-100 -5O O0 50 10.0 15.0 20.0 -100 -50 00 50 10.0 150 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
216 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model
20 .
20. - 7 - - i
Ma = .05
Ma = 0.21 i
Re = lx10^6
15-- . * _5 '1 ._w .2
o
u 05 - _ "3 o5 oo _ Re=6 4x10^6 00 _ " _Re=8 lx10^6 !
: --x-- Re=10xl0^6 Re= 12x 10^6 -O5 ..............................
-o 5 .............................
-100 50 00 50 100 150 200 -_oo -50 oo 50 1oo 15o 200 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
Drag Coefficients, cd
c_= -2.0 o. = 0.0 c_= 2.1 _z= 4.2 o_= 6.2
Run 23, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6 0.0064 i 0.0086 0.0114 0.0144 0.0180
Run 24, Ua = 0.12, Re = 6,4x10^6 0.0076 : 0.0072 0.0082 0.0107 0.0146
i 0.0322 0.0299 0.0222 i 0.0132
Run 25, Ma = 0.12. Re = 3x10^6 0.0253 !
Run 26, Ma = 0.21. Re = 46x10^6 0.0279 j 0.0287 0.0232 0.0153 i 0.0087
Run 27, Ua = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10^6 0.0418 i 0.0483 0.0463 0.0407 i 0.0361
Run 28, Ua = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6 0.0465 ' 0.0530 0,0501 0.0427 0.0353
Run 29 Ua = 0.21, Re = 8.1x10*6 0.0375 0.0439 0.0417 0.0357 0.0303 Run 30, Ua = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6 0.0230 0.0305 0.0282 0.0211 0.0143 Run 32. Ua = 0.21, Re = 12x10^6 0.0261 0.0345 0.0336 0.0282 0.0228 Run 35. Ua = 0.05, Re = lx10^6 0.0029 0.0044 0.0057 0.0069 0.0078 Run 701, Ma = 12, Re = 10x10^6 0.0077 0.0067 0.0080 0.0115 0.0174 Run 702, Ma = 21, Re = 4.6x10^6 0.0103 0.0091 0.0106 0.0148 0.0217
Run 703, Ma = 21, Re = 10x10^6 0.0079 0.0068 I 0.0085 0.0127 0.0196
! 0.0112 i 0.0156 0.0233
Run 704, Ma = 29, Re = 6.4x10^6 0.0112 0.0097 L Run 705, Ma = 12, Re = 3x10^6 0.0118 0.0102 i 0.0112 0.1490 0.0215 Italicized font indicates force balance data
NASA/TP--2000-210031 217
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model
Runs 701 - 705, Repeat Runs
2.0-- i
2o_ .. _
Ma = 0.12
Re = 6.4x10^6
{ 1,5
l ' 1
1.0 k= 0.5 o.o - i# , .
I -41-- Re=3x 10^6
!
Ma=0.29 ; --'_--" Re= 10x 10^6
i
-05' ! , , i I -O5 i -10.0 -5.0 0.0 50 10.0 150 20.0 -100 -5,0 00 50 10.0 150 200 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, (:leg 2.0 _ , .... • T
Ma=
0.21
QO 00 5.0 10.0 150 20.0 AngleofA_ack, deg
218 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 23, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
-40 ...........
-40 .....
F
-e-AOA = -40 -I-- AOA = -20 -35_ ....... _AOA=40 -35 - - - --,,,_ AOA = 00
ii +AoA=2o
-30 ...........
-30 .....
-25 : -25 ..........
-2.o :-
-20 ...........
-15 -1.5 ....
-1.0 -10 ' .....
-0.5 ,_
-0.5 " i
t
r 0.0 06 _ 05_ O5 10 : . + .......
15 ! ..................
15 ..............
-01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
X/¢ -125 . - - -125 _ .....
-120 ! _ ..... -e-AOA=8.0 , -120 _ - -.e-- AOA = 140 -11.5 ...... -Q--AOA = 160 .1!5 i _ _ i ...... -m--AOA=10.0.
-11.0 i ..... - .....
_1 o _ -.--AOA = 120 -10.5 ; _ " _ .......
-1o5 _ _ .....
-10.o k .... +_ .....
-100 ;_ _ Z- -- ff _ : : + -- _95 _ ......... L 1 -95 -90 F " * ......
-90 ) 85 _ -85 -80 _ ............
-80 -7,5 _ .......
-75 b " ! ' -70 i ...........
j ..............
-70 -65 i --( ..............
-65 i- _- + ....
-60 E ..........
-60 8 -55 ; -55 -5.0 1 -50 F
-45 _
-45 -40 -35 -35 -30 -30 -25 !
-25 -2.0 -20 -15 -10 -_o !- -0.5 0.6 0.5 05 _--- lo i 15 _ -- ..... Z ......
-01 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 0.8 09 10 -01 00 0 _ 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 219
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 24, Ma = 0.12, Re = 6.4x10^6
-1.5 -10 -0.5
! i
0.5 1.0
xlc
-_25 F ' ] --e- AOA = 8.0 -12o -115 i ..... _ _ _: _:: -'_-AOA=10.0 -_Io : i i .... +AOA 12.0i
-io5
-65 - -60 -55 -50 -45 -40 -35 -30 i -25 r -20 10 I 15 , I : -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 !0 -0.1 O0 01 02 03 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 09 10
x/c
220 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 25, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
-35 ..........
-35 ........ T *- --e- AOA = 20 --e-- AOA = -4.0 ; -I--AOA = 40 -m-- AOA = -20 -30 .......... + AOA = 60 -3.o -- " + _ " _ _ ----.--AOA = 0.0 -25 i _ _ .......
-2.5 ......... ? " " -20 -2o : ............
: i
-1.5 a -I o ' + ..... - ....
-0.5 -0500 "_ --- 0.5 10 .......... 10 ........
15 ......... L .............
-0.1 0.0 01 02 0.3 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 ;_Jc X/C -110 -- .....
-!"0 - " - --o-- AOA = 140 -e- AOA = 8.0 -105 i .... " ....
-105 = ......
-I- AOA = 160 .... -l- AOA = 10.0 -_00 : -- -100 _ ....... _AOA: 180 AOA = 12.0 -95 : ......
-90 _ .........
-8.5 i- --+ ..........
-85 [ ......
-8.0 _- 4 ..........
-8 0 .............
-75 [ .........
-7.0 ...........
-65 i .............
-60 ! ...... - 4 ' i -55"6° _ ...........
-55 :. -50 _ • _ .......
-40 ;: - - - U "45-40_35 ?i 7_i : i m-i I ii! i__ i-i_ i _ -30 [ .........
-30 ! _ , i -25 -20 -15 -1.0 -15 -0.5 -05 -- 05 ,_ 1 10[ J 15 : ............ ' " 15 ..................
-01 0.0 01 02 03 04 0 5 06 07 08 09 1.0 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
xlc
xlc
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 221
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 26, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
-3.5 ---- -3.5 --e--AOA = -4.0 AOA = -2.0 -3,0 - -- -3.0 - -- --*'- AOA = 0.0 -25 -- -2.5 -20 ....
-2.0 -1.5 - -1,5
a -lO
-05
i
I i
1_5i ...... !
-0.1 0.0 01 0,2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0,E 07 08 09 1.0
x/c
-115 -25 -20 -15 -10 -05 O0 05 _ -01 O0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 X/C X]C
"'- NASA/TP---2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 27, Ma = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10^6
-4.0 ...........
-40 ...........
--e- AOA = -4.0
AOA = -2.0 -35 ', + AOA = 40 -35 - * i ..... --'_-- AOA = 60 AOA = 0.0 i -.-e- AOA = 20 -3O [ .............
-25 -25 .....
q -20 -2.0 .....
[ ..........
-1.5 -1.5 -1.0 -10 -05 -05 00 -- 00 0.5 - 05 1.0 : 15 .................
-01 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 -0 1 00 0 1 02 0 3 04 05 06 07 08 09 1 0
x/c xlc
-11o ....... T .....
:_:-_ . -e-- AOA = 8,0 -105 ! -- -'-m-AOA = 10.01 -100 ------ AOA = 12.0 -95 -9 o -85 -80 -75 -70 -65 -60 -55 -50 -45 -40 -35 -30 -25 -20 -15 i . __ . 2 .......
-05 15 ..... _ ....... _ .........
-01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 X/¢
x/c
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 28, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
-4,0 - - --e-- AOA = 2.0 • 35 -_r _. _AOA = 40 _ AOA = 6.0 -2.5 -2.0 -1.5 -10 -0.5 -- - 0.0 10 .....
ii'
1.5 ........
-01 0.0 0.1 0,2 0.3 04 05 0.6 07 0,8 0.9 10 -0.1 0.0 01 02 0.3 0.4 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
-120 -85 -80 -75 -70 -6s _ _ ' i T : / i -50 i -40 -35 i -30 .
-25 -20 -15 -10 -05 O0 [ i :
,, +i;i
15 _+, _ -0! 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 X]C
xlc
224 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 29, Ma = 0.21, Re = 8.1x10^6
-40 -40 ......
-e- AOA = -4,0
! 1 i --_-AoA=20
-i- AOA = -2.0 :. J_ .... : _ -- , -.I-- AOA = 4.0 -35 -3.5 ....... _ AOA = 0.0 -30 -3.0 -25 -2.5 ......
-20 -2.0 -15 -15 ........
-1.0 -10 -05 -05
!
0.0 00 05 0.5 1.0 1.5 ...................
15 .................
-01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 0.9 10 -01 00 0.1 02 03 Q4 05 06 07 08 09
x/c
x/c
-115 ...........
-110 i ....... --_--AOA= 140 - _ A O A Z 1 6 0 -I05 i .... : - -105 --w-- AOA = 180 _ -10.0 F .........
-100 -95 _ .......
-95 -9.0 _ ...... + -90 -8.5 !...... _ ......
-8.5 -8.0 _ ..... _ -- _ ....
;8.0 -7.5 _ 4 , .... _ - - - -7.5 -70 -6,5 i .............
-65 -60 -60 i .......
-55 i .......
-55 r -50 -50 ! ..............
-45 -40 -3.5 -&0 -2.5 -25 _ -Z0 -1.5 -15
-lo i
-1.0 -0.5 -0.5 0.0 0,0 L 05 I. 0.5 10 ! I 10 i 15 • -01 00 01 02 03 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 10 -01 0,0 01 02 03 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
NASA/TP--2000-210031 225
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 30, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6
t
a
15 " _ ............ -- .....
-01 oo 0t 0.2 03 0.4 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
! !
i
I
-0.1 O0 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 09 10
xlc
x/c
226 NASA/TP---2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 32, Ma = 0.21, Re = 12x10^6
-40 .......
-40 ............
i -_--AOA = 2 0 : -e- AOA = .,.4.0 -i- AOA = -2,0 -35 i ..... + AOA = 40 -35 ..... _ ' --_--- AOA = 60 + AOA = 0.0 -30 ......
-30 .......
: i i -25 .........
-25 - - r . • -- _ ....
!
-20 r ......
20 _ - ........
-15
i
i
-lO- --i.-- . -
10 i -Q5
il!
-05 --.- _ . i O0 _ I 05 _ " * _ - _ .....
i !
i i 10 i - - ....... 10 .........
15 .......... 15 ............. L ......
-01 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 0.0 01 02 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
xlc
x/¢
-120 , - - - _ -115 " i q ....... -e--AOA= 140 .
' -D-AOA = 160 -110 i 1 -10o _ ........
-95 _ --_ .......
-90 .........
-85 - _ ....... _ .......
,o ; /! 12 : :--12
-75
-7o -- - : - - ; - - -
-65 _ " _ ..........
-60 _ -- _ .... _ " - -55 ...... C . .
-50 .........
-dO _ -35 b -30 -25 -20 i - -45 -1.5 _ -1.0 !
00 i t ......
1.o! _
1.5 i .................
-01 00 01 0.2 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
xlc
xlc
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 227
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 35, Ma = 0.05, Re = lx10^6
-1.0 0.0 0.o , i , ! !
O5
i I ! ! i
1.0 ............ __
_o i i
-0.1 00 01 02 03 04 0.5 0.6 0,7 08 09 "10 -0.1 O0 0 1 0.2 03 04 05 0,6 07 0.8 09 10
x/c
x/c
-3.5 -3.0 -2.5 -20 -15 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 10 I---- 1.5 • -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 09 1.0
x/¢
228 NASA/TP--20_-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 701, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
40 .......
-40 - T ..... i -- - ' --e-AOA = -4.0 -.m- AOA = -2.0 -35 , _ . _ . . . --I-- AOA = 40 35 i ........ -_AOA=0.0 --'_,f"-- AOA = 60 i I½ --e-'-AOA = 20 -30 * ÷
-3.0 .... i - - "
[
-25 ......
-2.5 ' - _ - - - : -20 - -20 ! - , -15 -15 " i ..... : " i -10 -10 ' i _ _ ....
-0.5 -0.5 - - " ' 0.0 00 r -- 05 _ .......... i - 05 , 1_0 .......... 10 .......
• i 1.5 ......... [': .......
15 ..................
-Ol o.o o.1 0.2 o3 04 o5 oe o7 08 o9 lo -01 00 01 02 03 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
-130 _ ................
-130 ......
4_ _ _ -_-AOA:140
-12.5 ,_ .... ..-_-AOA = 8.0
-12o125 _ _ ...... --.-AOA:16o
-120 ......... -m-AOA = 10.0 -11.5 . - . -,,-AOA = 12.0 -11 o ........
-10.5 b ............
-100 : .........
-1151 _' : _ _ _ _ --.-Ao,,°18ol
-95 .........
-9.0 i - -9o _ .......
-8.5 ....
-8.0 : .......
-75 "_ e ...........
-70 ! L .........
-65 _ -- -6.0 ! .....
-55 " - ......... -55 i -5.o :: .........
-50 ........
-45 _ ...... - ....
.5i,: ::::::i:::: i :: i :: :: :: :: -40 ..... r - L -- -35 i
-as: 1 : .... : T
-30 -30 -2.5 -25 : -20 -2.0 ¢ -I 5 -1.5 - .40 i_: -I 0 -1.0 :-- ....
-0,5 _ .....
-0.5 ; -
&o _ -
0.5 _- 05 _ - 0.0 __) 1.0 -- 1.5 ............ .................
1.5 ........................................
-0 1 00 01 0.2 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 1 0 -0 1 00 0 1 0.2 0.3 0.4 05 06 0.7 08 09 10
NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 229
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 702, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
-35 T -3.0
!
! i
I i
i I
L
1.5 _.....
-01 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0,6 07 08 0.9 1.0 -01 0,0 0,1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 07 08 0.9 1.0
x/c
XJC -125 -- -120 -115 -11,0 -10.5 -10.0 -9.5 -90 -8.5 ....
-8.0 -75 -70 -6.5 -6.0 -5.5 -50 -4.5 -40 -3,5 -3.0 -2.5 l -2.0 : -1.5 -1.0 -0.5 " 0.0 " 0.5 1.0
1.5 i__
-0.1 O0 0.1 0.2 03 0.4 0.5 06 07 08 0.9 1,0 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 03 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 08 0.9 10
230 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 703, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6
-40 [ " _ ...... .
--e-- AOA = 2.0
[ : -e- AOA = -4.0
r
--I- AOA = 40
r _ AOA = -2.0
-35 AOA = 6.0
[ --,_-AOA = 0.0
-30 -25 i .
-20
[
-1,5 F -10 t _ " ! !
-05
i
0.5 •
i
i 1.0 15 .... : -01 00 01 0,2 03 0.4 0.5 06 0,7 08 09 1.0 0.1 0.2 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
-130 -130 - - - -125 L I --.o-- AOA = 140, -125 __ - ........ --e-AOA = 8.0 . . - --I--AOA = 160.
-12.0
.12o_-1 2 _- : _ _: _-,,-AO._=1oo
i ....... --:,e- AOA : 180 -115 -115 :- --,',-AOA = 12.0 -110 -110 E .......
-10.5 -105 [ ........
-100 i ...........
-lO.O_- - -
............
-95 -95 : ...........
-9.0 -9_0 _ .....
-85 -8.5 i ........
-80 -8.0 L ............. i T ..........
-75 -7.5 ! ...........
-7.0 -70 ......
-65 il_ - i .... -6.5
-60 -60 - _ .........
-55 -55 -50
-5o i
-45 -45
i
-40 -40 i -3.5 i -35 I -3.0 -3.0 : -2.5 -25 E-
!
-20 _ '_ -2.0 -15 -15 ,_ -1.0
-10
-0.5 -05 0.5
00_- I _ o5_
15 ! .............................
15 .............
05 06 07 08 09 10 -0 1 00 01 02 03 0A 0.5 0.6 0 7 08 09 1.0 -01 00 0.1 0 2 03 04
NASA/TP--2000-210031 231
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 704, Ma = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10^6
-4.0 .....
-,4,0 _ --- -_ T T 7 -.e-- AOA = 2.0
i i --e- AOA = -4.0
--I-AOA = 40
' _ __ __L ! I -m-AOA -2.0
-3.5 _ I ---- AOA = 0.0 AOA = 6,0
i !
-3.0
-30 _ _ ' ' i i
-2,5 -3.5 I -25 -2.0 -1.5 -
! !
i i
-10 -05 0.0 0.5
l i
F 4--- __.__ i !
i 1
1.5 .- • -01 O0 0.1 0.2 03 04 0.5 0.6 07 0.8 0.9 10 -01 00 01 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 06 0.7 0,8 09 10 XIC
x#¢
-11.0 -11.0 !: ! " I ___ --e-AOA = 8.0 -10,5 i I I -'e-- AOA = 140i ' -m-AOA = 10.0 -I0,0 1 -105 _t !
-10.0 : f _ ---i-AOA = 160' I -9.5 _- i -"_-IAOA = 12.0
i
F -9,5
i
-9.o E-
i I i ----_ +--_+__ -9.0
i I '
i
-85 -8.5 :_-
I
J ! i -80 _: -8.0 L
I I i _ ,: --I i
i
, , I I -7,5 i-- _' 4 I- -75 F--- i ' I
i
-7.o ! !
-7.0 : ' I -6.5 i _ __ ,
' ' i
-65 i---
!
-6.o
-6.0 .: - -5.5 i- i
' i
-50 I i
!
-45 ]- -" -40 -3,5 -3.0 -2.5 i....
-20 I -15 -10 i -0,5 0.0 0.5
i .... i
1.5 : -0.1 00 01 0,2 0.3 04 0.5 06 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 -0.1 0.0 0 1 0.2 0,3 04 0.5 0,6 07 08 0.9 1,0
232 NASA/TP_2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Clean Model (cont.)
Run 705, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
-35 ............
-35 .... w - -- _ ....
-.e-- AOA : ..4.0 -I--AOA = 40
-e- AOA = -2.0
-30 _ " " _ .... --_-- AOA = 60
-30 - ' --:,*- AOA = 0.0
i [ , -e.- AOA = 20
i
-25 -25 ' • * * - * t •
" i i
i
-2o _ i " ..... v
-20 - - -
-1 5 -1.5 • - _ - • .
8 -lO ..... _ .....
-05 -05 _ 05 - 05 10 ...... 1.0 ............
I 15 - --- • - - " .....
-01 00 01 02 03 0.4 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 0.4 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
-120 - .............
-115 [ ...... --e-- AOA = 140, ; ]i_ , -I-- AOA = 160 : -110_100.10.5 _ t I_ _ _[ " ; . --_-- AOA = 180 -9.5 : _ ---_ -- t ......
-9.0 [ i : * ; _ -8.5 -70-75-8,0 [ .... ! ....
-65 -60 -55 _ - _ ........
-50 -45 -40 -35 -30 -25 -15 -10 -05
05 : , , _ ---_ -
-01 00 01 02 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
NAS A/TP--2000-2 i 0031 233
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA)
Ice Shape formed at:
T_ = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Ts = -5.0°C (22.0°F)
MVD = 20 p.m
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
006 ,
J
r
J
J
0 04 Smoothed Ice Shape
y
-- NLF-0414 0o0 -006 -005 0 15 020 0 25 005 x,_c 010 2O --T 20_ T ....... -- --
V
_m-Re=3xl0^6 :
Ma = 0.12 Re = 6.4x10^6 --m--Ma=0 12
--*-- Ma=0.21 I _o__Re=6.4xl0^ 6
--i--Re=lOxlO^6 ! i i -,,- Ma=029
[ i
i i i
i i
i l I '
i
i
F
05 i j
-05 _- _-- i .... I ...... !
-100 -50 00 50 100 150 200 100 -50 00 50 100 150 20D Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
234 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
20-- 20- + -l--Re=4.6x10^6 _Re=64x10^6
Ma = io.21 Ma = .05
-.--..--Re = 8.1x10^6
Re = lx10^6
i
__._Re=10xl0^6 i -.e--Re = 12x10^6
i
_5 ....
15+ +
t
{
J O 10+ ....
'3
_3
o
++
,oi!!! !!!!!
O0 t +o 5 ............................
-05 ............... _ .........
-100 -50 0o 50 100 150 200 -100 -50 00 50 1013 150 200 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
Drag Coefficients, cd
o+= -2.0 (z = 0.0 o_= 2.1 o_= 4.2 o_= 6.2
0.0235 0.0181 0.0234 0.0395 0.0589
Run 101, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
0.0931
0.0249 0.0528
0.0096
0.0096
Run 102, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6
0.0373 0.0657 0.1039
0.0203 0.0215
Run 103, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
0.0204 0.0499 0.0885
0.0064 0.0055
Run 105, Ma = 0.21, Re = 12x10^6
0.0969
0.0137 0.0137 0.0292 0.0576
Run 106. Ma = 012, Re = 6.4x10^6
0.0127 0.0095 0.0246 0.0543 0.0950
Run 107, Ma = 0.21, Re = 8.1x10^6
0.0166 0.0289 0.0588 0.0997 0.0139
Run 108, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
0.0820
0.0430
0.0168 0.0134 I 0.0057
IRun 109, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
0.0292 0.0323 0.0439 0.0663 0.1016
Run 111, Ma = 0.29. Re = 6+4x10^6
0.0078 0.0069 0.0062 J 0.0058 0.0058
Run 112, Ma = 0.05, Re = lx10*6
Italicized font indicates force balance data
NASA/TP--2000-210031 235
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 101, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
-20 0.0 i o.o
; i
lO i i
i !
15 ........ J L -0.1 O0 01 0.2 0,3 04 05 0,6 07 08 09 1.0 x/c
x/c
-30 -3.0 ....
-e-AOA = 4.0 --e- AOA = 8.0 AOA = 10.0 -2.5 -2,0 i I ; !
i i -1.5 I -10 -0.5 00 - O,5 -- 10 ...........
-01 0,0 01 02 03 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 08 09 10
x/c
X/C
236 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 102, Ma = 0.21, Re - 10x10^6
-3.5 ......
-e--AOA = 0.0 -I- AOA = 2.0 -30 .......
-2.5 " -2,0 -15 _10 -05 0.0 . i 05 - t - 05 j i ) !
loi I
i
i 15 L , : .............
-0.1 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
-30 ............
-e- AOA = 8.0 AOA = 10.0 ........ + .
-25 , l -20 -1.0 00 !
0.5 10 ..... _ ...............
10 ........
-0t 0.0 0.1 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 0.1 0,2 03 0,4 05 06 0.7 0.8 09 1 0
xlc X/C
NASA/TP--2000-210031 237
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 103, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
O5 15 .... .
-01 OD 0 1 02 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 08 09 1 0
x/c
x/c
-3.0
I f' : i
i i
-2o L !
J i
-15 -10 -05 0.0 i
i
L
1.0 .... ± .... '_ ..... I -0.1 0.0 01 02 03 04 0.5 0.6 07 0.8 09 1.0 -0_1 O0 0.1 0.2 03 04 0.5 06 0+7 0.8 0.9 10
xlc
x/¢
238 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 105, Ma = 0.21, Re - 12x10^6
-35 ' - ...... : '. --e-- AOA = 0.0 AOA = 2.0 -30 L ...........
-25 ; .
-20 , r
-is !
,_10
[
-05 -05 r L L 0.0 -- QO 1.5 _..................
15 I ............... : . .
-01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 1,0
x/c
x/¢
-30 .......... _ " -e-- AOA = 8.0 -_-AOA = 10.0 -25 ...................
-20 .............
-15 -10 -0.5 05 .
10 10 ............
-01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 0.8 09 10 -0"1 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 0.7 08 09 1.0
x/c
x/¢
NASA/TP--2000-210031 239
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 106, Ma = 0.12, Re = 6.4x10^6
-3.0 . -.m- AOA = -2.0 -25 ....
t -.e- AOA = -4.0 _ 2 _ 0 l_ • T ...... _ • - [-----T i -1.0 -05 0,0 0.0 0.5 t.0 t5 ..................
-0.1 0,0 0.1 02 03 04 0.5 0,6 0.7 08 09 1.0 X/¢
x/c
-30 ! : +AOA : 8,0 --m- AOA = 10.0 ! -2.5 -2,0
i
i -1,5 _ -1.0 -0,5 0.0 0,5 1,0 .... i -0.1 00 0.1 02 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 x/c X/C
240 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 107, Ma = 0.21, Re = 8.1x10^6
i I : i 15 ........................
-0 1 oo 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 1 0
xlc
x/c
+0 5 10 ......................
-0+1 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 0,7 08 0.9 10 XIC
xlc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 241
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 108, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
I 05 F
I
I
i -0.1 0,0 0.I 0.2 03 04 0,5 0.6 0.7 08 09 1.0 -01 0,0 01 02 0.3 0.4 05 06 07 0.8 0.9 1,0
x/c
x/¢
-3.0 -e- AOA = 8.0 AOA = 10.0 -2.0 -2.5 ---i -1.5 -10 -05 0.0 0.5 1.0 -01 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0,7 0.8 09 1,0 -01 00 01 02 0.3 0.4 05 0.6 07 0.8 09 10 X/¢
x/e
242 NASA/TP-----2000-21003I
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 109, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
-2.5 ...........
i --e-- AOA = 0.0 --u-AOA = 2.0 -20 -15 -10 t,%5 0.5 ........
10 _ _ .......
15 ' - _ .................
1.5 ...... i ..................
-01 0.0 01 0.2 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 0.5 0,6 07 08 09 10
x/¢
x/c
-25 _ -.e- AOA = 8.0 --I-AOA = 10.0 -20 _ _ -- i + - ; ........
-1.o --- -- -05 I O0 O5
oo
10 ............ i .......
-01 0.0 01 0.2 03 04 0 5 06 07 08 0.9 10 -0.1 00 01 02 03 0.4 0.5 06 07 08 0.9 10 _C
x/c
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 243
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 111, Ma = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10^6
-3,5 -o--AOA = 0,0 -!- AOA = 2.0 -3,0 ..........
-25 - - -2.0 _....
-20 - -15 -15 -1.0 _1.0 -05 -05 [ 0,0 0.0 0_5 i
i i
1.0
, i i i i _
i
: !
15 _ ,-J 1.5 _ .... - .......
-0,1 0.0 0,1 0.2 0.3 04 0,5 06 07 08 0.9 10 -0.1 0,0 0.1 0.2 0,3 0.4 0,5 06 0 7 08 0.9 10
x/¢
x/c
-,o-- AOA = 8.0 -I-AOA = 10.0
-25 _
i i -20
._ii ! '
i '
I -1,5 _ -1 0 -0.5 -0.5
L
L i 0.0 - 0.0 I 05 i
i ' i
i !
i
!
i i
[ , i
1.0 _ i -0.1 00 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0,5 06 0.7 08 0,9 10 -01 00 0.1 0.2 0,3 0.4 05 0.6 0,7 0.8 09 10
x/c
X/C
244 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 112, Ma = 0.05, Re = lx10^6
-1.5 ....
-15 .........
---e- AOA = 0.0 -e-AOA = -4.0 AOA = 2.0 : _ AOA = -2.0 -1.0 I ..... _ _ * -05 - 00 L 0.5 1.0 15 ' • ' ' ......
"01 00 01 0.2 03 04 05 06 0.7 08 09 10
x/¢
-2,0 .................
-20 - '-e-AOA = 4.0 -e-- AOA : 8.0 !
AOA = 6.0 : ---m- AOA : 10.0 -15 .... _- .......
-05 -10 __ 05 --- 05 O0 _ 10 -- t " -- " " 10 •
i
15 ....................
-01 00 0.1 02 03 04 0.5 06 07 0.8 09 10 -01 O0 01 02 03 04 05 06 0 7 08 09 1 0
x/c
X/¢
NASA/TP--2000-210031 245
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting)
Ice Shape formed at:
T_ = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
T_ = -5.0°C (22.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o o6 J 0 o4
30" Tracing
-- NLF-0414
ooo
!
o 02 004 .
-0 06 / -005 000 005 OX_c0 0 15 020 025 2G_ ,.-,.m--Re=3xl0^6
Ma_0.12 _ Re = 6.4x10^6 i -l--Ma=0.12
i "-t-Re=6.4xl0^6 i "--'*-- Ma=0.21
I
i I
i--,i--Re=10xl0^6 Ma=0.29 I i , , 15 _ 15 _----_ _ _ _ i
I
I I
i 1
C "3 o (,.)
i
i .... : -05 -10(3 -50 00 5O 100 150 20O -100 50 00 50 100 150 20(3 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
246 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
20T _ - - 20 .......
--_-Re=4.6x10^6
Ma = ,05
Ma =i0.21 --o-- Re=6.4x 10^6
--,--Re=10xl0^6
Re = lx10^6
i 15_ - 15 ......
10 ........
,{
'_ 05 - - 00 / ....
00- -05 ........................
-05 + ......... + ....
-100 -50 00 50 100 150 200 150 200 -100 -50 oo 50 100 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
Drag Coefficients, cd
L
c_= 6.2
c_= 0.0 o_= 4.2
c_= -2.0
_ c_= 2.1
i 0.0351
Run 201, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6 0.0353 0.0271 0.0584 0.1041
Run 202, Ma = 0.12, Re = 64x10^6 0.0350 0.0267 0.0349 0.0593 0.1049
1Run 203, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6 0.0349 0.0263 0.0348 0.0605 i 0.1203
O.0407 O.0389 O.0559 O.0559 O. 1296
Run 204, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
0,0586 i 0.1222
0.0273
0.0272 0.0164
Run 207, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
Run 208, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6 0.0319 0.0237 0.0317 0.0558 0.0956
Run 210, aa = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10^6 0.0442 0.0441 0.0553 0.0811 0.1250
Run 211, aa = 0.05, Re = lx10^6 0.0099 0.0090 [ 0.0082 0.0076 0.0072
Italicmed font indicates force balance data
NASA/TP--2000-210031 247
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 201, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
i
15 ........
-0.1 0.0 01 02 0.3 04 05 06 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 -0,1 O0 0 1 02 0 3 04 05 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
x/¢ XJC
-2.0 -15 r -1 .o L 1,0 L
i
i 15 [
! i
-01 00 0.1 02 03 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 08 0.9 10 }r J6 X/C
248 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 202, Ma = 0.12, Re = 6.4x10^6
-2.0 .... _ .....
-20 _ ..... : - - -- --e- AOA = 0.0 i --- AOA : -4.0 i i -_-AOA = -2.0 -m- AOA = 20 !
i -15 ' - -15 _ i ...........
[ -10 -10 _- i
-05 45 !
0,0 0.0 - L ....
05 0.5 - i 1.0 _- 10 _ - 15 -- - _ • _ .............
15 ....................
-0 1 00 0.1 02 03 04 0.5 06 0 7 0.8 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 0.4 0.5 06 07 08 09 10
x/c x/c
-2.0 -2.0 -15 -10 -05 0.0 0.5
i i
10 1.0 _. _ i _ +
1,5 ............ 1.5 __L . _
-01 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 07 08 0 g I 0 -01 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 X/C
x/c
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 249
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 203, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6
-20 -2.0 - - - ,I !' li ---e- AOA = .-410 --e-- AOA = 0,0 AOA = -2.0 --_- AOA = 2.0
-15 L- -1.5 i
!
! I i i
-1.0 -1.0 -0,5
a
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 .......................
-0.1 9.0 01 02 03 04 65 06 07 08 69 10 X/C xlc -2.0 -2.0 _--- _ T i -e- AOA = 8.0 i --i-AOA = 10.0 4.....
i -0,5
a
O5 I -61 0.0 01 02 0,3 04 0,5 06 0.7 0,8 09 10 yet Y-JC
250 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 204, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
-20 ......... • -- -- AOA = -4.0 -l- AOA = -2.0 -1.5 ............
-1 o J m t _ • . : . . i
i
oo- - i i
I
- i , i
05. _ .... _ • . - i r I
J
1.0 tb; ...........
1.0
i
1.5 ........ ..... J ....
15 ...............
-0.1 0.0 0.1 02 03 0.4 05 06 07 08 0.9 10 -01 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 1.0
x/c x/c
-25 .......... - -e--AOA = 8.0 r --m-AOA = 10.0 -20 _ ' -- + r i, -15 lr_ : i : -10 _ t_ -0.5
oo _i
05 - ; -+ .........
i i i : i i
!
' i i 1.5 - _ ........ ! .........
-01 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 yJc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 251
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 207, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
-2.0 -20 T- AOA = -4.0 I ! .-m.- AOA = -2.0
i i
-1.5 -15 ' i
i
i
-1.0 -0.5 O0 0.0 i
!
r
15' -0.1 00 01 0,2 03 04 0.5 06 07 0.8 09 1.0 -0.1 00 01 02 0.3 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 1,0
x/c
x/e
-2.5 -1.0
i
I
! I
! I
I
I
-0.1 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
)de
xl¢
252 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 208, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
-25 ........
-25 -e- AOA : 0.0 .-_-- AOA = ...4.0 AOA : 2.0 AOA = -2.0 -20 -15 ......
-1.0 -0.5 O5
o oi
10 .............
-01 0.0 0 1 02 0 3 0.4 0.5 0.6 07 08 09 1.0
xlc
-2.5 ..... _ -2.5 , ..... _ -- i -.e.- AOA = 4.0 -e- AOA : 8.0 -u-AOA = 6.0 -a- AOA : 10.0 -20 - - -20 _ _ .... _ .......
-15 _ ..... --- -- -1.5 _,
ifill
-05 L -05 -1000 :L_!:'_i -_ 0.5 _ ..... T - • - _ I 05 4 .........
i i 10 1.0 ........ ± • " - * -01 00 01 02 03 04 0.5 06 0.7 0.8 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 1 0
x/c
x/c
NASA/TP--2000-210031 253
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 210, Ma = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10^6
-20 -2.0
i
O0 0.5 _ i F ' --i ....
1.0 --4 --/ 15 .... _ , L ..............
-0.1 0.0 0 1 0.2 0.3 0.4 05 06 0.7 0.8 0.9 10
x/c
xlc
yJc
254 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 623-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 211, Ma = 0.05, Re = lx10^6
-20 .......
+ AOA = -4.0 -e- AOA : 0.0 -l- AOA : 2.0 --m- AOA = -2.0 -15 -15 ........ - -1.0 .
-1.0 ..........
;, .... ....
-05 -05 0.0 1 05 ;
o l_io i
10 ! i .......
15 ..................
15 ................. : -0.1 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 04 05 06 07 0.8 09 1.0 -01 0.0 01 0.2 03 04 05 0.6 07 08 09 "10
x/c
x/c
-20 ..........
-e--AOA = 8.0 --m- AOA = 10.0 -15 .............
i -10 ........
i -05 _ r 1.0 1,5 L_-- J . - - 1.5 ..................
-0.1 00 0.1 0.2 03 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/¢
xlc
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 255
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA)
Ice Shape formed at:
T, = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Ts = -5.0°C (2ZO°F)
MVD = 20 !um
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
o 06 o 04 Smoothed Ice Shape -- NLF-0414 o oo -002 o04 -006 ....
-005 015 020 025 000 005 x/c 010 2.0
: i
I --m--Re=3xl0^6 --m-Ma=0.12
Ma =!0,12 Re = 6.4x10^6
i --t--Re=6,4xlO^6 --s--Ma=0.21 i --_--Re=10xl0^6 _Ma=029 15 --- 15 I --- l i i i 05 i L
O0 _- i i-
i I
i i
I
F -051 .... , i .... i -0.5 i i i I ....
-100 50 O 0 50 100 150 200 -100 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 Angle of A_ack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
256 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
20 ....
Re=4 6x10^6
Ma = .05
I Ma = 0.21 --o--Re=64x10^6
r
--,p.- Re= 10x10^6 Re = lx10 ^
15 .
c o 00_--
i
-0 5 .................. * ..........
150 200 -I0 0 -5 0 00 50 100 -10 0 -5 0 oo 5 0 10 0 15 0 20 0
Angle of Attack, deg
Angle of Attack, deg
Drag Coefficients, c_
i (z = -2.0 cz = 0.0 oc= 2.1 (z = 4.2 c_= 6.2
Run 301, aa = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6 0.0134 0.0120 0.0134 0.0175 0.0242
Run 302, Ua = 0,12, Re = 6.4x10^6 0.0104 0,0089 0.0104 0.0148 0.0363
'_Run 304, aa = 0.29, Re = 6,4x10^6 0.0158 0.0t 39 0.0157 0.0213 0.0306
Run 306, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10xl 0^6 0.0129 0.0108 0.0134 0.0205 0.0323
Run 307, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6 0.0137 0.0113 0.0143 0.0226 0.0362
Run 308, Ma = 0,12, Re = 3x10^6 0.0159 0.0135 0.0164 0.0246 0.0379
Run 309, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6 0.0303 0.0170 0.0165 ! 0.0293 0.0528
!
Run 310, Ma = 0.05, Re = lx10^6 0.0062 0.0047 i 0.0039 i 0.0038 0.0040
Italicized font indicates force balance data
NASA/TP--2000-210031 257
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 301, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
-40 ......
i !
i [I '
-01 00 01 02 0.3 04 05 0.6 07 0.8 09 10
x/c
-0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 05 0.6 0,7 08 0.9 10 -0.1 0.0 01 02 0.3 0.4 05 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1,0
x/c
xl¢
258 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 302, Ma = 0.12, Re- 6.4x10^6
-3.0 .......
-e-AOA = -4.0 --m- AOA = -2.0 -2.5 .......
-2.0 -01 O0 0.1 0.2 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 1 0
x/c x/c
-25 -2.0 -- -1.5 -- -- -1.0 -0.5 -0.5 I 0.0 0.5 -0.1 O0 01 02 0.3 04 0.5 06 0,7 08 09 10 -0.1 0,0 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 0.7 0.8 09 10
x/c
x/¢
NASA/TP--2000-210031 259
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 304, Ma = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10"6
i
i '
i
i-!
I
I yJo yJc i i
I
i
_._i 1,5 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 0,5 0.6 07 0.8 0.9 10 yJc YJC
260 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 306, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6
-3.5 -35 ...........
r ---e- AOA = 0.0
-e-AOA = -4.0
AOA = -2.0 ..... -I--AOA = 2.0
-3.0 -30 [ ......
• i
-2.5 -20 -20 , .... i _ .........
I
a -1o a -1o
00 00 05 05
-o5 __ -o5
lo t • lo
i
15 ..... : .......... " • 15 .................
-01 00 01 02 0.3 04 05 0.6 07 0.8 O9 10 -01 0.0 01 02 03 O4 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c x/c
-6.0 ........
-6.0 .......
-e--AOA : 8.0 : ---e-AOA = 4.0 -55 - -- - % .....
-55 ....
-I- AOA = 6.0 -50 _ ..... --,_---AOA = 12.0 -5.0 L ........
-45 - _ ........
-4.5 i - .- -4.0 _ _ _ i _ - - " -40 E .........
-35 - _ .... _ - - ' -35 : .....
-30 -30 - - t -- - -- i Ill _ • .......
_ 2 5
a
-20 -20 i 7 _ ........
-15 : -25 i -"10 - + .....
-05 _ O0 -15 _L 0.5 15 .....................
15 .................
-0.1 0 O 0 1 02 0.3 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 "1 0 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 &7 08 09 1.0 xJ¢ XJC
NASA/TP--2000-210031 261
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 307, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
-1.5 -10 i _k ....
-0,5 0.0 0.0
i
i
1.0 - - o 1_0 .......
-01 00 01 02 0.3 0,4 05 06 07 08 0.9 1.0 -0'1 00 01 0.2 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 0.9 1.0
x/¢
x/c
-5.0 !--e-AOA = 4.0 i -4.5 ....
!-_-AOA = 6.0 !
i '
i i i
-40 ! ---
: i ! : i
I i
-35 _-- -3,0 F n_ J -2.5 _ I 0.0 10 t i I i
: ! !
1.5 ' -- ......... =--.. i J I -01 O0 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1,0 -01 0,0 0.1 0.2 03 04 0.5 0.6 07 08 0,9 10
x/c
xlc
262 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 308, Ma - 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
-20 ........
-e-AOA = -4.0 -m- AOA = -2.0 -10 .......
O0 05 ....
05 ; 1.0 ....
1.0 ....................
-01 00 0.1 0.2 03 04 05 06 07 0.8 09 10 -01 0.0 0 1 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
xlc x/¢
-25 -20 -20 -1.5 -1.0 -- -10 [ [ -0.5 -05 0.0 O0
x/c
x/c
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 263
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 309, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
-20 .......
-e-- AOA = -4.0 -l- AOA = -2.0 -1 5 I = -10 • _ -- -05 0.0 O5 0.5 4 --_ _ ........
i
10 .........
-0.1 0.0 01 0.2 03 0,4 0.5 0.6 0 7 08 0.9 1.0 -01 00 0.1 02 03 04 0.5 0.6 07 0.8 09 t 0
xlc
x/c
-5.0 -5.0 ] i I ' -e-AOA = 4.0 1 -4.5 , - i _ -=-AOA = 6.0
F i
k
-4.o ! ...... !
i -35 _ - -3.5
: i
i -3.0 -3.0
i i
: !
-25 ! ...... -2.5
I
-20
a
-t.5 -1,0 -05 0,0
I
I _ i 0.5 1.0 1.5 -0.t 0.0 0.1 02 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 08 0.9 1.0 -01 00 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 05 06 07 0.8 0.9 1_0
xlc
xlc
264 NASA/TP---2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 310, Ma = 0.05, Re = lx10^6
-3.0 -30 ..... : - • • --e- AOA = 0,0 : -e- AOA = -4.0 AOA = 2.0 -e- AOA = -2.0 -2.5 _ _ -
i
-25 I .........
-20 i _ - - * ....
: i
-2.0 _ i I
/
-1.5 -15
a
-10 -1.0 -05 -0.5 i O0 0.0 05 ..................
05 ....................
-01 00 0,1 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 0.0 01 0.2 03 04 05 06 07 0.8 09 10
xlc
x/c
-2.0 -1.5 -I.0 -05
0.0
0.5 _ ..................
-01 00 01 02 03 0.4 0.5 06 07 0.8 09 10
x/c
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 265
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting)
Ice Shape formed at:
T_ = -2.8°C (26.4°F) LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
T, = -5.0°C (22.0°F)
MVD = 20 #m
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts) Spray = 22.5 min
AOA = 0.3 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
J
30" Tracing
/
OO2
i
-004 i { 006 ..................................
-005 000 005 010 O 15 020 025 X/C 2.0 • ' T " L --al--Re=3xl0^6 Ma=0,12
Ma = 0.12
.--e.--Re=64x10^6 Ma=021 ..-,_.--Re=10xl0^6 Ma=029 1.5
! -
{
1.0 L } !
0.0 0.0 {
{
-0.5 4 -0.5 _ ..... $ ....... _ ......... _ .....
-100 -5.0 0.0 5.0 100 150 20.0 -100 -50 0,0 50 100 15 0 200 Angle of Attack, deg AngleefAt_ck, deg
266 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
20 ......
20 ...... _ " -4- Re=4 6 x 10"6
Ma = .05
Ma = 0.21 .___Re=64x10^6
Re = 1x10A6
--,_-- Re=10xl0^6 { i 15 ......
_st .....
{
{
i i O ,,.t 01o ¢
E 8
O5 O0 00_ - --
i
i : i -05 ............................
-100 -50 00 50 100 _50 200 -05 ........................... J -100 -50 O0 50 100 450 200 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
Drag Coefficients, Cd
c_= -2.0 o_= 0.0 c_= 2.1 o_= 4.2 { o_= 6.2
!Run401, Ma = 0,12, Re= 10x10^6 0.0170 0.0133 0.0178 0.0305 0.0511
IRun402, Ma = 0.12, Re= 6.4x10^6 0.0183 0.0143 0.0188 0.0316 0.0528
Run403, Ma = 0.21. Re= 4.6x10^6 0,0179 0.0138 0.0185 0.0317 0.0530
Run404, Ma = 0.29, IRe= 6.4x10^6 0.0197 0.0156 L 0.0200 i 0.0329 0.0542
Run406, Ma = 0.21, Re= 10x10^6 0.0173 0.0132 0.0180 0.0316 0.0541
Run407, Ma = 0.21, Re = 64x10^6 0.0184 0.0t42 0.0189 0.0321 0.0541
0.0198 0.0158 0.0201 0.0327 0.0532
Run 409, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
0.0030
0,0029 0.0026 0.0026
0.0033
Run 410, Ma = 0.05, IRe = lx10^6
Italicized font indicates force balance data
NASA/TP--2000-21003I 267
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 401, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
-2.5 ............ -2.5 ..... _ ........
[--- • ---e- AOA = -4.0 i
i_ AOA = -2.0
AOA = 2,0 I -e- AOA = 0.0
i i
-20 -20 ............
i !
i
i I i -1.5 -15 .............
; !
-1.0 _ .............
-05 00 _ 10 .................
-0,1 00 0,1 0.2 0.3 04 05 0.6 07 0.8 0.9 10 yJc
xlc
-35 -- -3.0 r 0.0 0.0
o.5 _ I
1.0 _ I -0.1 0.0 01 0.2 03 0.4 05 06 07 0.8 09 1.0 -01 0.0 01 02 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
xl¢
xlc
268 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 402, Ma = 0.12, Re = 6.4x10^6
O0 10 --- 10 • - .
-01 00 01 0.2 0,3 04 05 06 07 08 09 1.0 -01 0,0 01 02 03 04 0,5 06 07 08 09 10
yJc xlc
-4.0 ......
-e-AOA = 8.0 -3.5 ' _ _ . -.I-AOA = 10.0 --:,,,-- AOA = 12.0 i -3.0 .... 4 ......
-2.5
-2.0
-1.5 - -1.0 _ - -
-0.5
0.0
0,5
lO i
1.5 - __ x -01 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 0.7 08 09 "10 yJc
x/c
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 269
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 403, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
-25 .... T T ..... _ .....
i -e-- AOA = 0.0 ! + AOA = 2.0 i i l -20 _ I -05 O0
: i
I -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 0.7 0.8 09 10 -01 00 0_1 0.2 03 04 0.5 06 0.7 08 09 10
x/¢
X/¢ -35 -3.0 -25 -2.0 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 05 06 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
x/c
x/c
270 NAS A/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 404, Ma = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10^6
-2.5 - - - ---e- AOA = -4.0 -I- AOA = -2.0 -2.0 - - -15 .......
O0 • [ / 15 _ . _ L ........
1.5 ...................
-0.1 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 0.8 09 1.0 -0 1 00 0 1 02 03 04 0 5 06 0 7 08 09 1 0
xlc
xJc -3.5 -3.0 i - - - -25 _ - -20 -15 -10 -05
0.0
1.0 1.5- ................
-01 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 04 05 0.6 07 0.8 09 10
xlc
x/c
NASA/TP--2000-210031 271
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 406, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6
-2.5 - -- -.e.- AOA = -4.0 "-_- AOA = -2.0 -2.0 -1.5 -1.0 -1,0 -05 0.0 0.5 0.5' + J 10 4
i
i i
1.5 .................
-0.1 00 0,1 02 0.3 04 05 06 0.7 08 09 1.0 -01 00 01 02 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 YJc
x/c
-4.0 -3.0 -2.5 -2.0 -1.5 -1.0
-o.5 F--
0.0 _- i I I 0.5 1.0
i
1.5 -01 0,0 01 0.2 03 04 0.5 0,6 07 0.8 0.9 10 -0,1 0.0 0,1 0,2 0,3 0.4 05 0,6 0,7 0.8 09 1.0 YJc
xl¢
272 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 407, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
-25 - _ ......
-2.5 - ...... _ - - " q
'_ ! !-e-AOA = -4.0 ! '
--l- AOA = 2.0
AOA = -2.0 J
i l "201 [ i ....
--e-- AOA = 0.0 -1 5 ....
-15 t ....
i
-10 ; -1 0
_-05 1
- - 0 5 I
[
00 -- i i i lO 10 " • '
i
15: .....................
-01 0.0 01 0.2 03 04 05 06 07 08 0.9 1.0 -01 0.0 01 02 03 04 0.5 06 07 0.8 09 10
XJC x/c
-4.0 _ .....
--e- AOA = 8.0
ii-ii
-1.0
I
-0.5
0.0
0.0
!
0.5
i i i 1.0 '-- i : i ! , i I 15 .........
1.5 ....... J ....
-01 00 01 02 0.3 0.4 0.5 0,6 0.7 08 09 10 -01 00 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 0.7 0.8 09 1.0
xlc
x/c
NASA/TP--2000-210031 273
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 409, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
-10 II -10
-o.5 ,3-o5
i
l
1,5 1.5 -01 00 0.1 0.2 03 0.4 05 06 07 0.8 09 1.0 -01 0.0 01 02 03 0.4 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/¢
x/¢
-4.0
!
-e-AOA = 4.0
-35
!-_-AOA = 6.0 -
i
i
-3.0 -25 -20 -1.5 -t 0 -0.5 0.0
0.0
-0.1 00 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 07 0.8 09 10 -0 1 O0 0 1 0.2 0.3 04 05 06 0 7 08 09 1.0
xlc
xlc
274 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 622-3D (Casting) (cont.)
Run 410, Ma = 0.05, Re = lx10^6
- - T .....
-2+5 , - -2+5 -e-- AOA = 0.0
--e- AOA = -4.0
AOA = 2.0
-m- AOA = -2.0
-20 + + -20 - -
'i
-1.5 -15 .......
-10 -10 -05 -05 00 00 05 05 10 . i ..................
1.0 .................
-01 0+0 01 02 03 04 0.5 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
xlc
_/C -10 • -0,5 i -0,5 ,
0.0 0.0 ! , -- " _
1.0 _ ...... L .....
-01 0.0 01 0.2 03 0+4 0.5 06 07 08 09 10 yJc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 275
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA)
Ice Shape formed at:
Tt = -2.8°C (26.4°F)
LWC = 0.54 g/m 3
Ts = -5.0°C (22.0°F)
MVD = 20 pm
V = 66.9 m/s (130 kts)
Spray = 2.0 min
AOA = 0.4 °
chord = 90 cm (36 in)
{ 006 - { 004 *
i
Smoothed Ice Shape
-- NLF-0414
000 - L 4) o2 { -004 i 4) 06 -005 000 005 0 10 0 15 O2O O25 X/C 2_0 .......
i H_ 20 [ _ --_-Re=3xl0^6 L Ma=0 12
I Re = 6.4x10^6
+Re=64x10^6
I Ma=0.12 --o-Ma=021
L _Re=10xl0^6 ---_--Ma=0.29 { ] 1.5
15 i I
.,..- t_
i
-0.5 -10.0 -5.0 0,0 50 100 15.0 00 5.0 100 150 20.0 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
276 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
20 _ - ....
20 .....
+ Re=46x 10^6 Ma = 0.21 ,
Ma = .05
Re=64x10^6
Re = lx10^6
--,_-- Re= 10x10*6 I 15 - 1.5- i , . , 0 1.0+ _. 1.0 C "5 "5 I o -i
/
0.0 0.0 - - - -0.5; .............. _ ..............
-05 -100 -50 00 50 100 150 200 -10.0 -50 0.0 50 10.0 150 200 Angle of Attack, deg Angle of Attack, deg
Drag Coefficients, cd
{ e_= -2.0 o_= 0.0 e_= 2.1 i o, = 4.2 _ = 6.2
Run 501,Ma = 0.12, Re= 10x10^6 0.0104 0.0092 0.0104 0.0141 0.0200
Run 502,Ma = 0.12, Re= 6.4x10^6 0.01 38 0.0125 0.0135 i 0.0160 0.0209
Run 503,Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6 0.0114 0.0101 0.0113 0.0151 0.0213
Run 504,Ma = 0.21, Re= 4.6x10^6 0.0181 0.0166 0.0171 0.0198 0.0247
Run 505,Ma = 0.29, Re= 6.4x10^6 0.0172 0.0153 0.0162 0.0197 0.0258
Run 507, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6 0.0154 0.0137 0.0145 0.0176 0.0232
Run 508,Ma = 0.12, Re= 3xl 0*6 0.0200 0,0183 0.0187 0.0212 0.0259
Run 510,Ma = 0.05, Re= lx10^6 0.0452 I 0.0361 0.0290 0.0241 0.0209
Italicized font indicates force balance data
NASA/TP--2000-210031 277
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 501, Ma = 0.12, Re = 10x10^6
O0
i i
: i i
i i
i
i i
[ i
i
I I
i i
10 ........
-01 0.0 01 02 0.3 04 05 0.6 07 08 09 10 -0,1 0.0 0.t 0,2 03 0.4 05 06 07 0.8 09 1,0 ]rJc _C -9.0 _ ........... _ -- : i -8.5 _ .......... _ .... -_--- --_--AOA = 10.0 -45 -40 f -3.5 -3.0 i ' ,_j ....
-2.5 -2.0 -1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 ........ r-- -! .....
E
1.5 -01 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 08 0.9 10 -0.1 0.0 0.1 02 03 04 05 0.6 0.7 0.8 09 1,0 YJC YJc
278 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 502, Ma = 0.12, Re = 6.4x10^6
0.0
x/c x/c
-9.0 i -e-AOA = 4.0 -85
i --m-AOA = 60
-8.0 .... ..-,,*-- AOA = 8.0 i .........
-75 -70 -65 -60 -5.5
F
-5.0 F -4.5 -40 -35 -3.0
i
L -2.5 -2.0 L -15 -1.0 -0.5
F
: !
0.0
05 F
1(:] i 1.5 ......
0.2 0.3 0.4 05 06 0.7 08 09 10 01 02 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 07 08 09 10 -01 0.0 01
x/c x/c
NAS A/TP--2000- 210031 279
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 503, Ma = 0.21, Re = 10x10^6
-2.0 -.e- AOA = 0.0 AOA = 2.0
!
I -15 -
!
I i -1.0 -05 0.0 0.5 1.0 ...............
-01 0.0 01 0,2 03 04 05 0,6 07 0.8 09 1.0 -0 1 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 0.8 0,9 1 0
x/¢
)dC -40 •: -3.5 [ -30 -25 -20 -- -15
i
-10 ; ....
i
-0,5 oo 0.5 -0,1 0,0 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 05 0.6 0.7 08 0.9 1.0 yJc
x/c
280 NASA/TP---2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 504, Ma = 0.21, Re = 4.6x10^6
-2.0 ........
-e- AOA = 0.0 -l- AOA = 2.0 -1.5 + ...... _ " ' i -I.0 --- O0
8 -o5
05 - ÷ " ; ' " _ T " " 0.5 !
10 '-- ................
-0.1 0.0 01 02 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 0.9 10 -0.1 0.0 01 02 03 04 05 06 0 7 0 8 09 10 X/C X/C
x/c
xlc
NASA/TP--2000- 210031 281
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 505, Ma = 0.29, Re = 6.4x10"6
-20
; i
! ' i
I -10
L i
, i
-o.5
0.0 XJC -6.5 -e- AOA = 4.0
-6o _ , ; -m- AOA = 6.0
--w- AOA = 8.0 i -55 _ ; -40
-35 ;--
-3.0 [ -25 -25 -2.0 -1.5 -1.0 0.0 0.0
i
0.5 0.5
1.0-- i I !
15 : ! I i
1.5 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 0,8 09 1.0 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 0.7 08 0.9 1.0
x/c
X/C:
282 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 507, Ma = 0.21, Re = 6.4x10^6
-20 .....
-e-- AOA = 0.0 AOA = 2.0 i I -15 I .......
-10 i i -- - ..........
-05
J
05 05 10 1_0 ...................
-01 00 0.1 02 03 0.4 0,5 0.6 07 08 09 1.0 -0 1 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
x/c
x/c
-85 -80 i -e-AOA = 10,0 ; -o-AOA = 12.0 ' -75 -70 .... ..--_--- A 0 A =14.0 -65 -6.0
t i
-5.5 -5.0 -45 -40 -35 -30 -25 -20 -15 i -10 -05 0.0 0.5 :
x/c
xlc
NAS A/TP--2000-210031 283
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 508, Ma = 0.12, Re = 3x10^6
r - -20 -2.0 _ i
I
I -'e'- AOA = ,,,4.0 -.e- AOA : 0.0 !
-m- AOA = -2.0 --m- AOA : 2.0 F -1.5 -15 i i I -1.0 I -05 0.0 0,5 10 .... _-- I 1.0 - - -0.1 0.0 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 06 07 0.8 0.9 10 -01 00 01 02 03 0,4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0,8 0.9 1 0 yJc
x/¢
i - I i -0.1 0,0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 09 10 -0.1 O0 01 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 07 08 0.9 10 X]C Y4/C
284 NASA/TP--2000-210031
LTPT
General Aviation - Ice Shape 621-2D (SLA) (cont.)
Run 510, Ma -- 0.05, Re = lx10^6
-20 ...........
-2.0 ..... [
-e-AOA = 0.0
--o- AOA = -4.0
--_-AOA = 2.0
-i- AOA = -2.0
-15 ,
l
L -10 i -05 ,_ -05 !
r L r i O0 i- 05 05 - 10 ................... 1.0 ......................
-01 00 0 1 02 0.3 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 -01 00 0 1 02 0.3 04 05 0.6 07 08 09 1.0
x/c
XJC -85 -85 i --e-- AOA = 4.0 -8.o i ........ --e-AOA = 10.0 -80
" + _ _ " " -I-AOA=6.0
-7,5 -_-AOA = 120 -7.5
: - -x-- AOA = 8.0
; --,x,-- AOA = 14.0 i -7o -70 -65 -65 ! : i -6o -6,0 i !
-55 +
-55
- -i- J ' 4 -1
-50 -5o i
-4.5 _ -4.5
......... _ .... J
-40 -40 -35 i -3.5 -3,0 -3.0 -2,5 -2.5 _- -20 !
-20 -15 -15 _ -10 -10 -05
-05 F
0.5 0.5 ' + "
oo_
10 i-- 15 _ . _ ....................
-0.1 0.0 01 02 03 0.4 0.5 06 0.7 0,8 0.9 1.0 XJC ydc
NASA/TP--2000-210031 285
REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE I Form Approved
OMB No. 0704-0188
I
Public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed+ and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send commenls regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington, VA 22202-4302, and to the Office of Management and Budget, Paperwork Reduction Project (0704-0188), Washington, DC 20503.
1. AGENCY USE ONLY (Leave blank) 2. REPORT DATE 3. REPORT TYPE AND DATES COVERED
April 2000 Technical Paper
: 4. TITLE AND SU_ I I t LE
5. FUNDING NUMBERS
Ice Accretions and Icing Effects for Modem Airfoils
WU-548-21-23-00
6. AUTHOR(S)
Harold E. Addy, Jr.
7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 8. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION
REPORT NUMBER
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
John H. Glenn Research Center at Lewis Field
E-12228
Cleveland, Ohio 44135-3191
9. SPONSORING/MONITORING AGENCY NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 10. SPONSORING/MONITORING
AGENCY REPORT NUMBER
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
NASA TP--2000-210031
Washington, DC 20546-0001
DOT/FAA/AR-99/89
11. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES
Responsible person, Harold E. Addy, Jr., organization code 5840, (216) 977-7467.
12a. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY STATEMENT
12b. DISTRIBUTION CODE
Unclassified - Unlimited
Subject Category: 02 Distribution: Standard
This publication is available from the NASA Center for AeroSpace Information, (301) 621-0390.
13. ABSTRACT (Maximum 200 words)
Icing tests were conducted to document ice shapes formed on three different two-dimensional airfoils and to study the effects of the accreted ice on aerodynamic performance. The models tested were representative of airfoil designs in current use for each of the commercial transport, business jet, and general aviation categories of aircraft. The models were sub- jected to a range of icing conditions in an icing wind tunnel. The conditions were selected primarily from the Federal Aviation Administration's Federal Aviation Regulations 25 Appendix C atmospheric icing conditions. A few large droplet icing conditions were included. To verify the aerodynamic performance measurements, molds were made of selected ice shapes formed in the icing tunnel. Castings of the ice were made from the molds and placed on a model in a dry, low-turbulence wind tunnel where precision aerodynamic performance measurements were made. Documentation of all the ice shapes and the aerodynamic performance measurements made during the icing tunnel tests is included in this report.
Results from the dry, low-turbulence wind tunnel tests are also presented.
14. SUBJECT TERMS
15. NUMBER OFPAGES
Aircraft icing: Aerodynamic characteristics
16. PRICE CODE
A13
17. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION
18. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION
19. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION
20. LIMITATION OF ABSTRACT
OF REPORT OF THIS PAGE
OF ABSTRACT
Unclassified Unclassified
Unclassified
NSN 7540-01-280-5500
Standard Form 298 (Rev. 2-89)
Prescribed by ANSI Std. Z39-18 298-102